4 ms·
> Probably the single most effective thing to reduce police abuse in America would be to end the war on drugs and decriminalize drugs. No. No, no, no. A thousa
by vkou 6y ago
> Probably the single most effective thing to reduce police abuse in America would be to end the war on drugs and decriminalize drugs.
No. No, no, no. A thousand times no.
The war on drugs is just an objective of the police. The objective isn't why brutality happens. Brutality happens because of a systemic problem - the complete lack of accountability. Drugs are just the impetus for some fraction of police-public interactions. They are not the reason for how those police-public interactions are carried out.
The police are completely out of control in my neighbourhood. There are walls of tear gas rolling down the streets, rolling into people's apartments, their living rooms and bedrooms. Nobody, not the city mayor, not the state government is willing to reign them in - which is why this is happening.
The war on drugs is a bad thing, but if you end it tomorrow, it won't solve a single one of these systemic issues.
- mhh__ 6y ago>but if you end it tomorrow, it won't solve a single one of these systemic issues. Why not? The war on drugs is absolutely unenforceable - that leads to police picking and choosing what to enforce which amplifies systemic biases they have. You cannot enforce drug laws accountably, not least because it is largely racist in origin and as such targeted at specific minority groups - let alone practicalities There's a fantastic Vice interview of an British ex-undercover drugs officer: He summarizes most of his career as having been spent ruining the lives of poor people around him and his crowning achievement being a bust that (in the words of one of his colleagues apparently) "interrupted the illegal drug trade in stoke for upwards of 20 minutes"
- vkou 6y agoThe police can always pick and choose what they enforce. Have you ever called them? I am close friends with people who have, multiple times. Getting them to show up is an exercise in pulling teeth. They respond to calls - all calls - in an utterly discretionary nature. As they currently operate, they can't even do any part of their job accountably. Drug legalization is just a pet issue for techies, that is a smoke-screen that distracts from the real issues.
- mhh__ 6y agohttps://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_offenses.jsp https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_offen... https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2020.html https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2020.html > Drug legalization is just a pet issue for techies No. 14% of State prisoners, ~25% of people in local jails, and almost half of all federal prisoners is not a pet issue.
- vkou 6y agoReducing the police's arrests by ~25% will have a ~linear impact on police brutality. That is, it will reduce brutality by ~25%. I will take a ~25% reduction, but that is not my goal. The goal is to fix the system, not the symptoms of the system. Drug laws are a social fad, they will appear, or go away depending on which side of the bed the public wakes up tomorrow. The structural failings of the police, that persist through the presence or repeal of any one law are what need to be fixed. 'Which laws are on the books' is not a structural failure. The police should be capable of doing their jobs, regardless of which laws are on the books. If they aren't doing their jobs, the solution is not to change the laws, it's to change the police.
- kansface 6y ago> Reducing the police's arrests by ~25% will have a ~linear impact on police brutality. That is, it will reduce brutality by ~25%. Negative. Police brutality is not just driven by the number of interactions, but the likely outcome of those interactions. Dealers are often armed and strongly prefer avoiding prison.
- vkou 6y agoMost drug arrests are not of dealers.