3 ms·
HN suffers the same problem as reddit, but amplified. The first five votes are far more meaningful than the next 50. Since HN has a shorter time factor than r
by jedberg 6y ago
HN suffers the same problem as reddit, but amplified. The first five votes are far more meaningful than the next 50. Since HN has a shorter time factor than reddit, the effect is amplified.
If you get five votes in the first minute you'll almost certainly be on the front page. If you get one downvote in the first minute you'll almost certainly never make the front page.
I've been thinking a long time on a solution for this. My gut feeling is that every post should start with 10 points. That way one downvote won't kill it, and one upvote will only be 1/11 of the total score, instead of 100% of it.
Usually at reddit the way we would tweak these things is Chris would graph out each candidate algorithm in matlab and then we would go with the one that most continuous and "looked right", but you sort of need a PhD in Physics to get that right. :)