4 ms·
>> Driver assist systems therefore ignore any objects which are stationary on the road If true, that is totally unacceptable. Any mountain road can have falle
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> Driver assist systems therefore ignore any objects which are stationary on the road
If true, that is totally unacceptable. Any mountain road can have fallen rocks. Any city road can have a child's toy be stationary in the road. And EVERY road can at any time have a live person, a fallen motorcyclist/bicyclist, lying crumpled up and stationary in the middle of the road. Stationary objects, whether on radar, camera or both cannot be ignored.
If the radar 'sees' such an object for more than a heartbeat or two, the car should take action. That's what any reasonable person does when they aren't sure what they are looking at.
- renewiltord 6y agoWhy do you say this? I'm at the wheel so I can always act. The driver assist makes this easier to do by helping out but I'm still here at the wheel and so I don't need perfection, I just appreciate the help.
- rtkwe 6y agoPeople aren't machines and when something works fine 95+% of the time they'll get complacent and an uncommon event will eventually catch some people out.
- renewiltord 6y agoMy Subaru has Eyesight and I don't think I ever take my hands off the wheel to let it drive, though it does lane-keep. It's a comfort feature. I wonder if I would get more complacent in a Tesla.
- rtkwe 6y agoYeah there's a whole different level of automation between your car and what's being advertised by Tesla. EyeSight does do a bit of driving for you at higher speeds but it's not the stop and go capable 'Autopilot' of the Tesla.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoIt's even worse. Tesla maintains a whitelist of locations where problematic radar returns are caused by surrounding infrastructure. They blind themselves to the radar data in those zones. Pray you never get hit by a Tesla that has decided you're part of the background because their database says so.
- caf 6y agoYou always see a giant stationary object in front of you - the road itself. The way you can tell the difference between the rock and the road itself is through additional resolution, reflectance and colouring information that is available at visible light wavelengths but not to radar. So it's not a problem that can be solved through radar alone, you do need to combine that data with other sensors.
- sandworm101 6y agoYes, but when the radar sees a particularly reflective bit of road, suggesting something other than flat pavement, the least it can do is alert the driver. False alarms are an annoyance but a small price to pay. Even my tiny garmin dashcam has a basic collision alarm feature when it sees an object growing in size.