3 ms·
The judiciary is not a legislative body. I don't think anyone is claiming it is. But it acts, in practice, often as a legislative body. Certainly any applicatio
by renewiltord 6y ago
The judiciary is not a legislative body. I don't think anyone is claiming it is. But it acts, in practice, often as a legislative body. Certainly any application of judicial activism is indistinguishable from legislation due to the use of judicial precedence, i.e. it is parallel law-making.
For what it's worth, the nature of the judiciary appointed by representatives chosen by voters is just slow representative democracy. It is no surprise that, given the ability to make a law-like, appointed in a manner that is representative-like, they act lawmaker-like.
They are, in their activism, isomorphic to lawmakers. That's what judicial activism is. In a POSIWID sense, the judiciary are lawmakers, no matter what you call them, like North Korea is a dictatorship despite being called a Democratic People's Republic.
- clairity 6y agono, you're trying to stretch concepts past the breaking point to fit a desired narrative. the judiciary isn't a parallel lawmaking body. the legislation has corrective oversight of judiciary interpretation (outside of consitutional issues). that the legislature only exercises their oversight selectively inconsistent to your wishes is not a judicial issue. also, "judicial activism" is a loaded term. the judiciary is doing exactly and only what it's tasked to do--interpret law against the backdrop of the constitition; it's not a bug if you disagree with its decisions.
- renewiltord 6y agoI don't. I love it's decisions, I'm glad they made them, and I said as much, but that doesn't change that they're making law.