4 ms·
> "The simplest complete model of an organism is the organism itself." But that is trivially true about everything, including golf balls. The interesting quest
by Ma8ee 6y ago
> "The simplest complete model of an organism is the organism itself."
But that is trivially true about everything, including golf balls. The interesting question isn't if the model is complete, but if it is sufficient (or complete enough) to make predictions.
And in the case of golf balls we can make quite good predictions with a very simple model, mostly because we are only interested in if it ends up in the hole or not. But a complete model of a golf ball would need to include the exact dynamics of the different layers and the turbulence around it, which we just can't do. Luckily, we don't need to.
So what is a sufficient model of a living organism? That of course also depends on what we want to know. I am quite certain that modern egg farmers have, for their purposes, quite sufficient models of hens. They know how fast the hens grow, the effects of different amounts and types of food, how much heat they produce, and of course how many and how big eggs they lay, etc..
And it is of course possible that we need to know the exact wave function for the complete system that is the cell to model it sufficiently enough to, say, synthesise new drugs. But I don't think so.
- Gatsky 6y agoIt is definitely not trivially true about anything. A golf ball can be modelled easily. You are adding external complications to the system. An electron can be impossible to model if you inject it into a complex system. Anyway the point is a golf ball will not evolve into a sentient being who will then fly to mars and write poetry, which is what cells have done. This shows you can’t even put a meaningful bound on what you need to model for an organism.
- Ma8ee 6y agoBut that is not a complete model of a golf ball. A complete model will include the wave function of all the particles in golf ball. It won’t be simpler than the model an organism of the same size. And in this case I mean by simpler that the number of bits required would be lower. How does the capacity of the thing you try to model affect the complexity of the model?