3 ms·
Sensationalist bottom feeder People magazine crap gets a lot of attention. I wish that we as a culture were more concerned about things that really mattered.
by zdw 16y ago
Sensationalist bottom feeder People magazine crap gets a lot of attention.
I wish that we as a culture were more concerned about things that really mattered. Unfortunately, we have people obsessed with how they look and what's going on in "famous people's lives", 90% of which is tabloid distortion or outright fabrication.
I blame marketing for this. People are convinced they need stuff they don't really need, and the best way to do it is to say "person you admire uses X". The reason CNN is sending all these people is they know it will make result in great ad revenue.
sigh
- jerf 16y ago"I blame marketing for this." OK, but why does the marketing work? I'd submit the marketing is more effect than cause. We have significant support in the human brain for tracking social status and the leaders of the (perceived) hierarchy. We don't have very much support for "important long-term risks and issues". It may be unfortunate, it may yet kill us all, but it's not surprising.
- zdw 16y agoMarketing fundamentally is about matching up a solution with a need, and convincing that the solution being provided is better than others. The problem is that often there are solutions with no need, thus the need is manufactured (becomes a want). My wager is that celebrity coverage, and the products that advertise on that time are nearly all in the category of wants, and often frivolous/stupid ones at that.
- jerf 16y agoI don't think anyone had to create a need to observe the ranking of the perceived-by-the-brain-as-local social hierarchy. Gossip has been with us for as long as recorded history goes back. This is nothing more than the gossiping impulses translated into modern connected society.
- wtn 16y agoCNN, NYT, MTV et al will continue to trend tabloid as the number of alternative sources of information grows, bleeding away their "serious" audiences. While it is sad to see this crap get more concentrated over time, it's not really helpful to stress over it. Is the breadth and depth of content apart from television and outside the mainstream getting better? Probably yes. Cable TV subscriber counts began declining in 2009.
- zdw 16y agoThe sad thing about the internet is that you can insulate yourself from any opinion that you might disagree with. For an obvious political example, I know people who only read sites like The Drudge Report or Huffington Post. They self align with those viewpoints, and anyone who disagrees becomes the enemy. It's a tribalist resurgence, and I don't see a solution to this - there are no even handed debates anymore. Why is this? Marketing wants hits, so you get link bait headlines, and anything that will get hits even if it lacks merit gets pushed out the door for ad revenue.
- wtn 16y agoI don't think that's entirely true. For me, the great thing about the internet is that some of these "tribes" are actually pretty diverse in their viewpoints. They form loose communities based on currencies of quality (thoughtfulness, analysis, originality) instead of specific views. Specifically, I'm thinking of the bloggers/twitter users who write about political/econ topics. A lot of the good ones are non-commercial and ad-free and aren't looking for public acclaim.
- brazzy 16y agoIt's human nature more than marketing (or rather:marketing follows human nature in this). We're hardwired to be social and care deeply about what people in our group do and what happens to them, especially the leaders. Unfortunately, we're also hardwired to think that our group consists of those whose faces we see most frequently and the leaders are those we see others pay attention to. The result: millions of people unconsciously believe that Paris Hilton, Snooki and Charlie Sheen are socially closer to them than most of their family, and thus deserve most of their attention and trust... And of course that's what makes celebrity news so popular and endorsement marketing so effective.
- kmfrk 16y agoOn another note, I recently checked out some gossip on blekko, and I found out that all the gossip stories originated from one source all the time - usually Us Weekly or People Magazine. (Both stories seemed like conjecture or hear-say, but no surprise there.) It's incredible how frail your reputation and brand as someone in the entertainment industry can be. It's like there's a superficial need for gossip and its ilk, but no desire for "good journalism", when celebrities are involved. I know it seems a little orthogonal to the concept of journalism, but maybe there's a void to be filled for gossip that is well-written and -researched. Gossip is all completely alike, and I don't know why you would need to get it from one of your regular news sources like, say, NYT or CNN. Especially since so many just parrot the rumour-mongerers.