2 ms·
How would that work in practice? Say I have a traffic accident and the other party is uncooperative. We both threaten to use our guns unless the other party adm
by adrianN 6y ago
How would that work in practice? Say I have a traffic accident and the other party is uncooperative. We both threaten to use our guns unless the other party admits fault and then somehow the necessary paperwork for an insurance claim gets done?
Or my neighbors decide that 2am is a great time for some jackhammering. I threaten to shoot them unless they stop? They threaten to shoot me in turn?
Does this depend on righteous mobs of gun owners assembling and holding an impromptu court martial?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Say I have a traffic accident and the other party is uncooperative. You take a picture of their license plate number and bring it to a courthouse. They show up in court or the court gives you a default judgement and orders their insurance/bank to give you the money. > Or my neighbors decide that 2am is a great time for some jackhammering. You make a timestamped recording of the jackhammering and bring it to a courthouse. Do you see where this is going? You don't need police to have courts. And most of the time you don't even need to use the courts for the same reason you don't need to use the guns -- the other party can predict what will happen and it's easier for everybody to settle things and not go there.
- adrianN 6y agoWhat if I don't want the jackhammering to continue for a year until I have my court date? What if my neighbors don't give a fuck about court dates?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWhat happens in that case now? The police show up, they agree to stop and then don't, you call the police again, they agree to stop and then don't. You're still in court if you want them to stop and they won't, and they still actually stop because they don't want to end up in court. (You could also write to your legislators to hire enough judges that you don't have to wait a year for a court date.) And if they don't show up in court then you win and the court fines them.
- adrianN 6y agoI'm reasonably sure that the police would take away their jackhammer and/or arrest them after repeated calls.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoPeople generally don't get arrested or have their stuff stolen over noise complaints. More likely they'd issue a citation, which is really just a piece of paper that leads to a court date, i.e. the same thing you can get by bringing your evidence to a judge/prosecutor.
- Koshkin 6y agoIn theory there’s nothing wrong with jackhammering at 2am. This is just the classical issue of the will of one (or a few) vs. the will of the many. (Imagine yourself being the only one who doesn’t do the jackhammering at 2am.)