4 ms·
My experience as well. I've submitted numerous times and been shocked that it gets maybe one vote, and sometimes days later I see the same link but it's hundre
by freedomben 6y ago
My experience as well. I've submitted numerous times and been shocked that it gets maybe one vote, and sometimes days later I see the same link but it's hundred of votes and sitting on the front page.
My current theory that is entirely without basis or data to back it up is certain users are given a lot more weight. A post of mine with 6 to 10 upvotes won't make it to page 2, but I'll see some with 4 upvotes on the front page. Oh well.
- Tomte 6y ago> certain users are given a lot more weight Almost certainly not. My submissions regularly reach the front page, but it's still a very small fraction, and, as you observed, often only at the fourth or fifth try. HN's "submission success" is indeed highly random. Your submission gets between few minutes and two hours at /newest (and if it's got longer that's because it's a time of low activity: nighttime in America). Either the "right" readers for your submission happen to be active at this timespan, or they don't.
- jedberg 6y agoI'm almost certain that is not the case. It's mostly based on time. The faster you get votes the faster it climbs. The mods do have the ability to "slow down" a post, if they think it will cause a flame war or is actively causing one. It basically makes it fall quickly by increasing the number of votes needed to reach the same position. But having some votes worth more than others would be in opposition to the egalitarian principles of the site. Oh, and when YC partners and founders log into HN, they get highlights for other YC people, so it may look like YC people are getting a boost, but really they're just getting more visibility to a subset of users, who tend to upvote other YC users quickly.
- CJefferson 6y agoAnother important part is voting rings -- companies who want to get high up will send out an email saying "We are submutting at time X, be ready to upvote".