3 ms·
IMO the default for body text should be serif, with sans used for headlines and display text. There’s a reason books and magazines are set in serif fonts: they
by pavlov 6y ago
IMO the default for body text should be serif, with sans used for headlines and display text.
There’s a reason books and magazines are set in serif fonts: they are easier to read for long text paragraphs.
GUIs defaulted to sans serif fonts because displays didn’t have enough resolution to properly render serifs, but that’s mostly not the case anymore.
- mrob 6y agoI don't think there's anything inherently more legible about either serif or sans-serif fonts. Whichever one you read the most will be most legible to you, which means the default shouldn't be changed even when it's no longer technically necessary.
- technothrasher 6y agoCommon wisdom is that serif fonts are easier to read, but most research I've read on the topic show either very small or no readability increase with serif over san-serif fonts. As an example: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4612630/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4612630/
- mark-r 6y agoThe studies that show an advantage for serif fonts are old, and were done with printed samples. I doubt their conclusions apply to the screen.
- pavlov 6y agoI don't think it's obvious either way. Reading on paper vs. high-DPI screens isn't that different. Text-oriented software like Kindle and Medium default to serif fonts, but I don't know if they have any research to back that up. I suppose Amazon's usability people might have even bothered to look into that. Of course a large part of this is simply that you read fastest what you read the most.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- quietbritishjim 6y agoMost monitors are definitely still not high enough resolution to render serif fonts more clearly than sans serif ones. (By resolution, I mean the original meaning of pixel density per unit area, not the modern usage of total pixel count.) Mobile screens are obviously higher resolution so it's less clear cut, but sans serif are still a bit clearer in my view. I think the problem here is that the text is much smaller in physical size, so now the resolution of the human eye has come into play.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y ago> By resolution, I mean the original meaning of pixel density per unit area, not the modern usage of total pixel count. Interesting - I wasn't aware "resolution" was ever used this way. PPI (pixels per inch) and "pixel density" are common terms for this now.
- pavlov 6y agoIn printing, resolution traditionally meant DPI.
- snowwrestler 6y agoResolution goes back even farther than that, to the number of line pairs that could be "resolved" (distinguished from one other) in an image. It was a way to compare the ability of imaging systems to capture and accurately display fine detail. With digital sensors and screens you can pretty much just calculate it directly since you can't resolve detail below the pixel level. But, note that moire can eliminate fine detail well above pixel level if not controlled. Before that, there were standard targets with fine lines in tight tapering patterns. Folks would take a picture of the target with a particular lens and film, and then count the smallest line pairs they could make out before the taper disappeared into an undifferentiated blur. By varying lenses and films, they could compare resolution. Example: https://www.onlandscape.co.uk/2014/12/36-megapixels-vs-6x7-velvia/ https://www.onlandscape.co.uk/2014/12/36-megapixels-vs-6x7-v...
- dhosek 6y agoWhen I first became interested in type, monitors typically had a resolution in the neighborhood of 72–96ppi. My MBP, according to Apple's support site, has a resolution of 226ppi. Back in the 80s I had speculated that 300ppi was a minimum for good typography, but maybe it's my aging eyesight, but I find that what I've got on my laptop is more than sufficient to use most typefaces (and the fact that there's no pixel spread likely helps with the slight lack of resolution), although more subtle designs, like Optima really want a resolution of at least 1200ppi.
- hatmatrix 6y agoIt's also hard to distinguish among numbers in many sans serif fonts.
- namibj 6y agoTake a look at "Input Sans Narrow Light". Example/demo: https://input.fontbureau.com/preview/?size=14&language=xml&theme=monokai&family=InputSans&width=300&weight=300&line-height=1.2&a=0&g=0&i=0&l=0&zero=0&asterisk=0&braces=0&preset=default&customize=please https://input.fontbureau.com/preview/?size=14&language=xml&t...
- smcl 6y agoQuick question - "body text" and "headlines" are clear to me but what is "display text"?
- gjm11 6y agoPretty much anything that isn't body text. Headings. Words on posters. Book covers and spines. Advertisements (unless they're very wordy ones). Street signs. Of course these don't all want the same sort of treatment, but they have some features in common: you're not going to be reading a lot of whatever-it-is at one go, and there probably aren't going to be multiple lines of text. So you don't care so much about things like how comfortable it is to read in bulk or whether blocks of text look good in overall shape/density, and being quirky or distractingly eye-catching might be a feature rather than a bug.