5 ms·
Well, Sweden's 4:10000 death rate is alarming. In only a few months. And their confident approach (doing very little) in the face of scant information was bold.
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
Well, Sweden's 4:10000 death rate is alarming. In only a few months. And their confident approach (doing very little) in the face of scant information was bold. With lives at stake, its natural to be alarmed/scandalized at their lack of effort to control a pandemic.
- sojournerc 6y agoA pandemic cannot be controlled, only mitigated. That's what one part of the definition of epidemic vs. pandemic. What's alarming is that there isn't sympathy or discussion of the way lockdowns are putting lives at stake, when control of the virus is an illusion. It's natural to be alarmed at overly authoritarian responses, the justifications of which are diminishing as we get more information. Sweden, as far as I understand, is doing very little authoritarian intervention, but are providing thre public information so they can make their own choices with respect to risks they want to take.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoOf course there's discussion. All over. And the point of lockdown was, time. Time to understand what to do next. Now that's happening. The concern is all the idealism and absolutism thrown about, instead of measured intelligent discussion, IMO.
- graeme 6y agoBut several countries have basically eliminated the virus. SARS-COV-2 spreads in clusters. Tracing these clusters, testing people, and isolating patients seems to work. Neighboring Denmark is down to ~30 cases a day. Is it impossible to believe that with border control and testing they’ll basically have it eliminated on their territory? Countries which have basically eliminated it: Vietnam, Cambodia, Thailand, Australia, New Zealand, iceland, luxembourg, monaco, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Belize, China Also the Canadian provinces of new brunswick, nova scotia, newfoundland, PEI, Saskatchewan, Manitoba I’m sure I’m forgetting some. What do the countries in that list have in common? Yes some are islands but not all. Yes some are small but not all. For the most part, they took action early, and used contact tracing, testing, isolation, and border control systems. According to this article the small, poor country of Belize has outdone the province of Quebec, where I live. Belize developed a software based contact tracing system. Quebec still does it by fax. It is not a surprise which jurisdiction has better results. What’s your theory for how the systems built in these countries will inevitably fail? The virus is contagious but it isn’t magical. It has to spread from person to person. If you test people, isolate the infected, trace their contacts, the virus has nowhere to go. Most of the west is still not isolating the infected, instead sending them home to their families, and in many cases free to leave home if they decide to break quarantine. https://www.vancourier.com/living/government-of-belize-credits-ground-breaking-technology-for-halting-covid-19-1.24137140 https://www.vancourier.com/living/government-of-belize-credi...
- ApolloFortyNine 6y agoThe only virus ever to be eliminated globally is smallpox, and it took a vaccine to do so. Unless Vietnam, Cambodia, Thailand, Australia, New Zealand, iceland, luxembourg, monaco, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Belize, China plan on never reopening to the World, the virus will spread again. It's already been proven you can go from 1 case to full pandemic in 4 months.
- graeme 6y ago> It's already been proven you can go from 1 case to full pandemic in 4 months. When nobody was testing, and nobody was expecting it. Testing and tracing infrastructure will only get better, not worse. You won’t see cases in Hong Kong suddenly go from zero to thousands. > Unless Vietnam, Cambodia, Thailand, Australia, New Zealand, iceland, luxembourg, monaco, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Belize, China plan on never reopening to the World, the virus will spread again. I suspect they'll reopen with mandatory testing and isolation of travelers. Many of those countries already have varying versions of this. This will go until a vaccine exists. Then once a vaccine exists you’ll need proof of vaccination to enter. Tourism is nice for economies, but not being in lockdown and not paying the costs of an outbreak is even better. Why exactly will it be impossible for those countries to use this system for 1-2 years until a vaccine is ready? The alternative on offer in countries with outbreaks is hardly compelling. Perhaps we’ll discover a treatment in between that will make this unnecessary, but barring that the world may divide into cold zones and hot zones.
- dredds 6y agoIndeed. NZ & Aus exchange about 20% of each other's tourism in a regular year. Sometime in July we should see open borders across the ditch, saving a good number of jobs in travel and tourism sectors. Job subsidies have been timed to maximize this 'bounce back' economy as well. China, Singapore, and Qatar seem to have less-lethal strains if their recent numbers are to be believed. Perhaps in lieu of an early vaccine we might see weaker asymptomatic strains as providing a safer path to herd immunity. Someone here from these countries might be able to explain their low death rates in more detail.
- cwhiz 6y agoThat rate is in line with the US and most European countries. The US lost 40 million jobs and spent $4 trillion dollars to achieve the same outcome as Sweden. And now the US is reopening and attempting a similar approach to Sweden. You can’t shut the world down for months and months waiting for a vaccine.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoIt is a doubling or tripling of other places. 5% of all deaths due to a single infection. The US lockdown had concrete effect, limiting cases to what the hospitals could manage. Further, we understand more now (1000's of studies and papers published in a few months). To compare blindly ignoring the disease and crossing fingers (Sweden's approach) vs wait-measure-respond, I know which way I prefer.
- cwhiz 6y agoDoubling or tripling? Belgium 8.2, UK 5.8, Spain 5.8, Italy 5.5, France 4.4, Netherlands 3.5, Ireland 3.3, US 3.3. The US lockdown may not have had any impact. Mobility trends are disconnected from government orders. The people more likely stemmed the tide in the US more than any government action. Sweden is just marginally worse off against Covid overall than the US. And they didn’t have to spend $4 trillion or lose 40 million jobs to achieve that.
- claudeganon 6y agoAgain, as someone else up thread pointed out, you’re just comparing various notches on the “bad response” scale. Your calculus doesn’t work if you compare Sweden to Taiwan or the US to South Korea, even with adjustments to population. If your argument is that “it doesn’t make that much of a difference choosing between doing nothing and pursuing a bungled, haphazard response,” then sure, a lot would probably agree with you. But these are not the only choices any of these countries had. The economic damage is part and parcel of the overall mismanagement, which is why Taiwan and South Korea are doing better with both handling the pandemic and the state of their economies.
- matz1 6y agoWith only 4:10000, its not worth being alarmed. I like their approach.
- alkonaut 6y ago> With lives at stake, I think we must remember that "lives at stake" aren't just Covid infected. People will die in 10 years from budget cuts coming from things we do now. This isn't about counting bodies in the spring of 2020 (only).
- tharne 6y agoThat's pure speculation and not very informative to the debate. Basically you're saying, "In a decade the government will spend less money on a number of unspecified things and those cuts are going to kill people in some unspecified way". You could just as easy make a number of different equally speculative arguments, such as: "This will force drastic cuts in spending, including military budgets, leading to fewer deaths from war". "This will kill a lot of the elderly and chronically ill, drastically reducing government costs for things like healthcare, socially security and pensions, freeing up money for other things". "This will leads to more people moving to suburbs, increasing carbon emissions." "This will lead to more people working remotely, decreasing carbon emissions." What this pandemic has taught us so far is that we're really bad at predicting the future. In the meantime, we should try to minimize the death toll in the here and now.
- alkonaut 6y ago> What this pandemic has taught us so far is that we're really bad at predicting the future. In the meantime, we should try to minimize the death toll in the here and now. While I agree that it’s hard and speculative, I don’t agree with this. We have to minimize total suffering and lives lost and in the long term even if it means using very difficult predictions.
- mayama 6y agoHere are the deaths per 1M for few countries around Sweden's death number. Even ignoring Italy which was affected first, all other countries deaths per million are within 2% of each other. What is alarming about Sweden's numbers? * UK 585 * Spain 580 * Italy 556 * Sweden 450 * France 445 * Netherlands 350 * USA 330
- cygx 6y agoHere are the deaths per 1M for few countries around Sweden's death number. Why that restriction? Let's expand your list a bit more, shall we: * Portugal 142 * Germany 103 * Denmark 100 * Austria 75 * Finland 58 * Norway 44 * Czechia 30 * Poland 29 * Greece 17 The contrast between Sweden and its nearest neighbors Denmark, Finland, Norway is kind of glaring...
- geoffreymcgill 6y agoA chart to help visualize some of those countries... https://i.imgur.com/WrYORJL.png https://i.imgur.com/WrYORJL.png
- heracles 6y agoI certainly don't like the death rate either. Unfortunately lots of countries are in the same ballpark, 3-4/10000, but with wildly varying stragies. "Only a few months" happens to be the same timeframe for almost everyone else, so not sure why that is relevant. We aren't "doing very little", lots of restrictions on behaviour and travel, but certainly less strict than many other places. "Effort" isn't a good proxy for effective in these circumstances. I think there is at least two things going on: - The long-run approach being taken makes it seem like nothing is going on, since there isn't much action. Slow and steady easily registers and stillness. - Tons of misreporting, in all directions. I get newsclips from friends in the UK that are just out wrongwrongwrong, and they are wrong in different ways and directions! With this being said, I hope that Sweden's approach is in't the best! Why? Well, that would mean that large parts of the rest of the world is doing something better (if we simplify it into "lockdown" vs "limited restrictions"). That would cost us here in Sweden 1000's of unnecessary death, but perhaps spare millions in the rest of the world.