4 ms·
https://static.cambridge.org/binary/version/id/urn:cambridge.org:id:binary:20200423073226266-0814:S0003055420000052:S0003055420000052_tab1.gif?pub-status=live h
by rayiner 6y ago
https://static.cambridge.org/binary/version/id/urn:cambridge.org:id:binary:20200423073226266-0814:S0003055420000052:S0003055420000052_tab1.gif?pub-status=live https://static.cambridge.org/binary/version/id/urn:cambridge...
So they have a list of “undemocratic” behaviors, such as biased redistricting. But it doesn’t include using courts to secure laws that one side would be unable to get through the ordinary legislative process. That’s one of the most profoundly undemocratic things about the US. (Not bad, which is debatable, but by definition undemocratic.) So many major policies, from abortion to the role of religion in the public sphere are decided in America by unelected judges, whereas Europe for the most part manages to pass legislation on the same issues through democratic consensus. But social scientists steeped in American liberal ideology don’t even perceive this as anti-Democratic (again, different from good or bad).
This popped into my head reading the first paragraph, so I scrolled down to see what they thought were “undemocratic” things. Sure enough.
- drewcoo 6y agoSo judges. Just judges. Judges deal with things that haven't been specifically legislated. You're saying judges are antidemocratic because we don't vote on their decisions. This applies equally to any individual's choice, then, I suppose.
- denkmoon 6y agoAny individual's choices do not influence the laws of a polity, generally.
- Tehdasi 6y agoComparing Australia to the US, the difference is that in the US what happens is that the Supreme court rules on a law, and the ruling directs how the government implements the law for the next 50 years. In Australia the High court makes a ruling then legislation is put into the next legislative session to 'fix up' the issue with the existing law. Although this doesn't always happen, it seems to be the most common outcome.
- smnrchrds 6y agoReminds me of the time a court ruling made hard drugs legal in Ireland. The legislature fixed the law in a matter of hours. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/ireland-just-accidentally-legalised-ecstasy-ketamine-and-crystal-meth-10098612.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/ireland-just...
- rsynnott 6y agoThat wasn’t on a constitutional issue, though. In 1992, the Irish Supreme Court found that there was a right to abortion where a person was suicidal (at the time abortion was generally illegal in Ireland), on a constitutional basis. The government attempted to amend the constitution by referendum to remove this, but that failed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mnm1 6y agoThat's how the US system is supposed to work too. You're just pointing out its failure, not some fundamental difference.
- jbeam 6y agoThere needs to be a distinction here between SCOTUS rulings on constitutional issues versus rulings based on statute. Many if not most of the decisions that the Supreme Court hands down could be changed by the legislature. These are based on interpreting statute. For example, recently the court unanimously overturned the conviction of two New Jersey officials who were involved in a scandal involving shutting down an interstate bridge for political revenge. The majority opinion, that again was unanimously agreed to, went out of its way to say that their acts were reprehensible. But the statute that was used to charge them didn’t cover their acts. This is something that can be changed by the legislature easily and there’s no issue at all. The issue comes with the constitutional ones. These get the most press and tend to be the ones that are most controversial. But the alternatives aren’t much better. Besides the historic reasons for SCOTUS supremacy in this area starting with Marbury v. Madison, there are legitimate concerns with having the interpretation of your constitution being subject to the whims of the most recently elected body. Of course, this has led to the current nightmare where Supreme Court seats are hotly divisive contests to be won. Changing the makeup of the court is a battlefield and for the life of me I cannot see a way to fix that. Changing the number of justices or setting term limits will be seen as court packing by whichever party attempts it. It might result in open rebellion. Things are very fragile here and we are teetering on the edge.
- mdorazio 6y agoNot sure I agree with your assessment of the questions asked. Question 3 is related to if the governor should rule by executive order if the opposing party doesn't cooperate. This is pretty much exactly what you're saying in your second sentence, just with executive orders instead of courts (bypassing the normal law process vs. monopolizing it). Question 4 is then about ignoring unfavorable court rulings, which again is pretty close to the undemocratic things you're referring to.
- rossdavidh 6y agoThe executive is at least elected, while the courts are not, even indirectly. More importantly, in recent decades one part has more often obtained what it wanted through the courts, another through executive order. Having them both as examples of undemocratic, would have made the questions more nonpartisan. As written, it seems pretty clearly written from a left-of-center position. If the study questions had been written during FDR's time, when the courts were striking down parts of the New Deal and FDR was expanding the powers of the executive in order to expand the social welfare net, we likely would see different questions used as examples of undemocratic behavior.
- caf 6y agoIn recentish times the courts have been striking down parts of Obamacare, gun control and campaign finance legislation too, though.
- JoshTriplett 6y agoIn general, the judicial branch can't quite make new law, but they can throw out (in whole or in part) or place limitations on an existing law. (There's some nuance to that.) That seems like a relevant distinction to draw, as it's an intentional aspect of the checks and balances between branches of government.
- umanwizard 6y agoThis isn’t true. In common-law jurisdictions, making new law is the primary role of appeals courts.
- wahern 6y agoIt's definitely not the primary role. It's principally a consequence of stare decisis. And even though stare decisis is the defining characteristic of the common law, in actuality many other jurisdictions apply the principle, including in Europe, just without formalizing it. The promotion of consistency is a nearly universal characteristic of all human legal systems, and stare decisis is consistency reified. [1] In terms of the exercise of de facto law making powers the United States is somewhat of an outlier owing to the fact it was one of the first to explore how to apply the principles of 1) separation of powers and 2) to do so in the context of a Federal system. Also, the concept of Parliamentary Supremacy solidified in England after the American colonial legal system had begun to evolve on its own. So for these reasons it's unsurprising we ended up diverging from England, and that other former British colonies didn't end up with lawmaking powers quite as extensive as in the U.S. Similarly, it's unsurprising that the evolution of European Union legal rules arguably mirror much of what happened in the U.S.--de facto application of stare decisis, de facto judicial review powers of top EU courts, etc. [1] Here's an interesting 1988 law review article that includes an exploration of the legal system of revolutionary France: "Tort Liability in France for the Act of Things: A Study of Judicial Lawmaking", https://digitalcommons.law.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=5129&context=lalrev https://digitalcommons.law.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?artic... The French so despised the practice of judicial lawmaking that they made it a criminal offense for judges to disambiguate the law, mandating that courts instead refer any legislative ambiguities to the Congress for interpretation. Guess how often that happened. So if you start from the premise that an intrinsic function of the courts is disambiguation, and combine it with the principle of consistent application of the law, guess where you end up. See also "Why Europe Rejected American Judicial Review and Why It May Not Matter", https://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2295&context=fss_papers https://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti...
- clairity 6y agofirst, the US is a representative democracy, not a direct democracy. we don't vote on every little legal precedent. second, judges and the judicial system are a check on executive and legislative power, not a lawmaking body. please keep partisanship out of such analyses. if your ideas are good, they can stand on their own merits without trying to rally the party faithful (ironic, given the thread title).
- treeman79 6y agoWell said. Founders deeply distrusted democracy. Government in general, which is why system is setup to be so inefficient at change
- scarmig 6y agoThe Founders deeply distrusted democracy, but loved big government. That's why they built the ability in for constituent governing bodies to construct and maintain a state apparatus for the totalitarian control of a mass slave population. Moreover, they built into the Constitution the ability for the federal government to assist in the operation of that apparatus.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrisco255 6y agoTheir point is that judges sometimes rule on cases beyond what the law explicitly states. Gay marriage was one such case. Abortion another. I would argue the Eminent Domain (for private construction, to eliminate blight) ruling from a few years ago was also another example of judges ruling beyond the law. Their rulings create de facto laws or regulations many times beyond the letter of the law. I don't think it's right but whether you agree with the Supreme Court's position is often dependent on your political leaning in that particular case, even if the ruling does go against the letter of the law.
- rsynnott 6y ago
- rpiguy 6y agoThey also forgot to mention a huge one - supports suppressing the political speech of your opponents. Both parties are guilty of this, but the Left is outright determined to regulate speech, shut down the sharing of information they consider dangerous, or deem hateful. Also the paper might want to examine the executive branch leaders of each party to see who actually, consistently legislates or attempts to legislate through executive order (hint, it isn't Republicans).
- mrmario27 6y agoThe current president has issued more executive orders than the previous... care to elaborate or support your claim?
- Enginerrrd 6y agoWikipedia says that's not true. And he's really about on track to match his contemporary predecessors. According to the table, he's issued substantially fewer than every president before him until you get has far back as Benjamin Harrison. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_order https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_order
- _emacsomancer_ 6y agoIf you think the Dems are the Left....I don't know what to tell you.
- rsynnott 6y ago> So many major policies, from abortion to the role of religion in the public sphere are decided in America by unelected judges, whereas Europe for the most part manages to pass legislation on the same issues through democratic consensus. I’m not sure that’s entirety true. It is true that the US tends to act on courts alone more often; that is, it doesn’t bother legislating at all. But a lot of civil rights issues in many European countries originate in the courts; the government acts when it realises the courts are going to do something. This is particularly true of the ECHR.