3 ms·
Staying closed for longer saves lives. There is, of course, a trade-off, but saying it does nothing is wrong. First thing is the whole "flattening the curve" t
by GuB-42 6y ago
Staying closed for longer saves lives. There is, of course, a trade-off, but saying it does nothing is wrong.
First thing is the whole "flattening the curve" thing. The less cases on a given time, the better treatment is. So even if the number of cases will ultimately be the same, it is better if happens over a long period of time.
There is also a simple mathematical argument. Let's take this simplistic model :
- Start with 1024 cases
- The pandemic will last for 6 months until a treatment is found
- Every "open" (O) month will cause the number of cases to double
- Every "lockdown" (L) month will cause the number of cases to halve
- To avoid overwhelming the health care system, we automatically go into lockdown when the number of cases reach 4096
Open early model:
O(2048) O(4096) L(2048) O(4096) L(2048) O(4096)
Cumulative cases: 18432
Open late model:
L(512) L(256) O(512) O(1024) O(2048) O(4096)
Cumulative cases: 8448
In both cases we have the same number of lockdown months and the same number of cases in the end (that's a property of multiplication), but the cumulative number of cases is lower when we open later.
The parameters are wrong, but the logic is the same no matter the values you choose. For example I used a very optimistic 6 months for the time before we have a cure, that's just to make the calculation shorter, you will get the same kind of result by making it 4 years.
The only case where the two strategies give out the same result is if you expect no cure will be found and go for herd immunity. I hope we won't get to that because it will mean millions of death in the US alone.