2 ms·
I’m making an observation MLK himself made directly. Immediately preceding the article’s lead quote, in the same speech, MLK said: > Let me say as I’ve always
by rayiner 6y ago
I’m making an observation MLK himself made directly. Immediately preceding the article’s lead quote, in the same speech, MLK said:
> Let me say as I’ve always said, and I will always continue to say, that riots are socially destructive and self-defeating. I’m still convinced that nonviolence is the most potent weapon available to oppressed people in their struggle for freedom and justice. I feel that violence will only create more social problems than they will solve. That in a real sense it is impracticable for the Negro to even think of mounting a violent revolution in the United States. So I will continue to condemn riots, and continue to say to my brothers and sisters that this is not the way. And continue to affirm that there is another way.
MLK does not rule out violent resistance on moral grounds, but practical ones. Bangladeshis mounted a violent revolution against Pakistan and won. But as MLK directly states, it would be “impracticable” to “even think of” a minority group within the US doing the same. Not “immoral.” (Given the history of what African Americans have endured, being second class citizens in their own country, I wouldn’t say it would be immoral.) But “impracticable.” And it obviously is.
People will go to tremendous lengths to preserve law and order. Saddam remained in power despite tremendous abuses because he maintained law and order. What MLK recognized is that if you give the majority a dichotomous choice between the rights of a minority and maintaining law and order, people will easily choose law and order. MLK’s non-violence wasn’t just a moral sentiment, it was rooted in pragmatism and self-preservation.
(I should add, MLK was a Christian. It's an issue the Bible grapples with directly: what do you do when the government is antagonistic to you and has an overwhelming advantage in force? The Bible hardly writes off the idea of righteous exercise of violence. But it also counsels temperance where any other approach would be "impracticable.")
- jahaja 6y ago> MLK does not rule out violent resistance on moral grounds, but practical ones. This is my point. People are quoting MLK in order to suppress or silence protests, even though there's a vast difference between morally condemning riots and disagreeing on its effectiveness as a tactic. Also, importantly, this was ~50 years ago. How long should people have to wait peacefully for justice? Most of the progressive points of MLK have not been fulfilled.
- rayiner 6y agoNo, people are quoting MLK to point out the destructive and counter-productive nature of rioting and looting. As to how long—given that the issue is logistics and not morality, indefinitely. Absent dissolution of the United States, there will never come a time when violent resistance becomes a more pragmatic solution than non-violent resistance. It’s a grim observation, but it’s worth noting that Jews lived peacefully alongside their neighbors in Poland for centuries, only to have their neighbors turn on them when Hitler rose to power. That is not to say we can’t make it better, but how much better it can be and what means we can use to make it better are circumscribed by the parameters of the human condition.
- jahaja 6y ago> No, people are quoting MLK to point out the destructive and counter-productive nature of rioting and looting. The same people would never ever quote him regarding economic policy, but cherry-picks the non-violent "order" perspective because it suits their interests. "I never intend to adjust myself to economic conditions that will take necessities from the many to give luxuries to the few, leave millions of God’s children smothering in an air tight cage of poverty in the midst of an affluent society." Logistics? Indefinitely? Poland? What an absolute garbage post, especially coming from someone that firmly supports the status quo. Reap what you sow. This is a time for introspection. At some point peoples patience will run out. This should not come as a surprise. No pleads of "It's complicated logistics!" will prevent the disadvantaged mob from storming the Bastille.