6 ms·
I read something different from that same graph. Assuming the French lockdown does not get rid of the virus/sickness completely, the "cases" line shows the spee
by kqr 6y ago
I read something different from that same graph. Assuming the French lockdown does not get rid of the virus/sickness completely, the "cases" line shows the speed at which the virus burns through the population. Sweden will have gone through its population long before France has, and will France be able to keep functioning under strict lockdown for all those months? Or even years, at the present rate?
Assuming we'll all contract COVID-19 anyway, eventually, it makes little sense to adopt strong restrictive measures on personal liberty to slow the spread down to a crawl. Sure, you have to impose some restrictions in order not to overload hospitals and whatnot, but anything beyond that is just extending the suffering (both making living harder and ensuring it will go on for a longer duration), is it not?
- asciimo 6y agoDelaying the spread also buys time to develop therapies and vaccines.
- kqr 6y agoYes, absolutely true and I'm glad you brought it up. I should have mentioned that in my comment too.
- BillyTheKing 6y agoexactly, we've also learned that not all lockdowns are equal. Super-spreader events seem to be the driving force behind this pandemic, using effective measures we can avoid and learn to deal with super-spreader events while also allowing society to continue at a more normal rate.
- rumanator 6y ago> Delaying the spread also buys time to develop therapies and vaccines. I would also add that delaying the spread also contributes to making it progressively harder to get the disease to spread.
- chimprich 6y ago> and will France be able to keep functioning under strict lockdown for all those months? France has already lifted many of their lockdown restrictions. > Assuming we'll all contract COVID-19 anyway, eventually, That's a big assumption, and not necessarily correct. First, we won't all get it - herd immunity means infection rates max out at something like 60% to 90% of the population. I understand this maximum is to some extent a function of how fast your infection rates rise due to a sort of momentum effect. Second, we may be able to suppress maximum infections indefinitely (or until we get a vaccine or treatment) with tracing, local lockdowns and so on. It's not clear if this is an effective long-term strategy, and is disputed by some epidemiologists, but seems to be the leading preferred strategy by most experts. > it makes little sense to adopt strong restrictive measures on personal liberty to slow the spread down to a crawl The problem is that you can't really adopt half measures. That's linear thinking, and it's an exponential curve. You either keep the reproduction rate above 1 or below 1. Above 1 you get an accelerating increase and eventually overwhelmed hospitals. Below 1 your infection rates start halving. Luckily, the measures required for keeping R<1 don't seem to be too intolerable. Spain, Italy, France etc. have managed to squash their epidemics and are getting close to having something like normal society back.
- WildParser 6y agoBtw. The statistics to calculate herd immunity to 60-90% were extremely flawed. They used numbers that came right out of superspreader-events. The most likely thing for COVID-19 is, that it has R0 < 1. It will spread by using a series of superspreader-events and will disappear after a while. Check out Michael Levitt for some understanding of the mathematics of COVID-19... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8aHrx68IT7o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8aHrx68IT7o
- chimprich 6y agoI'm not sure what you're trying to say here. If R0 was <1 then we would never have had an outbreak in the first place. I don't believe Levitt's interpretation. I certainly hope it's true, but I don't think it is. He seems to believe containment measures have no effect, which is implausible to me. He's just talking about the stats, without giving a biological hypothesis for why infections would top out - that seems to be coming in an upcoming video that hasn't been released yet.
- PeterisP 6y agoAt this rate, Sweden will take years until they "have gone through its population". "Assuming we'll all contract COVID-19 anyway, eventually" is not a reasonable assumption - it was the worst case scenario that the world has avoided and (as it seems) will continue to avoid. It's reasonable to expect that if we solve this issue through a vaccine in 2021, then by that time perhaps 10% of the world's population will have contracted COVID-19 and almost everyone else will not. And the expected difference between Sweden and France is going to be that by the time that we have a solution, one of them will have burned through more of their population for no good reason.