3 ms·
That's only assuming we never get a vaccine or an effective treatment. If we do, then the number of people to die before that point matters a lot, because we wo
by viraptor 6y ago
That's only assuming we never get a vaccine or an effective treatment. If we do, then the number of people to die before that point matters a lot, because we would get a sharp decline after.
- compumike 6y agoPrecisely. I've simulated this numerically and shown that the curve of [deaths]-vs-[duration of widespread economic crisis] is concave, like an inverted parabola that's been truncated by eventually getting a vaccine (or effective treatment). Perhaps counterintuitively, the points on the strategy curve that have both lowest death counts and shortest widespread economic crisis are the same. I've published these simulations here: "Surprising COVID-19 Strategy: Reduce Economic Damage and Deaths Simultaneously" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NuNrkG188HA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NuNrkG188HA
- octodog 6y agoIn addition to your points, another reason for "flattening the curve" is to give time for hospitals and health care systems to prepare for a spike in cases, so that every patient who needs critical care can receive it. For countries like Italy that were hit at the start of the pandemic, this was a serious problem. Where I live, in Victoria, Australia, the state government has used the lockdown time to plan for and deliver a huge increase of ICU beds [1]. Thankfully, it looks like these beds may not even be necessary, but initial modelling suggested a peak of 10,000 active cases with only 500 IUC beds available. [1] https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/thousands-of-beds-promised-for-coronavirus-pandemic-may-never-be-used-20200420-p54lip.html https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/thousands-of-bed...
- alkonaut 6y agoThe Swedish assumption (not officially, but what I take away from communication is what they assume) - No effective treatment or vaccine will arrive within a year. - Measures that completely eradicate the virus aren't sustainable for the time it takes to do so or until a vaccine arrives (e.g. lockdowns), - Without at least some immunity, "Test, Trace, Isolate" is not a viable strategy for dense regions. - Without at least some immunity, a second wave is unavoidable, and risks being worse than the first, if it arrives early next season. It's better to have a small immunity in the low risk population now, than let risk high risk groups later. - Even a small level of immunity has a large effectiveness in limiting spread, i.e. 10% or 20% immunity in a region can make a big difference, so if that can be achieved in the low risk population that is a good thing. - Asymtomatic spread, presymptomatic spread, and spread from children are all possible but not significant (That is: if symptomatic spread is controlled, that is enough). Some of these assumptions have been challeneged, some were not at all controverrsial to begin with but have changed over the last months.