5 ms·
If Zuckerberg were to make Facebook politically active, it would probably be his personal views that they pushed. Why would it be anything else?
by whatshisface 6y ago
If Zuckerberg were to make Facebook politically active, it would probably be his personal views that they pushed. Why would it be anything else?
- pesfandiar 6y agoI don't know his political views very well, but since Facebook's user base in the US skews towards older demographics, I imagine "old folks conservatism" would be better for business.
- banads 6y agoNot necessarily. Nothing raises engagement quite like a good rage flame war
- jakelazaroff 6y agoZuckerberg is politically active, and his personal views are being pushed. Their current policy of allowing incitement to violence and voter suppression in the name of free expression is the result.
- whatshisface 6y agoAllowing something isn't pushing something. To see how, look at the following debate: Liberal: "Stop trying to push your views on us, let people decide for themselves whether they want to be gay." Conservative: "You are also pushing your views, and the fact that gay marriage is allowed is a result of that. By allowing gay marriage, you are forcing your views on everyone." So, that's clearly wrong, because as smart as it sounds to say things like "the null policy is a policy," being permissive is actually possible to distinguish from any of the particular ways one could be restrictive.
- testbot123 6y ago> let people decide for themselves whether they want to be gay > By allowing gay marriage, you are forcing your views on everyone This is a straw man. People don't choose to be gay, and conservatives are depriving people of their rights for something they can't choose. Allowing individuals the right of self determination is nowhere near allowing a sitting president to incite violence against American citizens.
- whatshisface 6y agoI think you're misusing the term "straw man." A straw man is an argument that nobody ever uses, brought forward purely to discredit. I am pretty sure I have heard that argument before, so it's not a straw man. In any case, it doesn't even matter whether that example has happened in a debate before. It's simply meant to illustrate the error in failing to distinguish between liberality and restrictivism.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoA straw man is misrepresenting an argument so that it's easier to counter. I don't think this is a straw man, I just think it's a poor analogy. The difference between same–sex marriage and what Trump is doing is that same–sex marriage affects no one except for those getting married. No one is being forced to have a same–sex marriage or go to a same–sex wedding. "Forcing your views on us" means "we don't want to live in a society where this is permitted, even if I am never personally affected by it." Trump, on the other hand, has posted propaganda about voter suppression and incited violence. This absolutely affects other people. It's not neutral to unaffiliated parties at all — how many protesters will be hurt because Trump has openly called for violence against them?
- whatshisface 6y agoGoing back to the original point, if Zuckerberg was in charge of deciding which policy positions were good and which ones were bad, it would be his personal opinions that mattered. So your or my opinion about whether Trump tweets or gay marriage are good or bad, are not very relevant.
- oneplane 6y agoIt would be anything else if it makes more money.
- jlarocco 6y agoI agree, and I feel like these guys might not realize the full consequences of what they're asking. On the other hand, with no transparency, it's hard to know what kind of censorship and filtering already goes on. If Facebook removes content offensive to advertisers, why not remove content offensive to real people?