4 ms·
The question is interesting, but any answer is more projection of one's beliefs than any actual grounding in reliable fact. In the context of the 18th century,
by jcranmer 6y ago
The question is interesting, but any answer is more projection of one's beliefs than any actual grounding in reliable fact.
In the context of the 18th century, the forces that a government could bring to bear would either be a centralized army (that would take months to get anywhere in what is now the US, due to its large size), or the very localized militia forces, which would be responsible for local defense until the regular army could arrive. In the specific context of the US, the main threats would have been Indian raids and slave revolts, where immediate action from local militia would have been essential for response. One of the pivotal events of the American Revolution was the British attempt to disarm the Massachusetts local militias, and it's my belief that this is why the Second Amendment is worded the way it is.
At the same time, we must recognize that our modern world is alien to those who lived 200 years ago. Services once provided by a collective civic obligation (such as the militias of that period) are now institutions provided by the government or by private individuals under contract of the government. And the realistic threats we face are vastly different. I imagine that given these circumstances, they would take a much narrower view of Second Amendment, casting it more as a right to personal self-defense rather than a right to private military rebellion against the government acting unlawfully.
- whatshisface 6y ago>casting it more as a right to personal self-defense rather than a right to private military rebellion against the government acting unlawfully. Then again, it might be hard to drum up support for a ban on rebellions, among people who were at the time in the middle of a rebellion.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoI imagine that support would have been quickly reestablished amongst people making the laws once they got a grip on power.
- saghm 6y agoBy the time the Bill of Rights was written, the rebellion had been over for years. The American revolution ended in 1783[1], whereas the Bill of Rights wasn't written until 1789[2]. That's not to say they might not have been sympathetic to rebellion still, but they definitely weren't "in the middle of" one. Note that Washington himself literally led the American military against a rebellion during his presidency[3]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Revolution [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Bill_of_Rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Bill_of_Rights [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiskey_Rebellion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiskey_Rebellion
- jcranmer 6y agoThe Confederate States (during the American Civil War) prohibited states from seceding... and this was only a few months after they had seceded from the US!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]