5 ms·
Antifa literally exist to use violence upon people who don't share their politics, which is one of the hallmarks of fascism. Naming yourself "the good guys" do
by nailer 6y ago
Antifa literally exist to use violence upon people who don't share their politics, which is one of the hallmarks of fascism.
Naming yourself "the good guys" doesn't mean anyone who opposes you is bad. It's like if someone said disliking 'Make America Great Again' means you don't want America to be great. Or opposing the Patriot Act makes you not a patriot.
You know this, everyone else reading this knows this, stop pretending we don't.
- astronautjones 6y agono, they don't! what are you talking about? I have been to places where people have to defend themselves from neo nazis coming to beat them up for being gay. it is a label that indicates reactive protection from fascist violence, period
- nailer 6y agoI think my post was pretty clear. The fact that nazis exist doesn't invalidate it. Again you probably know this so I'm not going to bother replying further.
- joshuamorton 6y agoEquivocation between literal facicts and people who want to fight literal facists doesn't make a lot of sense. So no, I really, truly have no clue what you're getting at. Like as far as I can tell you're saying "being willing to punch a Nazi makes you a Nazi". Which, like, no.
- malka 6y agosaying antifa = facist is the hallmark of facist supporters.
- barking 6y agoDemonising your enemies as racists or fascists, ie nazis and employing mob tactics to "no platform" them or otherwise shut them up as in "no free speech for racists", strike me as exactly the sort of tactics the real fascists employed in the 1930s. So in that sense, yes, Antifa groups/coalitions/collectives/networks frequently behave like fascists. Which is no surprise really if you subscribe to the horseshoe model of the political spectrum.
- nailer 6y agoMy post: >> Naming yourself "the good guys" doesn't mean anyone who opposes you is bad. It's like if someone said disliking 'Make America Great Again' means you don't want America to be great. Or opposing the Patriot Act makes you not a patriot. Your reply: > Like as far as I can tell you're saying "being willing to punch a Nazi makes you a Nazi". ok
- joshuamorton 6y agoYes, I'm still confused by the equivocation between facists and antifacsists, and your dodging that question doesn't help. Please elaborate. Please don't just re-quote yourself. You know, follow the guidelines and engage in good faith. I did, it why I asked a genuine clarifying question which you seemed to ignore.
- julianmarq 6y ago> Which, like, no. No, you did not address GP in good faith. And GP did address your question by quoting himself: the problem is not "fighting against the bad guys", the problem is whom you consider the bad guys. Anti-fascists calling themselves such in no way means that everyone they oppose is actually a fascist.
- joshuamorton 6y ago> No, you did not address GP in good faith. I did. Please don't presume to know my thoughts. > Anti-fascists calling themselves such in no way means that everyone they oppose is actually a fascist. This doesn't address my comment, nor is it what GP said. Id suggest you reread their comment. And mine. I'll break it down: > Antifa literally exist to use violence upon people who don't share their politics This is overbroad. Many people don't share antifa politics. I don't. They don't threaten me with violence. Something is missing here. > which is one of the hallmarks of fascism So this is only sensical in an overbroad generalization of antifa to mean "violent left wing people who are violent towards anyone not suitably left wing", which isn't antifa under any reasonable definition, and is an entirely circular argument. So yes, please: explain.
- eirini1 6y agoI wonder if you also think that the allies forces in ww2 were also fascists for going to war with nazi germany. They were after all, using violence of people who didn't share their politics (politics of genocide). Equivocating someone who wants to commit genocide and someone who wants to stop them from doing so can certainly be done with saying that they both "want to commit violence to people who don't agree with them" but its a very good example where ignoring the political content of an action in favor of the content can lead you to really bizarre statements.
- nailer 6y ago> allies forces in ww2 were after all, using violence of people who didn't share their politics (politics of genocide). Antifa use violence on unarmed opponents. Their enemies are anyone who does not share far left politics. I find it very difficult to believe you are not already aware of this.
- ohbleek 6y agoThis is provably false. It’s possible this has occurred but exceptions are not the rule and you’re painting with the broadest of brushes.
- luckylion 6y ago> This is provably false. I mean, no, it happened, so obviously you cannot prove it didn't happen. > It’s possible this has occurred Ah, but "they were not real anti-fascists". Have we still not gotten over this line of argument?
- dependenttypes 6y ago> using violence of people who didn't share their politics (politics of genocide). The genocide became widely known after the war had already started. The allies did not join the war out of their goodwill but rather due to their own geopolitical and economic interests - they never intended to stop any genocide (the US engaged in eugenics and mandatory sterilisation and only stopped because hitler did it too - they even put the Japanese living in the US in concentration camps), it was just a side-effect. Regardless (and this is a bit offtopic), I wonder, would you support WWII if only to save people from genocide? In the same spirit would you support war against China in order to save the Uyghurs and other suppressed groups? I personally would reply yes to the first one but I am debating about the second.
- n4r9 6y agoUsing violence to achieve political goals is not in itself a "hallmark of fascism". From the Gordon Riots, to union riots, to militant suffragettes, history is littered with examples of political change that was expedited by violence. In the UK, the British Union of Fascists organised a march in London in 1936 and were countered by ten times as many people organised by anarchist, communist, socialist and Jewish groups. The ensuing violence sent an extremely clear message that fascism is not welcome in the country.
- nailer 6y agoMy post: >> Antifa literally exist to use violence upon people who don't share their politics Your reply: > Using violence to achieve political goals is not in itself a "hallmark of fascism". Agreed. But I didn't write that it was. You live in the UK. How would you compare the IRA of the 1920s with the provos in the 1980s? Would you say they're the same group? They have the same name.
- n4r9 6y agoI'm a bit confused about your argument, then. Antifa aren't violent against just anyone that doesn't share their politics. It's not a single organisation with a uniform political ideology, so that wouldn't make sense. It's more like the practise of aggressive confrontation specifically against authoritarian, right-wing movements, especially those which have some level of support from the state and/or police.
- nailer 6y ago> Antifa aren't violent against just anyone that doesn't share their politics. In my experience (as a mainsteam left person) Antifa consider anyone not on the hard left to be either 'fascists' or 'bootlickers'. Everyone else I know who has had any contact with Antifa has had the same experience. Many Antifa people would say this is an accurate view of anyone who does not share hard left political views.
- n4r9 6y ago
- totalZero 6y agoHonestly, I'm not even sure that Antifa exists. I'd never heard anything about such a group being worthy of concern in America until the current president started trying to make white supremacists sound like regular folks. I view rhetoric about Antifa as propaganda from apologists for right-wing extremism. It's their way of saying "he started it!" Any time their culture war comes to blows.