6 ms·
> health savings plans where we get a debit card and can buy that stuff with pre-tax money, These are stupid, and I wish they'd die, for multiple reasons. Fir
by triceratops 6y ago
> health savings plans where we get a debit card and can buy that stuff with pre-tax money,
These are stupid, and I wish they'd die, for multiple reasons.
First, the list of things that are allowed and not allowed is completely arbitrary and random. Feminine hygiene products are allowed, but baby formula isn't. Wtf why? And now someone's gotta maintain this list of items and enforce it (Wageworks et al), and process claims made manually. So now we've just added another actor in the whole system that can add their own profit margin on top. All so we can save a few bucks in paying taxes.
Second, these aren't available to everyone (just like 401k plans, the other symbol of taxation inequality). It's a benefit that has to be offered by your employer, and there are plenty of shitty employers out there. The people who could most use a tax break on a $10 bottle of aspirin are the least likely to get it.
Third, the use-it-or-lose-it nature of FSA money. And if you lose it, the money goes back to the employer. Again, wtf why? You're basically placing a wager against your expected healthcare expenses every year at open enrollment time. For really no clear benefit. Why can't the "debit card" work like a "credit card" instead, with payments made directly from your paycheck? There's no guessing involved, and no one ever over- or under-contributes.
- jedberg 6y agoI agree 100% with everything you've said. They're dumb and just another band-aid for the fact that our insurance is tied to our jobs.
- FireBeyond 6y ago> feminine hygiene products are allowed, but baby formula isn't One is a healthcare product, the other is a food (nutritional supplement at best).
- triceratops 6y agoIt's baby formula not protein powder. It's literally life-sustaining. Calling it merely "a food" misses the point because, other than breast milk, it's the only food very young infants can consume. I'm not arguing that tampons and sanitary napkins shouldn't be FSA-eligible; I think it's 100% correct that they are. I'm just pointing out the randomness of what is considered eligible.
- jjeaff 6y agoFood and water is necessary to sustain human life. Why isn't food and water covered? Whether something is necessary to sustain life is not the criteria used to decide if an HSA covers it or not.
- triceratops 6y agoI was talking about FSAs, not HSAs. > Whether something is necessary to sustain life is not the criteria used to decide if an HSA covers it or not. And I'm arguing that the criteria, whatever they are, are arbitrary and stupid and need to die in a fire. Along with the the whole concept of FSAs. Yeah food and water are essential, but baby formula isn't ham sandwiches or avocado toast. It's the only food that a baby can have - it's an essential health item. That an account meant to pay for health expenses doesn't allow it is downright dumb. Calling it a "flexible" spending account is downright Orwellian language. It's the opposite of flexible.
- jedberg 6y agoTo a baby, baby formula is a life saving drug. Many women can't produce enough breast milk for their child, or have to work, or can't breast feed at all, or myriad other reasons that they need to supplement or completely replace their supply with formula. There is a reason formula is sold at pharmacies.
- mattlondon 6y agoFormula is literally the only thing some babies can eat particularly less than 6 months old. You cant just give them cow milk, or chocolate or bread or whatever. Has to be formula if it cant be breast milk. Not all parents breast feed their babies for myriad reasons - some by choice, some not by choice. Formula is quite expensive in the UK - no idea how expensive it is in the states, but a 800g tin of powder might cost about £12/15USD. That makes about 4 litres of milk which might last a 100% formula-fed baby 2-7 days depending on how old/hungry they are. By comparison 4.54L (i.e. 8 imperial pints ... we still seem to sell milk in imperial sized bottles for unknown reasons) of cow milk is £2.18, so formula is roughly 5x or 6x as expensive. Is £12 for 2-7 days worth of food for your kid expensive? For people on HN probably not, but I do know that the formula in the supermarkets often have security tags on them (along with razors etc) so I am guessing a lot of people cannot easily afford the formula/can't afford to feed their kid literally the only thing they can eat. Sad stuff really - this is why I would expect it to be on these sort of discount schemes.
- jedberg 6y agoThis Costco brand formula is about the cheapest you'll find in the US [0]. It's 5kg for $82 (or about $13 for 800g). So basically the cheapest we have is a little less than your average. Our cow milk is sold by the gallon (3.72L) and is about $4, so about the same ratio. [0] https://www.costco.com/kirkland-signature-procare-non-gmo-infant--formula-42-oz%2c-4-pack.product.100500042.html https://www.costco.com/kirkland-signature-procare-non-gmo-in...
- Spivak 6y ago> Formula is literally the only thing some babies can eat particularly less than 6 months old. You cant just give them cow milk, or chocolate or bread or whatever. Has to be formula if it cant be breast milk. I think the ideal compromise for this situation is that if this describes your situation you get a doc to sign off on it and then your FSA/Insurance should cover it as medical expense. Like it wont and it makes little sense for it to be excluded in the first place but I think we could find a compromise that satisfies everyone.
- 6y ago
- bhupy 6y ago> It's a benefit that has to be offered by your employer, and there are plenty of shitty employers out there. This seems like a weird indictment of health savings accounts, because it has nothing to do with the type of benefit, and has everything to do with the coupling of healthcare to employment. If that's your issue, solve that — don't drag down everything else. Decoupling it from employment has the added benefit of essentially killing the FSA because, you're right, it's dumb that it belongs to the employer. Health savings accounts are exactly how most people pay for their healthcare in Singapore, and it enjoys some of the best health outcomes with some of the lowest costs. I think that there's a lot of room to improve the experience in the US, but you don't have to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
- triceratops 6y agoI was talking about FSAs, not HSAs. But HSAs are kind of weird too. Why pre-allocate money specifically for healthcare expenses to a separate account? Instead, why not bump up IRA contribution limits and allow penalty-free distributions for qualified medical expenses? Why restrict HSAs to high-deductible health plans? Why are we asking people to deal with investment stuff in order to pay for their healthcare? Isn't that the point of an insurance company? You pay them premiums, they invest the money and pay for all your healthcare needs - none of that co-pay, coinsurance, deductible shit. The whole thing is a hack on top of a hack on top of a hack. One kludge after another.
- bhupy 6y ago> Instead, why not bump up IRA contribution limits and allow penalty-free distributions for qualified medical expenses? Seems indistinguishable from a higher limit HSA, but I'm on board with that. > Why restrict HSAs to high-deductible health plans? Removing this restriction is a great idea! I agree. > Why are we asking people to deal with investment stuff in order to pay for their healthcare? Most HSA providers use robo-investment. Where active investment is an option, it's usually only used by the most savvy users. Half the value add of most off your HSA providers is this investment management, which 100% beats having it sit around in cash. > Isn't that the point of an insurance company? You pay them premiums, they invest the money and pay for all your healthcare needs - none of that co-pay, coinsurance, deductible shit. This is really debatable, because the concept of "insurance", traditionally, is tail risk mitigation. Having insurance pay for everything from flu shots to regular check-ups makes it something else entirely, that's no longer insurance, it's a glorified health payment plan with all of the price information removed. Indiana has a very interesting program for their government employees, where they offer "deductible security", in which the state provides a health savings account into which it deposits an amount equal to the annual deductible every year. Another potential policy avenue to incorporate with HSA's.
- creatornator 6y agoThere are also HSA plans, which are not "use it or lose it", but require high deductible insurance plans. I consider the two options targeting two entirely different audiences. If you have high or very predictable medical costs, you only contribute to an FSA what you will use in a year. If you are young, with no pre existing conditions, and generally take care of your own health, you can save some money on premiums with the high deductible plan and HSA, you are unlikely to need to make any claims so the high deductible never comes into play, and you get to keep the HSA through retirement when you are sure to have more medical costs and you get to benefit from the triple tax advantage.
- apta 6y agoThis is side stepping the issue. The solution is very simple and straight forward: you simply buy whatever is "FSA approved", and submit a claim. Can't be any more straight forward. Or as OP presented, you use the same card, but then it gets deducted from your paycheck minus tax. We have to see who's benefitting from this elaborate gambling scam that steals money from people.
- apta 6y ago> Third, the use-it-or-lose-it nature of FSA money. This has always surprised me, as it is nothing but literal gambling. Very strange how this is a "government approved" program.