6 ms·
In all likelihood lashing out at fancy retailers will be effective. Additional police powers and crackdowns will be paired with throwing the rioters a few bones
by pydry 6y ago
In all likelihood lashing out at fancy retailers will be effective. Additional police powers and crackdowns will be paired with throwing the rioters a few bones (e.g. greater checks on police powers and throwing the book at George Floyd's murderers).
Of course, the elites will pretend that they meant to throw that bone all along and will vehemently deny it has anything to do with a smashed up Gucci store in Beverly Hills and a lot of Americans (perhaps most) will believe this denial.
- brenden2 6y agoIndeed, peaceful protests are good for the status quo because they're easy to ignore. They want you to sit down and be quiet so they can ignore you. Once you start to inconvenience rich people, or god forbid cause the stock market to go down, real change will begin to happen.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoDo you really think so? These stores all have insurance. The deductibles will hurt a little but I don't think it's going to be game changing, especially for any national or international chains.
- brenden2 6y agoIt hurts insurance companies, but it's great for anyone who fixes or repairs windows.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoUntil the businesses don’t exist anymore because it’s not possible to insure at a price where people will still buy product.
- brenden2 6y agoThese are mostly big chains, I think they'll be okay.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThe big chains were suffering outside of a handful of affluent neighborhoods in all cities even in good times, I don’t see why this wouldn’t be a problem. Margins are low, and consumers’ ability to spend is low, so raising prices might not be possible leaving closing down as the only option.
- brenden2 6y agoIf you don't run a viable business, should your business continue to exist? Which one do you want, socialism or capitalism? In a capitalist system, failed businesses are allowed to fail and don't get free money from the government.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThe discussion is about businesses that suffer losses from being vandalized or robbed. No one can run a viable business in that kind of environment.
- ggreer 6y agoThe big chains won't run risky or unprofitable stores. It's the communities that will be hurt by this. Despite interest-free loans and over $100 million in federal funding, Baltimore still hasn't recovered from the 2015 Freddie Gray riots.[1] Moreover: government funding is a rather blunt tool, and directing it at a city tends to cause most of the money to flow to the nicer parts of town. That's what happened in Ferguson.[2] Riots tend to widen the disparities, not reduce them. 1. https://www.baltimoresun.com/maryland/baltimore-city/bs-md-ci-freddie-gray-five-years-later-20200417-gcz7z44lajdizdgvtl6d54rnv4-story.html https://www.baltimoresun.com/maryland/baltimore-city/bs-md-c... 2. https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2018/business/is-racial-discrimination-influencing-corporate-investment-in-ferguson/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2018/business/is-rac...
- minitoar 6y agoThey will keep getting smashed up. People don't like to shop for luxury goods in a shop with boarded up windows.
- pydry 6y agoYes. I don't think it's a problem for them financially, it's just it's a a powerful symbol of the control that they have lost. That's why they'll pull out all of the stops including heavy handed propaganda, agent provocateurs, sending in the army (if it gets much worse) and even (finally, with gritted teeth), appeasement. Historically riots have often presaged regime change as it can uncover how dangerously exposed the elites are and how little support the elites have. Unlikely in this case, but it's still the same process that scares the bejesus out of most regimes.
- zozbot234 6y agoWe're already seeing agent provocateurs in the current protests. White nationalists are purposely trying to incite violent riots throughout the U.S. as part of their "accelerationist" plans. The regrettably widespread opinion that the original, peaceful protest against police brutality is per se violent and thus to be opposed is very much a false and racist claim.
- MiroF 6y ago> We're already seeing agent provocateurs in the current protests. White nationalists are purposely trying to incite violent riots throughout the U.S. as part of their "accelerationist" plans. The amount that this is actually happening is vastly overstated. I've watched this narrative blow up within 48 hours, but the reality is that a lot of the "looting" is from frustrated, angry, low-income people. In no way is that a racist claim - poverty and extreme inequality breeds desperation and anger and you can't pretend that away.
- zozbot234 6y agoAngry and frustrated people will always be vulnerable to provocation. We can't pretend that away, but we can't wish that away either. So both claims could be true in some sense, but agent provocateurs (acting under fictitious monikers such as "Antifa", "Anonymous/4chan" or the like) are clearly playing a key role.
- whatshisface 6y agoWait, so if there were some elites in charge of everything, and if they felt personally threatened, you are suggesting that their response would be to decrease the power of their security forces? Wouldn't they want to make the police even more powerful?
- pydry 6y agoYes of course they'd want that, but compromise is often a necessity to prevent things from spiraling totally out of control. The French and Russian revolutions are a testament to what happens when the ruler tries to effect the appearance of compromise without actually doing it (e.g. Constitution of 1906). It ended very badly for the rulers in both of those cases. They fucked up a lot more than just that, but that was a key contributing factor to their deaths.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoThe difference is in the times of the French revolution, the elite lived only mere miles away from the angry poor, within striking reach of their wrath whereas now the elites can move to super safe heavens, isolated from the mess they created and suffer no consequences from the angry masses. Jeff Bezos and Warren Buffett can move with their families to some private island in the Caribbean and wait while things cool down while running their gigs remotely. The French elite had no such luxury.
- pydry 6y agoI could see Louis 16th's failed flight to varennes being repeated in a different form. It wasnt a lack of technology that stopped him, it was a man recognizing him and arresting him. Part of the problem was that he left it too long to attempt fleeing.
- brenden2 6y agoThey didn't have helicopters, underground bunkers, and air force one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 6y agoThis is really wrong. Destroying retail will just destroy retail. When it's gone it's gone. If you think shopkeepers control the Police, you are hopelessly confused.
- brenden2 6y agoThe pandemic demonstrated that luxury retail is non-essential (you can still buy your Gucci bags online). When luxury retail was closed the world did not fall apart. Nobody is protesting because they can't shop at the Apple store.
- Aunche 6y agoPlenty of people complain that not enough stores like Target open up in low income areas and riots are only going to make this worse.
- brenden2 6y agoFor someone in desperation all I hear is further reason to riot and loot. Nobody cares about these people, and politicians keep going on TV saying how they're going to put everyone in jail or shoot them.
- fein 6y agoStatements and actions are two very different things, and as far as I can tell the rioters have the support of both corporations and the state, as absolutely nothing has been done to deal with the unrest. That is, unless you start to cause trouble in the wrong neighborhood, then the police will absolutely take care of it: https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/nypd-shoot-gunman-after-finding-man-shot-in-brooklyn/2444323/ https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/nypd-... I'm not sure why people are eating up the media lie idea that the government is some fascist entity supporting corporations, because the government's actions show that the rioters, politicians, corporations, and government (state and federal) are all on the same side. Revolutionaries that signal on the same lines as Sony, Target, Walmart, Google, the state governments, and the federal government... It's honestly laughable how well this is orchestrated and how incredibly naive or stupid the people are that are eating it up for social brownie points. The only people not being represented by anyone are the small business owners who don't wan't their homes and businesses eviscerated, and normal citizens who keep their heads down.