5 ms·
Reddit slammed by former CEO Ellen Pao for 'amplifying' racism and hate
- Y_Y 6y agoYou have a website aimed at humanity in general, and it turns out that people are interested in this kind of stuff. I think the corporate dream of having all the "good, clean, fun" with none of the complicated not-on-brand stuff is generally impossible. You have to take people as they are, whether or not you find them "deplorable". Or just run a really niche website.
- uniqueid 6y agoGod himself did not invent the internet, the web, or social media websites. There are actual design decisions that went into their design (eg: https://www.ietf.org/standards/rfcs/ https://www.ietf.org/standards/rfcs/). Humans, like you and me, made them, and continue to make them. Many of those decisions were unfortunate in that they do not hold people accountable when they should be (eg: sociopaths, criminals, psyops, etc) and yet discourage good actors from interacting online (due to reputational damage, persecution by mobs, occasional murder, privacy concerns, etc). Humans do not behave like walking garbage all of the time in the offline world. They do on social media, because of naive design decisions that we should probably change, if we want to survive as a species.
- sremani 6y agoWith the power of hindsight.. I want to congratulate all reddit stakeholders who got her fired. You got that decision right.
- haunter 6y agoReddit has general problem with everything. For example yesterday the front page and /r/all were both having an /r/bestof conspiracy theory post that the police directly planting bricks near the protests to insitagate violence https://www.reddit.com/r/bestof/comments/gv4xds/umetamaoz_provides_evidence_that_the_police_are/ https://www.reddit.com/r/bestof/comments/gv4xds/umetamaoz_pr... The general Reddit hivemimd is basically: - If you are not with us you are against us - Whatever doesn't fit my view on the world is a big part of some kind of hidden agenda against the things I care about That's the site. Also fueled by the downvote upvote system which makes everything worse.
- aspaviento 6y agoAnd don't forget: - do and say everything needed to get karma points.
- bmarquez 6y agoYup. Another thing that's common is that people will look at your posting history in order to discredit you, according to that "if you're not with us you're against us" principle. I've seen this happen with political views, operating systems, and even city subreddits.
- aestetix 6y agoThis is a big reason why I don't comment on reddit.
- ornornor 6y agoIt feels like if you’re using Reddit for politics and news you’re doing it wrong. It’s a dumpster fire in that respect. I still find Reddit has some relevance for more “niche” interests. For instance bikewrench To help with anything bicycle maintenance related. Or woodworking where there are many knowledgeable and friendly users. If you’re blocking ads and not playing the Reddit gold game, you’re not really giving Reddit any money. In an ideal world we’d get rid of Reddit altogether but that’s already a step. Wait until they disable old.reddit.com and restrict the api to their official app only and they’ll lose all their users I reckon except the people arguing about politics.
- masonic 6y agoPao has quite a knack for landing in "hostile workplaces".
- gjs278 6y agoellen can fuck off. some parts of the internet are just meant to be fun and don’t need to be moderated beyond what is illegal content.
- mrtksn 6y agoAs I recall Ellen Pao had her own set of scandals and she was portrayed quite negatively on the news and social media. Correct me if I am wrong but at that time the main issue with Reddit was the "barely legal" content, that is the subreddits with underage girl photos and videos that were shared with obvious pornographic intent but nothing illegal strictly speaking. At that time some argued that Pao was a CEO hired for one mission: To take down that questionable content. I don't know how many people are missing the underage girl photos in Reddit but the demand voices for it died of. Maybe it wasn't a free speech issue after all. Maybe Reddit's or any large community's issue is the disproportional amplification of marginal voices, making them mainstream. It's not really about the idea that these voices have but about the amount of noise that they create giving the impression that there is a large demand for it and due to the mechanics of the community the fake demand brings up the supply. The sub in question, The_Donald, is not a place of free speech. It is heavily moderated to push a narrative but if you don't pay attention you may have the impression that this is an organic forum and people simply arrived at these hateful ideas after a thorough discussion. Analytics also would catch on this and the obvious business decision would be to amplify that content that appears to be on-demand.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThat was one of many things wrong with Reddit at the time, others were the racist subreddits like coontown, and the bullying subreddits like fatpeoplehate - see also https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/jun/10/reddit-bans-five-subreddits-harrassment-concerns https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/jun/10/reddit-ba.... If you tolerate stuff like that, you are complicit. She took a hard fall for making those decisions and I think could've handled it better, but it needed to be done.
- caymanjim 6y agoAlready deleted Twitter and Reddit accounts. Deleting Facebook as soon as I gather alternate contact information for people. Hiding behind free speech claims while profiting off of and actively promoting hate is unacceptable. There are limits to free speech, and while I don't think it's the government's place to legislate or regulate it, I'm not going to support any of these companies any more. Arguments about a commons, not talking sides, and freedom ring hollow. I don't condone violence, but the kind of speech these sites allow and promote would get you punched in the face at the very least, if you couldn't hide anonymously behind a screen. People wouldn't speak the same way if they had to face their audience in the real world. All these platforms (and others) hand a megaphone to the worst of humanity. It's unacceptable. I'm done.
- not_a_moth 6y agoThe problem stems from interest groups using reddit as a political battleground. This is overwhelmingly evident on election years. Even one of my favorite subreddits of a popular non political podcaster in recent months has been inundated with political accounts who do nothing but try to discredit and bury viewpoints they don't like. Worldnews, news, politics are so incredibly one-sided it feels orwellian and creeps me out. That's the sad state of reddit today from a user of 10+ years.
- Mengkudulangsat 6y agoReddit is nigh unusable without the RES pluggin. I use Reddit daily and every time I see suspicious users / subs I add them to my RES filter. It's now hundreds of names long, but my front page of the internet gets to be the way I like it.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoIs there a way to have a shared blocklist so it can be made a community effort? I believe this is a thing with Twitter as well. Of course, ideally you could block people in Reddit's own software, and said users would be flagged / banned if they appear on enough people's blocklists.
- Mengkudulangsat 6y agoIt's an oft-requested feature, kind of like Easylist. I don't think it's a good move. Everyone's filter bubble should be unique.
- drevil-v2 6y agoWhat would you say are your top 5 features in RES which makes Reddit more palatable? I have never used it but I can definitely see the need
- Mengkudulangsat 6y agoHonestly I've used RES for so long, I can no longer tell which features are from RES and which ones are from Reddit. Absolutely worth it even if just for these filters.
- ramblerman 6y agoReddit is a mess, on all sides. It's ok, in the quest for social justice, to just go on witchhunts and post videos of anyone online. I can't imagine the amount of unjust damage they have done by just randomnly posting peoples photos and names online. Take for example the "Karen" meme. Any suburbian mum who has a fit in a public space is now called a "Karen", and it's fine to post their video online to mock them and hopefully "get them fired". A 5 minute mistake can cost you your career. That just doesn't seem like a road to progress, or a better world imo. Chasing absolute morality without a shred of empathy. The website is the online personification of "Lord of the flies".
- ablqp 6y agoThis is the same Pao who talked about "incels". And that is the problem in a nutshell. The people who portray themselves as good (often for monetary gain) are so vicious that they provoke a counter reaction. Previously leftists (or limousine leftists) fighting for something attacked politicians and institutions. Now they attack regular people directly online and also offline -- Hillary Clinton's "basket of deplorables" was unheard of in earlier times. What you see in the right is a backlash. I wonder if some left hard liners (perhaps unbeknownst to themselves) are planted and financed by the right as agent provocateurs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]