3 ms·
It looks like a site may consume about 20kW. This sounds like a good bit, and is more than an LTE mast, but you have to keep in mind that it’s much less than a
by rsynnott 6y ago
It looks like a site may consume about 20kW. This sounds like a good bit, and is more than an LTE mast, but you have to keep in mind that it’s much less than a car and about equivalent to two electric showers. From a societal energy usage point of view it’s irrelevant.
- mikekchar 6y ago20 kW in what period of time? 20 kW in a year is nothing. 20 kW in a second is quite a lot. Edit: Facepalm!
- rsynnott 6y agoA watt is a measure of power, not energy.
- quietbritishjim 6y agoI think you're thinking of kWh, which are kilowatt hours. In which case, the answer is 20 kWh per hour.
- pg-gadfly 6y agoDepending on how many people a single point serves, it can imply a pretty sizeable chunk of energy. Smaller things add up when you're talking of hundreds of millions of people
- lcam84 6y agoThanks for the information. I know there are other things that consume more energy, but this is indicative of Jevons' paradox. When we have the choice between efficiency and productivity we choose the second. We could be replacing 4G technology with one with the same speed but less energy consumption, but that would never make economic sense. In my opinion resource efficiency is not an irrelevant goal but a goal contrary to this society. We must always consume more because otherwise there is no growth. Without that there is no creation of jobs and profits. The goals of the economy are opposite to those of ecology. The first is to produce as much as possible. It is no wonder that carbon emissions have only actually been reduced when there has been an economic decline. Now we are going to revitalise the economy with the green new deal, but if it is really efficient it will not generate profits or jobs. So it will only make the situation worse. I think 5G is another desperate measure to maintain this infinite growth in a world of finite resources.
- rsynnott 6y agoEfficiency isn’t irrelevant, but if you’re worried about efficiency, this isn’t worth caring about. A mast that can covers tens of thousands of people uses as much energy per day as driving an SUV for a couple of hours. If that mast lets one person work from home a few days a week, say, it has paid for itself energy-wise. If you’re worried about energy inefficiency, the best things to focus on are probably domestic insulation and reducing car usage. People tend to get hung up on the small stuff. It’s really bizarre to me that THIS is the aspect of consumerism that people go after for energy use. Improved access to the internet has substantial benefits to society; a little energy use is acceptable. SUVs and 5000sqft houses have no obvious benefit to society at all, and use vastly more energy than the telecoms industry could dream of using.
- pg-gadfly 6y ago>It’s really bizarre to me that THIS is the aspect of consumerism that people go after for energy use It's more common than you think. In fact it's so common that it has it's own Wikipedia page(s): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_triviality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_triviality
- lcam84 6y agoWe shouldn't counter-argument against something by saying there are worse things. Just because there are worse things does not mean that less bad things do not matter, especially since we have to reduce our carbon emissions substantially. Personally I don't have a car and I don't fly. I live in an area that has a climate that allows me not to spend too much on air conditioning (I don't have air conditioning), but again that's not the point [1]. We currently spend 5.6 billion tons of materials on communication equipment 5.6% of all our consumption [2]. These are not figures that we can ignore, especially since in my opinion it is one of the areas that we least need to spend. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism [2] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/jan/22/worlds-consumption-of-materials-hits-record-100bn-tonnes-a-year https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/jan/22/worlds-c...
- 6y ago
- BubRoss 6y agoWhere are these 10kw electric showers? Even 240v at 20amp is only 4.8kw.
- rsynnott 6y agoBEHOLD, terrifying 40 amp showers: https://www.screwfix.ie/c/bathrooms-kitchens/showers/cat820272?showerproducttype=electric https://www.screwfix.ie/c/bathrooms-kitchens/showers/cat8202... Getting less popular now that tankless gas and electric heating is a thing, but they're historically pretty common in some countries. They're more efficient than electric tank water heating approaches, and arguably more efficient than gas tanked systems, sometimes (usual caveats for comparing gas and electric heating apply). A major downside is that you typically can't have more than one, or at _most_ two, in one home. Some installations have a scary setup where there are two or more of them, but only one will operate at a time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]