4 ms·
> Working without knowing whether you're correct is not epistemological conflict. It's the fundamental condition of being a scientist. This is true, but it's a
by pdonis 6y ago
> Working without knowing whether you're correct is not epistemological conflict. It's the fundamental condition of being a scientist.
This is true, but it's also true that, when making public policy, we should be thinking like engineers, not scientists. Public policy is not about constructing new knowledge. It's about working out conflicts between different values and priorities based on our best current knowledge. To the extent the article is talking about public policy, I think it makes a valid point that the limitations of our knowledge in areas highly relevant to public policy are very often not recognized or taken into account when making public policy.
- snowwrestler 6y agoThere are no sidelines in public policy. There's nowhere to wait to see how things turn out before making a decision. So, there are no neutral decisions. "Waiting until we're more sure about something" is not actually waiting, it is an affirmative decision to disregard what we think we know right now. That can be a valid choice, and something to debate, but it's fundamentally different from the feined neutrality of the concept of waiting to see. To make such an argument requires attacking that knowledge directly, showing specifically how it's wrong. Not just vaguely complaining that it's not good enough yet. This is actually well-understood in public policy when it comes to other areas like economics or defense; leaders act to address needs in real time, making the best decisions they can with the information available to them. "A good plan violently executed now is better than a perfect plan executed at some indefinite time in the future.” ― General Patton Engineering, as a discipline, cannot cover all of life. It largely constrains itself to situations that are understood, and can do so because there are other complementary disciplines that create the knowledge it uses. But in public policy there's not a complementary Earth or society that we can wait for.
- pdonis 6y ago> "Waiting until we're more sure about something" is not actually waiting, it is an affirmative decision to disregard what we think we know right now. No, it's an affirmative choice to not impose a public policy on everyone based on what we think we know right now. And often that is the right choice. > To make such an argument requires attacking that knowledge directly, showing specifically how it's wrong. Not just vaguely complaining that it's not good enough yet. You have this backwards. Claimed knowledge doesn't get to be assumed to be right until it's shown to be wrong. It needs to demonstrate that it's right with a sufficient level of confidence before it even gets considered at all. "Not good enough yet" just means "you haven't shown your claims to be right with enough confidence to make them worth considering in this public policy debate". > leaders act to address needs in real time, making the best decisions they can with the information available to them. "Leaders" aren't the only ones who act to address needs in real time and make decisions. Everybody does that. Often the best thing for "leaders" to do is to not make any decisions at all as "leaders", but to simply let individual people, who have far more accurate information about their individual situations than any "leader" can possibly have, make their own decisions. For a "leader" to make a decision and dictate a public policy, the policy needs to be based on knowledge that is strong enough to justify overriding the billions of individual decisions that people are making all the time about their individual lives, with a top-down dictated decision that everybody must follow. That's a much, much stricter requirement than most people appear to think.
- snowwrestler 6y agoEveryone is already under the imposition of public policy, right now. Today's society is not neutral just because it is today. Edit to add: the public policy imposed on us today is based on what we thought we knew back when it was put in place.
- pdonis 6y ago> Everyone is already under the imposition of public policy, right now. To the extent that this is true, it is, IMO, mostly a bug, not a feature. > the public policy imposed on us today is based on what we thought we knew back when it was put in place. If you seriously believe the public policies we have today were all based on the best current knowledge at the time they were put in place, all I can say is that you have a most charming naivete.
- snowwrestler 6y agoI don't think I claimed they were based on "best current knowledge," but I hope we can agree that is an ideal to aspire to.
- pdonis 6y ago> I hope we can agree that is an ideal to aspire to. It's an ideal to aspire to, but only if the ideal includes a very strict standard on what level of knowledge justifies dictating a public policy at all.
- jbay808 6y agosnowwrestler has repeatedly made the point that you can't not have a public policy about something; you can only accept or change the status quo. England has a public policy that people drive on the left. America has a public policy that people drive on the right. In a society that had no codified rule about which side of the road to drive on, where people just weave back and forth, the choice to not enforce a particular convention would also be a defacto public policy. It seems to me that in general you should only need the preponderance of evidence to suggest that a public policy change will do more good than harm in order to adopt it; otherwise you're unnecessarily biasing yourself in favour of the status quo. This of course should be done with an appropriate risk-weighting decision theory (how you weigh a small chance of large negative utility against a large chance of small positive utility, etc).
- renewiltord 6y agoIt's just a status quo bias to choose "act to preserve without prior of belief > 0.95". It's a novelty bias to choose "act to change without prior of belief > 0.95". But there are many modes of action in between. Knowledge is necessarily imperfect (cf. Conjectures and Refutations). The engineer/scientist difference isn't all that useful in reality. Even disciplines dominated by engineering rapidly see advances over time purely through process improvements which often manifest across the field as the hypothesis-test-apply loop of knowledge acquisition. Public policy, like all decision making, should work with a gestalt view of utility and certainly most organizations attempt to do that irrespective of whether their spokespeople claim otherwise. It's like any intervention: if the patient will almost certainly die if you do nothing, you try the most unlikely things (assuming consent) but if the patient will most certainly recover with no ill effects you are not going to try an experimental intervention. And naturally you do account for change fatigue, etc. etc. Put simply, the science of policy is not as puerile as you think it is, but the nature of its execution is necessarily a complex interweave of the power centres available and their objectives and influence on the policymaking body. After all, we don't all have the same objectives.
- pdonis 6y ago> the hypothesis-test-apply loop of knowledge acquisition Public policy, affecting the lives of everybody, is not the same as engineering with inanimate objects. > It's like any intervention: if the patient will almost certainly die if you do nothing A country of 300 million people, or a planet of 8 billion people, is not one "patient" to which one thing will or will not happen. Treating public policy as though it were just a matter of deciding "what is best for the patient" is foolish. There is no one "best" thing for everybody.