3 ms·
This comment x 1000. (Some) Engineers think they have it all figured out. And they do...because someone figured it out all for them, and they get to work with
by rrmm 6y ago
This comment x 1000. (Some) Engineers think they have it all figured out. And they do...because someone figured it out all for them, and they get to work with the benefit of that knowledge.
This is a polemical statement, I'm closer to an engineer than a scientists and I really like having a solid model to work from. It took me a long time to understand how useful approximations are to solving hard problems. Because I didn't want to know the approximations, I wanted a perfect model.
(Oddly, I came to understand the power of approximations in terms of electronics. Electronics are filled with rules of thumb that help you figure out how your circuit works and help to elucidate the behaviors that are important to you.
But it took me awhile to get over myself and use them. It was honestly a huge road block to progress in learning.)
My own take-aways: getting knowledge (de novo, ex nihilo) and applying knowledge are two very important things, but are separate skills. Ideally you'd like to have both.
Secondly science is difficult because you are trying to figure out true things in the face of glaring uncertainties.
- danielscrubs 6y agoMy biggest pet peeve is the use of term computer science as something you get knowledge of from coding. The latest Gödel Prize award for computer science was awarded for "their constructive proof of the Lovász Local Lemma". How many of the self proclaimed computer scientist would be able to read the math formulas Cynthia Dwork (latest Knuth Prize winner) wrote in her paper The Algorithmic Foundations of Differential Privacy? That's what you get from a Computer Science degree. How many of those theorems became understandable to someone just from coding? You have to hit the books, the CS-books. It's like someone saying they know law because they know english, and english is what is used in the end. Sorry for the rant.