5 ms·
> "Waiting until we're more sure about something" is not actually waiting, it is an affirmative decision to disregard what we think we know right now. No, it's
by pdonis 6y ago
> "Waiting until we're more sure about something" is not actually waiting, it is an affirmative decision to disregard what we think we know right now.
No, it's an affirmative choice to not impose a public policy on everyone based on what we think we know right now. And often that is the right choice.
> To make such an argument requires attacking that knowledge directly, showing specifically how it's wrong. Not just vaguely complaining that it's not good enough yet.
You have this backwards. Claimed knowledge doesn't get to be assumed to be right until it's shown to be wrong. It needs to demonstrate that it's right with a sufficient level of confidence before it even gets considered at all. "Not good enough yet" just means "you haven't shown your claims to be right with enough confidence to make them worth considering in this public policy debate".
> leaders act to address needs in real time, making the best decisions they can with the information available to them.
"Leaders" aren't the only ones who act to address needs in real time and make decisions. Everybody does that. Often the best thing for "leaders" to do is to not make any decisions at all as "leaders", but to simply let individual people, who have far more accurate information about their individual situations than any "leader" can possibly have, make their own decisions.
For a "leader" to make a decision and dictate a public policy, the policy needs to be based on knowledge that is strong enough to justify overriding the billions of individual decisions that people are making all the time about their individual lives, with a top-down dictated decision that everybody must follow. That's a much, much stricter requirement than most people appear to think.
- snowwrestler 6y agoEveryone is already under the imposition of public policy, right now. Today's society is not neutral just because it is today. Edit to add: the public policy imposed on us today is based on what we thought we knew back when it was put in place.
- pdonis 6y ago> Everyone is already under the imposition of public policy, right now. To the extent that this is true, it is, IMO, mostly a bug, not a feature. > the public policy imposed on us today is based on what we thought we knew back when it was put in place. If you seriously believe the public policies we have today were all based on the best current knowledge at the time they were put in place, all I can say is that you have a most charming naivete.
- snowwrestler 6y agoI don't think I claimed they were based on "best current knowledge," but I hope we can agree that is an ideal to aspire to.
- pdonis 6y ago> I hope we can agree that is an ideal to aspire to. It's an ideal to aspire to, but only if the ideal includes a very strict standard on what level of knowledge justifies dictating a public policy at all.
- jbay808 6y agosnowwrestler has repeatedly made the point that you can't not have a public policy about something; you can only accept or change the status quo. England has a public policy that people drive on the left. America has a public policy that people drive on the right. In a society that had no codified rule about which side of the road to drive on, where people just weave back and forth, the choice to not enforce a particular convention would also be a defacto public policy. It seems to me that in general you should only need the preponderance of evidence to suggest that a public policy change will do more good than harm in order to adopt it; otherwise you're unnecessarily biasing yourself in favour of the status quo. This of course should be done with an appropriate risk-weighting decision theory (how you weigh a small chance of large negative utility against a large chance of small positive utility, etc).
- pdonis 6y ago> England has a public policy that people drive on the left. America has a public policy that people drive on the right. Neither of these policies were imposed by government. They were conventions that naturally evolved without any top-level policy being dictated, because they are obvious ways of solving an obvious coordination problem about using roads, and only got codified in law after that natural process of evolution had taken place. > in general you should only need the preponderance of evidence to suggest that a public policy change will do more good than harm in order to adopt it Even this standard, while it is weaker than the one I have suggested for what is needed to dictate public policy to everyone, is still strong enough to exclude many public policies that are currently in force, or suggested.
- didibus 6y agoHum, I think both of you provide a good point. Ultimately though, I have to agree with snowwrestler, public policy often needs to make a decision with incomplete information. There's probably a middle ground here, I'd say having 70% of the information, something like that. Otherwise, it is too slow to act to prevent future problems. In that regard, I feel it's best paralleled with business. Business decisions are often made with incomplete information, to get a competitive advantage. But you always need to weigh the risk/reward potential. Feel it's the same for public policy. Depending on the potential risk of a particular policy, pitched against the level of confidence in the information that supports it, and you can arrive at a decision. I don't think it make sense to say, always wait for the confidence level to be approaching 100%. You've got to take calculated risks sometimes.
- bobbydroptables 6y agoI think only snowwrestler has a good point. "Waiting for the science" is the same as saying "we know for a fact that burning carbon is safe" if both of those result in burning unsustainable amounts of carbon. >I'd say having 70% of the information, something like that. This is still missing the point. This means that you need only 31% of science to continue burning carbon, but you need 70% to stop burning carbon. You have created an asymmetry that's not justified by anything (let alone science). Public policy cannot be agnostic about the science. It's not possible. If you say "let's wait" you're saying "it's safe to keep doing what we're doing" even though you don't have any justification for that. To put it really simply, you've created a default bias. There is no reason to assume the default is better than a given alternative. It needs to be justified. If you can justify it, fine and good, let's do it. But no one has.
- pdonis 6y ago> If you say "let's wait" you're saying "it's safe to keep doing what we're doing" even though you don't have any justification for that. As I responded elsewhere in this thread, by this criterion, we should stop pretty much everything we are doing. Which is not a viable option, never has been, and never will be.
- bobbydroptables 6y ago>No, it's an affirmative choice to not impose a public policy on everyone based on what we think we know right now. You're either misunderstanding his point or misunderstanding reality. Our public policy today endorses (and heavily subsidizes) the burning of carbon on a scale never before tested. Why should the default position be to subsidize this as opposed to alternative means? Or are you arguing that we should be agnostic about the science and thus stop burning all carbon immediately (i.e., returning to a scientifically validated state in the past where we didn't burn carbon)? >You have this backwards. Claimed knowledge doesn't get to be assumed to be right until it's shown to be wrong. I'm guessing you have it backwards but I'll let you explain. Which knowledge do you think we are claiming that we shouldn't assume to be right? Give a concrete example and we can discuss. If you think we can "assume its safe to burn obscene amounts of carbon" without any evidence of that safety, then you are the one who has it backwards. You can't make a public policy that is agnostic to the science of burning of fossil fuels at current levels. It's clearly unsustainable, but let's set that aside. If you want to argue it's sustainable and should continue, you would still need to rely on (nonexistent) science to make your case. It's not an argument to say "this is how we done things for a long time so this way doesn't need to be supported by science." That's illogical.
- pdonis 6y ago> Why should the default position be to subsidize this as opposed to alternative means? I don't think the government should be subsidizing any energy sources or playing favorites with certain sources over others. That applies just as much to playing favorites in favor of "alternative" energy sources as to playing favorites in favor of oil, coal, and natural gas. (Actually the government subsidizes all of these.) However, that has nothing to do with any beliefs about the relative risks of different energy sources. It has to do with a belief that government subsidizing anything or playing favorites in general is likely to do more harm than good. In other words, the government does not have reliable enough knowledge to justify favoring any energy source over any other, so it shouldn't. > It's clearly unsustainable, but let's set that aside. No, let's not. Let's ask, instead, why you apparently believe that the only way to fix anything that is "unsustainable" is government policy. Why not just let the market work? If governments would stop subsiziding fossil fuels, their prices would be higher, and there would be more market pressure to find alternatives. Just as we found alternatives to horses that saved us from the "unsustainable" practice in the late 19th century of using horses for transportation, which, if that had gone on the same way, would have us all by now, as the saying goes, knee deep in horsesxxt. (And people were predicting exactly that at the time.) > It's not an argument to say "this is how we done things for a long time so this way doesn't need to be supported by science." That's illogical. No, it's not, it's a fact of life. Most of the things we currently do are not "supported by science". We do not have well-supported scientific rationales for most of our current activities. That's because we don't have a good scientific understanding of the relevant domains for most of our current activities. But just stopping all of our current activities that aren't "supported by science" is not a viable alternative, never has been, and never will be. So it's you that is being illogical, not me.