4 ms·
The second clip I've looked at claims "The Police try to break up the peaceful protest by resorting to hitting individuals with batons.". What ACTUALLY happens
by onion2k 6y ago
The second clip I've looked at claims "The Police try to break up the peaceful protest by resorting to hitting individuals with batons.".
What ACTUALLY happens is that they cut out all context of what led up to the situation, and cut in to a point where anybody with half a brain could see that the cops had been giving lawful orders for rioters to disperse, for what was probably a long time, they're on a loudspeaker giving them lawful orders to disperse, warning them that if they don't disperse force will be used against them, they decide to ignore lawful orders, and force is used against them to make them disperse.
The way the headline makes it sound, they were just nice peaceful protesters, not causing any problems, and police just rolled in and started beating them.
Protest is legal, and ignoring a "lawful police order" is also legal. The police can't just tell people what to do. Neither of those things warrant being assaulted by a police officer. Your own description of what happened is that the police used force to disperse peaceful protestors, which is obviously unacceptable.
- read_if_gay_ 6y ago> The police can't just tell people what to do. That’s like the whole point of the police.
- adjkant 6y agoIt's called abuse of power. Police should be enforcing laws, not their own will. Police 100% cannot tell people to do anything. The issue is the law is not good at defining these things, leading to this exact issue of mass scale police brutality. If you think the police have that much latitude in their power, you're missing the entire point of the protests.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoNo it is not. The police are there to uphold the law, not dictate what people do. If someone's protesting they are exercising their rights and the police has no right to intervene. If someone is looting however, sure, then they can step in - with appropriate force, which in most cases does not involve shooting them in the face.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoYes. Upholding the law necessarily involves telling people what to do. They cannot arbitrarily tell people what to do, but that’s not what I was arguing.
- TheGrim-888 6y ago"The police can't just tell people what to do" What world do you live in? I could just go on a murder spree and when police come to arrest me I can just tell them "you can't tell me what to do", and they'll say "shucks, he's right, guess we'll let him on his way". By the way, you're being doublespeaky when you say "protest is legal". It sure is. But the vast majority of these altercations come from after a group has been declared a riot, a public safety hazard, and ordered to disperse. They're no longer peaceful protesters when the cops have to use force to shut it down.
- adjkant 6y ago> But the vast majority of these altercations come from after a group has been declared a riot This is typically after police have antagonized the situation and created it through tactics like kettling and surrounding protesters and then throwing grenades of tear gas and misusing rubber bullets in potentially lethal ways on nonviolent crowds. "declared a riot" is political speak for when the police don't like a protest and begin attacking.
- TheGrim-888 6y agoIn your mind, cops really just see a peaceful protest and just decide to start fucking with them? "Oh look at all those peaceful people, let's just start shooting and gassing them"? Really? You really think that nothing led up to it? You haven't seen the hundreds of hours of "peaceful protesters" turning into riots, looting, spending hours throwing rocks, bricks, piss, fireworks, and more at cops that are just doing their job? Are you really that brainwashed? You think there's some giant conspiracy where all of these cops, across the whole country, are just evil people that love hurting people for no reason?
- fzeroracer 6y agoCan you explain what the cops [1] were doing to this car and what is their rationale for destroying someone else's property? Was the car resisting arrest? [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/ThatsInsane/comments/gv2ogk/news_chopper_pans_out_as_riverside_county_sheriff/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ThatsInsane/comments/gv2ogk/news_ch...
- newacct583 6y ago> The police can't just tell people what to do. Well, to be clear: they can. Courts have given police very wide latitude on what they're allowed to compel from the public in the execution of their duties. This is sort of the problem. That said, your second point is really the meat here. Faced with civilians refusing their orders, it is not appropriate for the police to resort to any and all means to compel obediance. No one thinks it is. Especially conservatives, under normal circumstances (who, it seems, are a little confused right now). I mean... most of the same people who two weeks ago were all "You can't tell I'm supposed to stay at home, that's tyranny!" are now all of a sudden all "You can't stay in that park if the president wants to be there! You should be tear gassed![1]" [1] Excuse me: "pepper balls", which is totally not the same thing because it disperses a fine suspended powder and never enters a gas phase.
- gremlinsinc 6y agoWhat do you think they'd say if they were hit by pepper spray and tear gas at the next anti-lockdown rally?
- jcims 6y ago> Protest is legal, and ignoring a "lawful police order" is also legal. The police can't just tell people what to do. This is a pretty thin hair to split. The police can’t ‘tell you what to do’, but the law can and part of the job of the police is to communicate and enforce the law. Anyone going to a protest is definitely advised to understand their rights at the local, state and federal level so you can differentiate between the two.