9 ms·
People try to do right by each other, no matter the motivation, study finds
- corin_ 6y agoHow do you get people into a trial like this without the bias of either "people kind enough to spend time helping research" or "people who need money enough that being a paid test subject is worth their time"? Might not matter for something like a vaccine trial, but for this?
- rpedela 6y agoSometimes participation is required to pass psychology classes.
- koolba 6y agoIndeed though even there you’ll have significant selection bias for psych v.s. other majors.
- austincheney 6y agoGenerally it’s college students who, despite having no income, are not living in poverty and have plenty of time.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago...and who on average have very limited life experience. A random subset of psych majors is going to have very different characteristics than a random subset of dining hall student employees is going to have very different characteristics than a subset of frat members.
- mercer 6y agoI can't vouch for this particular study, but my experience in college has been that possible differences between 'subset of psych majors' and the rest of the population are among the earliest considerations to, well, consider.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tixocloud 6y agoYou've just highlighted the key issue with studies, focus groups and marketing research. The population will always be biased - even the responses from the participants are likely to be biased because they are more likely to give a biased response. The insight that you get is marginally useful but nonetheless, it's better than no insight at all.
- skruban 6y agowhy would a biased insight be better than no insight? Depends on the amount of biasness, doesn't it?
- diegoperini 6y agoBecause having multiple researches about the same subject but with different biases is the way to eliminate bias with meta analysis studies.
- playpause 6y agoSelection bias (and mitigation of it) is a big topic, and worth googling, if you're interested. I recommend reading 'Bad Science' by Ben Goldacre, which is a fun read and goes into fascinating detail about various forms of bias in scientific studies and their reporting in the media, and how such problems can be managed.
- bonoboTP 6y agoMy harsh and honest opinion is that this kind of research is useless and is mostly a waste of resources and most likely serves other motives than we may think (narratives, signaling etc). All experiments with virtual money, with artificial lab setups, with people knowing they are in an experiment are very very biased. Even if being mean would gain you some money in an artificial experiment, there are other social factors that can counteract this, including pleasing the experiment designers, thinking of yourself as a good person. People probably introspect more in these observed scenarios etc. You know all those people writing their bachelor and master theses based on questionnaires filled out by random recruits from social media for the chance of winning a gift card? I see tons of those. Are they rigorous and valuable research? Unlikely, but at least they don't get into the press. We keep falling for this stuff even after the replication crisis, because science is used by the masses as a replacement of the priesthood. People in labcoats must say to us with jargon that compassion is good. We are too afraid of and are still recovering from the shock of the early and crude interpretation of the Darwinian theory. So we crave the "people are good after all" message and when there is demand there will be supply.
- crawfordcomeaux 6y agoUpvoted for the skepticism and the reality of how controlled experiments can produce desirable results that don't replicate. I still believe people are good after all because I've been conducting a real-world study for nearly 3 years, off-and-on. I started out with a car, no money, and the assumption that I'd gotten good at identifying my needs, asking for them to be meet, and being seen/heard. I now suspect people who are actively working to unlearn their social conditioning are more willing to help others because they're willing to see some aspect of their own humanity in me. That seems to be the trend, at least. When people first see me, they often respond either by showing fear (referring to me as Charles Manson was something a stranger did a couple weeks ago), intrigue/curiosity (asking why I'm dressed the way I am, possibly asking to take a photo), smile and walk away, candidly catch me on film, compliment me for what I'm wearing, or thank me for what I'm wearing. It could also be that people who are unlearning toxic/limiting social norms value seeing others doing the same, which I definitely do with my fashion. My experiments have led me through many adventures and now I'm writing this while next to my sleeping partner & 19-month old, so I'm not actively testing in the field as much. We're planning on expanding our community during the pandemic to find land to live on and people to live with. That's the next big experiment. We're hoping someone will simply give us land to conduct experiments in community building on. My experiences could also have a bit to do with the fact that I'm white and perceived as a man, since I have a big beard. Ultimately, I'd need way more people doing what I'm doing to see what really happens outside the cloak of white privilege.
- scribu 6y agoTitle of the paper: "The robustness of reciprocity: Experimental evidence that each form of reciprocity is robust to the presence of other forms of reciprocity" I think the interesting point about this paper isn't the conclusion, which is unsurprising, but rather the methods used for confirming it (They use linear mixed models, which I hadn't encountered before).
- executive 6y agoPeople want to help each other when they shoot each other in the face?
- dathinab 6y agoPeople shooting each other in the face comes normally hand in hand with a form of dehumanisation. For example instead of thinking about humans which protests they think about rioters. Or they see certain kinds of humans depending on skin color or religion or similar as less "human" as some form of "malformed product of nature" and other bs*. This circumvents any instinctual natural protections humans have against harming each other. Oh and for example in case of companies humans (employees) tend to be reduced to a tool costing some money and giving something back. Similar thinks often apply to many politicians.
- vitorbaptistaa 6y agoThis. There is an amazing Black Mirror episode that treads on this subject: Men Against Fire (S03E05) [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men_Against_Fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men_Against_Fire
- teekert 6y agoNice book on this subject: [0] [0] https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/12/humankind-a-hopeful-history-by-rutger-bregman-review https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/12/humankind-a-ho...
- dntbnmpls 6y agoWhat a misleading title. Apparently there are 4 motivators to benefit others. One: The recipient of a kindness is inclined to do something nice for the giver in return. Two: A person is motivated to do something nice to someone that she saw be generous to a third person. Three: A person is likely to do good in the presence of people in their network who might reward their generosity. Four: A person is likely to "pay it forward" to someone else if someone has done something nice for her. They did a online "study" where they mixed and matched the motivators to see how it affected people's "giving" ( points tied to money ). It's hard to tell from the article, but the assumption was that #1 would dominate people's motivation to give ( return the favor ), but the "study" showed that all 4 motivations and all the permutations still influenced the giving. So people do "right by each other" given these 4 motivators which ultimately is selfish because they all imply you have gotten something already or you hope to gain something by "doing right". > "From an evolutionary perspective, it's kind of perplexing that it even exists, because you're decreasing your own fitness on behalf of others," Melamed said. "And yet, we see it in bees and ants, and humans and throughout all of nature." I can't believe that a "scientist" would even say such nonsense. It isn't evolutionarily perplexing at all. We see it throughout all of nature because it doesn't decrease your fitness on behalf of others. Social networking and cooperation isn't evolutionarily perplexing.
- gwd 6y ago> Apparently there are 4 motivators to benefit others. The article says "Scientists previously had determined that four motivators influenced people to behave in a way that benefited other people." But that completely leaves out the fact that, you know, sometimes helping other people feels good. Why do people watch a sunset? Why do they listen to music? Why do people do exercises or read books, or have sex? The most basic reason for anything is that it gives people pleasure. Now, you can come up with some kind of evolutionary reason why those activities are pleasurable, but given that helping other people can be pleasurable, you don't need to come up with any deep psychological reason beyond that. And really, from a moral point of view, the purpose of social reward / shame mechanisms is to get you to to act in a caring way towards other people, so that you experience the pleasure of doing so, and then start doing it for its own sake. The best sort of person, after all, isn't the person who helps someone else for social status, or because they're afraid of retribution, or looking for a payback later. The best sort of person is the person who genuinely enjoys seeing someone else happy.
- readingnews 6y agoThese people do not live where I live. Of course, my observation is a singular data point, but speaking with colleagues through the years, it seems everyone in this area is of the "I will help you, but what is in it for me" philosophy. I wonder where they picked these participants from.
- arethuza 6y agoWhere do you live?
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIn my experience people's willingness to be kind is correlated more strongly with having shared problems that nearly nobody is exempt from. Some combination of an oppressive climate and limited local wealth seems to be the ticket for maximizing people's willingness to help each other out.
- leto_ii 6y agoMy personal understanding of human nature is that it's capable of the whole range of attitudes, from violent selfishness to pure altruism. I think the society you live in and the way you're brought up matter a lot in moderating these attitudes. If you're taught that you should be selfish, that it's a dog-eat-dog world out there etc. then of course you'll lean towards selfishness and transactionalism. This however is not a direct aspect of human nature, just a consequence of nurture.
- 082349872349872 6y agoHave you circulated your CV recently? I had thought people learn to be very transactional through either (a) prison, or (b) international relations, but clearly I am wrong. (as to A, I know two prison guards. One of them is now retired, and he told me the speech he'd eventually figured out: "I don't care what they say you're in for. It's none of my business. I do care that we all stay cool. If everyone is cool, everything will be cool." Still transactional, but he claims everyone was mostly cool)
- fallingfrog 6y agoOn the other side, if you want to know when people are going to be selfish and harmful towards one another, look for the situation where they have unaccountable power over another without consequences. Every time. There is a reason that the stereotype exists of the mad king or queen yelling “ off with their heads!” or feeling a pea under 18 mattresses or otherwise acting like a spoiled toddler. It’s the same reason that police walk around beating peaceful protesters and acting shocked and indignant that anyone would object. That’s what power turns a person into.
- spodek 6y agoHow do they factor in context and framing? - The oceans are filling with plastic so people with perfectly good tap water can drink bottled water - Sea levels rising so people in deserts can cool their homes and offices to 60 - Aquifers drain for golf courses in the desert - Sweatshops, data breaches, 9/11, etc I'm sure terrorists feel they are doing right by someone when they blow something up, but even the most zealous must realize not everyone agrees with them.
- barrkel 6y agoPrices don't expose moral costs, so market exchange removes this function talked about in the article.
- amiga_500 6y agoBeing priced out is having the choice removed from you. This is about making the moral choice. People know plastic bottles pollute, yet westerners continue to buy. Flint residents have an excuse. Most do not.
- IggleSniggle 6y agoI took the comment to mean that a dollar price hides the moral cost by masking it with a material cost.
- wolfram74 6y agoYou say including the ethical cost in the price removes the burden of choice, but I say excluding the cost in the price removes information for the consumer. I feel like the lucky 10000[1] also applies to bad things as well. I remember in high school having a conversation about teen pregnancy with classmates that wanted to go into medicine and they didn't realize that sex education in some school districts was so poor that some teenagers literally didn't know that sex made babies. Not a huge amount, but more than 0%. [1]https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/
- 6y ago
- Luc 6y agoLot's of mention of 'in the real world...', only to find they organized a contrived online game to 'prove' their argument.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoThis matches my experience. I've practised "paying it forward" and the rewards have been incredible. I've got way more back than I ever gave. People are always ready to be nice to each other, but sometimes wary of strangers. I've seen the other side of it, too. Where people approach situations with a "what's in it for me" attitude, and get nowhere. Their fear of getting ripped off, or "losing" in the interaction, stops them from being trusted.
- crawfordcomeaux 6y agoI wonder if my experiences match yours because I'm white.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoI'd never even thought of that. Interesting. I'll have to compare notes with non-white friends.
- 082349872349872 6y agoI once lived in a bilingual area in the States. Depending upon how I was dressed, I would be greeted in either english or spanish[1] when walking into a shop. My experience was that people were more helpful (to the extent of addressing me as "paisano") in spanish. I suspect this is because when I was greeted in english, I was being greeted as an out-group[2] member. [1] hypothesis: if you have never learned to code-switch, you are probably a member of a preferred group. [2] not necessarily due to being classified as anglophone, more likely due to being classified as tourist.
- leto_ii 6y ago> "From an evolutionary perspective, it's kind of perplexing that it even exists, because you're decreasing your own fitness on behalf of others," Melamed said. "And yet, we see it in bees and ants, and humans and throughout all of nature." I find this concluding remark really amusing. Even after performing the experiment, the researcher still can't really fathom the possibility that his views should be reassessed. If this behavior is present in humans and many other species, couldn't it simply be that in a more sophisticated way it actually increases fitness? Faced with these observations, shouldn't you maybe reassess your ideas about evolution?
- anoplus 6y agoDoesn't seem perplexing to me either. Humans are tribal and their survival depends on teamwork of about ~100 people or so. This is natural on intimate scale. What perplexing is to think about how humans can cooperate effectively on a scale of billion people to solve humanity biggest problems. As we can see, empathy for humans outside of the tribe is limited and so different gangs fight each other, let alone different countries. Maybe we can think about techniques to create empathy among strangers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rhacker 6y ago> Maybe we can think about techniques to create empathy among strangers. Small scale trial, a world exchange program where you could sign up, and basically you swap with someone random for a year. Before the swap happens both people get a week where they meet and discuss what is going on in their life. This can happen in a vacation resort somewhere. Then the two people take over the life of the other person. It would be assumed that everyone would sorta- help the swapped person out a bit. The swap would need to have very specific requirements: Probably no spouse, the job needs to be similar, friends/coworkers need to be on board, finally the swappers need to blog once per day about the experiences. Bank accounts would be locked out - the experiment pays the two individuals from a fresh account. Bills and Mortgages are locked or payed through other mechanisms during the experiment. I think that even starting out with maybe 100 people, then scale to 1000 a year later, 10000 after that. I don't know if those numbers are unrealistic... but wouldn't it be interesting to see if empathy for other countries or even ways of life start to develop?
- Allower 6y agoClearly the study didn't look at police..
- collyw 6y agoReminds me of how some newspaper explained that "Covid showed us how unselfish we were all being" or something to that effect. They conveniently missed the part when everyone was hoarding toilet paper at the start of the crisis.
- watwut 6y ago> They conveniently missed the part when everyone was hoarding toilet paper at the start of the crisis. Factually, it is not true that everyone was hoarding toilet paper. Also, you conveniently ignore that there was simultaneous recommendation to have supplies of everything for two weeks, in case you need quarantine - which means portion of people who were buying a lot were thinking the are following instructions.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoOur community has little free libraries on the sidewalks, many of them had toilet paper in them at the time.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoHa. That was also happening here. We never saw a drastic shortage, though. The store was empty or had limited supplies for a week or two then they brought in a large shipment and everybody cooled off.
- vangelis 6y ago> source on every single American hoarding toilet paper?
- jariel 6y agoPeople were not hoarding, they were just buying a little bit more than usual. It's not irrational or 'hoarding' to buy 2x24 when normally you buy 1x24. It seems pretty reasonable actually. But when we all do that, it sells out immediately. It was 'significant increase in demand brought on by marginal and reasonable increases in individual behavior'.
- have_faith 6y agoIs there not a consideration for the act being beneficial for the group (species) and that considerations have been elevated beyond either of the individuals concerns subconsciously? Ants are the obvious comparison, being very quick to sacrifice themselves to maintain a path to food for the group.
- stormdennis 6y agoRead something once about the best way to interact with other humans. It boiled down to, you can scratch someone's back once but you don't scratch it again until they've scratched yours. If someone does it to you first be sure to pay them back.
- gowld 6y agoIt's called "tit-for-tat" in th literature.
- stormdennis 6y agoThanks I couldn't remember what it was called.
- mindcrime 6y agoYep. As I recall, the origin of this idea comes from a series of competitions arranged by Robert Axelrod[1], where people submitted algorithms to participate in an Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma[2] situation. Tit-for-tat was one of the simplest algorithms submitted, but yet it won the contest. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Axelrod https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Axelrod [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_dilemma
- LatteLazy 6y agoI think an underappreciated factor in the drake equation is whether an intelligent species is able to form and maintain societies. For all our issues as a species, we're surprisingly good at forming everything from tribes to nations...
- neutronicus 6y agoOne wonders whether the fierce individualism of the Octopus saved us from being hunted to extinction
- LatteLazy 6y agoHumans are interesting because we're one of the few semi-social animals. If you're tribe/village is whipped out, you'll die soon too. But just because your group flourishes doesn't mean your genes will even be passed on (like they would in an ant colony). So we have all these behaviours (like empathy and cooperation) but they're finely balanced and complex (unlike an ant that will die for the colony without hesitation). The lack of top down control and the requirement for cooperation means communication abilities are vital and have to be complex and suddenly you have a brain that needs to simulate other brains (empathy) and consciousness is born.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIt depends on who the stranger is. My grandma grew up on the fjords of Norway on an island with a population of ~100. The island was split with a very large hill that separate the east from the west. On the west were the fishers, and on the east were the farmers. Each side was taught to look down on and distrust the other side... Humans are very tribal, and for most people, if a stranger looks like they could join the tribe, they might be offered help. My black cousin in the military still gets pulled over by police all the time. When they want to search his vehicle, he is smart enough to ask for a warrant, after which they use the tactic ‘Lower your voice!’ to escalate.
- jonahbenton 6y agoUpvote 1000 times. There's always an "other".
- dirtybirdnj 6y agoI completely reject this idea, it's 100% antithetical to the experience I've had in life. People are inherently bad and lack ethics until educated or exposed to it in a group setting. Even then a decent majority of people will continue to adopt a selfish mindset. I'd posit that as you become wealthier and more successful, your capacity to practice empathy and "doing the right thing" significantly diminishes quickly to a zero sum. You cannot manage above N number "other people" you don't see and interact with in person without mentally converting them into a resource or a number. The motivation to do the right thing drops out when you don't need societal / communal acceptance and validation of yourself and your actions. When you're rich enough to not give a fuck, fuck em. I got mine. Pretty sure this is what's destroying America.
- tw000001 6y ago>For this study, which was done online, participants had to decide how much of a 10-point endowment to give to other people. The points had monetary value to the participants; giving cost them something. Totally contrived study which completely ignores culture. Growing up in a shitty area in NYC for example will teach you that plenty of people are all too eager to act selfishly even when it is trivial to be considerate. Soft sciences are a joke and they erode layman credibility in hard sciences.
- kingkawn 6y agoHilarious how much effort has to go into is realizing how absurd the dogma of the individual actor is
- Glosster 6y agoThis is why I seriously believe that our competition-based approach to society is the one major issue we really have, in addition to the many symptoms and consequence that are now popping up. When you construct (or just arrive at) the foundation of society being built on the polar opposite of cooperation - namely, competition - how could we possibly arrive at a sensible, sustainable, peaceful world? People want to cooperate, help each other, work together. But in capitalism that goes directly counter to the imposed need to compete, and thus work for your own benefit by working against others.
- djyaz1200 6y agoHuman morals/behavior aren't like a fractal that's the same at every level. Let's see a study like this where much larger amounts are in play. As a young adult, my dad warned me that people are basically honorable up to about $10K. In practice, I've found everyone's threshold is different and fluctuates greatly with their individual situation and the broader economic situation. For example, right now I'm seeing otherwise successful and decent folks do really ugly things over 4 figure money.
- jstarfish 6y ago> As a young adult, my dad warned me that people are basically honorable up to about $10K. No way. $10k is the lower boundary to litigation being worth anybody's time. If somebody is going to defraud you, it's going to be for an amount less than $10k. Amounts of money higher than that may entice people into doing things they otherwise wouldn't, sure, but there I'd submit that they were never honorable in the first place if they can be bought for the right price.
- qwertox 6y agoThere are people who have learned that being kind and generous attracts people, and once they have got them close to them, they start to use or abuse them, push them to feed their ego with praise and have them work for them to live a comfortable life. The discussions with strangers with their narcissistic self-praises give them all the kick they desire to feel in their life. Nothing matters more to them.
- neilwilson 6y agoIt's a pity they didn't go to the next stage. Does doing others a favour build up 'social assets' you can call in? Are people in your debt? For how long? You could even call it testing the MacGyver Principle. How many favours can you pull in?
- foooobaba 6y agoThere is a class which is behavioral evolution from stanford which covers these topics. There are other frameworks to look at it from like individual selection theory (try to make sure your dna survives) kin selection (your family shares your dna so try to pass that on as well, even if you sacrifice yourself). There are even more ways to look but I’m too much of noob to elaborate on them. But bottom line some behaviors might not help you and your dna but similar enough dna for you to want to sacrifice yourself. Robert Sapolsky is the professor and you can find the lectures on youtube, highly recommend all though i only finished 4 of them so far.
- question11 6y agoThey don't outline how they removed culture from the study. Maybe this applies only to people in Ohio? Or maybe those nice canadians next door?
- aaron695 6y agoI've just read the 'Media' version of the 'study' But yes, humans are intrinsically social. But what's actually matters is how much. Bending over once a year to pick up rubbish vs spending a day. What we need it know is how to maximise it in more cases (for good or evil) these studies are more about clicks. You barely know what's going on when the cost is so low.
- stretchwithme 6y agoI would say people freely give who feel that they gain from the community far more than they give. And they do right by others when they feel the community is doing right by them. And this is not PER INTERACTION but over the long haul. People that are not connected to their community strongly, meaning they don't have mutliple adults protecting, disciplining and sustaining them, aren't as likely to do right by others or give freely. Sons without fathers living in the home are far more likely to have behavioral problems. I think we grow into our social hierarchy or we seek to establish a new one that competes and clashes with the existing one. Unfortunately, the trend more and more across most groups is single parent families.