4 ms·
Letting people get sick and die will also cause economic damage. I think the ideal solution would have been a quick lockdown to stop the exponential growth of
by mcv 6y ago
Letting people get sick and die will also cause economic damage.
I think the ideal solution would have been a quick lockdown to stop the exponential growth of the spread, and once that's under control, loosen up the restrictions one at a time while ensuring the spread doesn't increase again.
This is what Netherland has been doing, and it seems to be very effective. Schools have been partially open for 2.5 weeks now, and the numbers keep going down.
But in a country where half the population is determined to sabotage any attempt to prevent the spread of the disease, where leaders call it a hoax and spread misinformation, I can imagine that any attempt at lockdown is doomed to fail anyway. Might as well open up and let it run its course with all the damage that will do, because too many people insist on inflicting that damage anyway.
- user5994461 6y ago>>> Letting people get sick and die will also cause economic damage. Quite the contrary. A few percents of elder dying might literally save many of the European pension systems that were on the hedge of collapse. Besides there are way more people than jobs (double digit unemployment even before the lockdown). A calamity reducing the workforce would stimulate the economy and make it easier to get a job. That's quite the opposite of economic damages.
- rusticpenn 6y agoThis is the most inhuman thing I have read on Hacker news. Life is life and every life is important. Many skilled people are irreplacable, there is no economy without customers.
- mehrdadn 6y agoInteresting discussion on this: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/835571843 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/835571843 Excerpts: > GONZALEZ: Valuing people differently was kind of tried once in 2003. The EPA, under the George W. Bush administration, was considering a new clean air standard. How clean the air should be. And the EPA was like, well, people over age 70 have fewer years to breathe clean air. They should count less. And a lower value on some lives would essentially mean looser clean air standards. > MALONE: The EPA suggested that, perhaps, older people should be worth 37% less money. > STEVENSON: It became known as the senior discount. > GONZALEZ: The senior death discount, actually. People protested. They held up signs that said granny for sale. It did not go over well. > STEVENSON: The backlash was so intense they, very immediately, walked away from that, and you haven't seen any kind of similar proposal since.
- mcv 6y agoWell, we've seen similar proposals now. The Lt-Governor of Texas suggested old people would be happy to die for the economy.
- user5994461 6y agoI am all for being inspirational and believing in humanity. Yes people are good most of the time. But being nice shouldn't imply being naive. Every single person in a medium-large organization is replaceable, no exception. I used to not believe it too but it's been shown time and again in my career. Even if executives/managers understand that treating their employees well has benefits, they will not blink an eye when it's time to take managing decisions or let employees go.
- oarsinsync 6y agoYes, most employees are replaceable. No, the same is not true of people. My family and close friends cannot be replaced. Not quickly, not easily, not without lasting damage. Yes, there may be some economic benefits in the long term to "letting people die." No, there will definitely be severe short term shocks to the economy to following that strategy. 1-5% of the population dying (even when skewed towards particular demographics) means that almost everyone will know someone that's died, several someones that have ended up in ICU, several someones that have suffered badly, and several someones that just had nothing happen at all. If you ignore the second order effects of that ("I don't want to go to work because I don't want to end up in ICU like my buddy Dave"), the economic damage in the short term then becomes even more severe. The loss of confidence in the government becomes more severe. The willingness to return to the workforce reduces significantly.
- mcv 6y agoYou seem to see people only as labour resources. I strongly object to that view.
- alexashka 6y agoLet's lower the speed limit until the number of deaths in car accidents due to speed is 0 then? In this physical universe, humans have a non-zero possibility of dying from coming in contact with other human beings directly or indirectly. You have to agree on some level of danger because trying to avoid all danger would itself cause death, by boredom and likely starvation. Now if we're going to agree that some people should have more resources than others and if we're going to agree on trading using currencies and if we agree that lack of resources may cause someone to die, we've just put a price on human life. I'm sorry that realities of life are upsetting to people who've been given a children's view of the world where all life is precious, but at some point, we have to grow up :)
- rusticpenn 6y agoLowering the speed limit of a car to 0, and removing seat belts from a car because it cost more money to manufacture and test are two different things.
- alexashka 6y agoYou may want to try comprehending and responding to the entire reply, not a single cherry picked sentence. Here is a sample nonsense reply I can give you based on the first part of your sentence: lowering the speed limit of a car to 0 would mean it is no longer a car, because a car is something that moves. See how my reply makes sense if I ignore the rest of your reply and yet doesn't make any sense when your reply is seen as a whole? That's not a good conversation strategy.
- manigandham 6y agoYes lives are irreplaceable but realistic risk assessment and actuarial modeling is required for the world to function.
- rusticpenn 6y agoYes, however, Germany for example was able to reduce death count, flattenned the curve and is currently mostly reopened. Its possible to value lives and stabilize the economy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mcv 6y agoDo you think health is that binary? Either you're in perfect health or you drop dead? A serious case of COVID-19 can take months, possibly years to recover from. It's quite likely it will leave people with permanent health problems. Nothing about that is good for the economy. But even if it was, I'd object to "let's kill people because it's good for the economy" in a strongest possible way. Any government that thinks about the people in those terms deserved to be overthrown in a revolution.
- misja111 6y ago>> This is what Netherland has been doing, and it seems to be very effective. Schools have been partially open for 2.5 weeks now, and the numbers keep going down. As a Dutch person living abroad, I find it amazing how my fellow Dutch citizens keep finding ways of justifying their government's handling of the Covid crisis. Dutch schools were closed pretty quickly in the beginning of March, despite the advice of virus experts to keep them open: there were strong signs that children were not affected much by the virus. Now that the schools are reopening, as you are saying, it turns out that having the schools open does not increase spreading of the virus. I would say that this proves that the experts were right and the Dutch government wrong, and that the closing of the schools was a mistake. A costly mistake, both for the sake of the education of the children, and for their parents, many of which had big problems with combining their work and the daycare of their children.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoOf course children in schools is a primary disease vector. Never mind the children don't suffer much; grandma at home could suffer grievously from a virus brought home from the petri-dish of the classroom. This is obvious, right?
- misja111 6y ago@JoeAltmaier I can't reply to your answer directly for some reason, but: to me it is not obvious at all that schools are a primary disease factor. Most kids show no symptoms when they are infected. AFAIK there is no proof yet that asymptomatic carriers of the COVID virus can contaminate others. And if they do, it might be much less than carriers with symptoms. This is not only my opinion, it was the opinion of Dutch virus experts as well at the time the decision was taken to close schools. That was a political decision, based on the fear that lived among people to send their kids to school. But instead of opinions it is better to talk about facts, and now that schools are reopening everywhere we have plenty of those. And the facts are showing that reopening the schools does not significantly increase the number infections.
- mcv 6y agoThere were a lot of early assumptions about the virus. Some turned out to be true, others turned out to be false. For example, they were also saying that the virus would only spread if you had symptoms; that turned out to be totally false, and a big reason why it spread so much faster than everybody expected. I think erring on the side of caution was absolutely warranted. But I also think it's good that kids are going to school again. Compared to many other countries, I'm pretty happy with how the Dutch government is handling this.