3 ms·
I think legal realism as Matt Levine states it this time is not quite right. Whether a law is meaningful depends not just on what officials do, it's about what
by skybrian 6y ago
I think legal realism as Matt Levine states it this time is not quite right. Whether a law is meaningful depends not just on what officials do, it's about what most people do.
An example is a curfew. If the government announces a curfew and most people stay home, then this supports the curfew, and the authorities have a better chance of enforcing the curfew. If nobody obeyed it then it wouldn't work at all. (At best it would give the police a justification for selective enforcement.)
The same is true of health orders. We have seen quite a bit of cooperation, partly due to people agreeing with the general principle of wanting to avoid spreading the virus, and partially because many people will obey the law even if they don't agree with it. But, this cooperation is only partial and has seemed rather tenuous lately, due to fatigue and fairly obvious lack of enforcement.
There are different ways people obey laws. Most people outside government have fairly vague understandings of law and only follow the general principles. For the specifics of a law to matter, ultimately it depends on most people accepting the authority of the courts in settling disputes. In particular, the police accepting the courts' authority and enforcing decisions is key.