5 ms·
> If anything shouldn't they be glad about idiots with more money than sense investing poorly like that? Outside of pure business, some of these companies are
by Apocryphon 6y ago
> If anything shouldn't they be glad about idiots with more money than sense investing poorly like that?
Outside of pure business, some of these companies are creating negative externalities that impact other industries and society at large:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23216852 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23216852
https://www.wired.co.uk/article/airbnb-coronavirus-london https://www.wired.co.uk/article/airbnb-coronavirus-london
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22418725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22418725
Giving some companies too much money isn't just handing them a gun that they might shoot themselves in the foot with; it's giving them a rocket launcher armed with a cluster bomb.
- bobbydroptables 6y agoThe Doordash externality that you posted is not really a problem for anyone except Doordash. Both the restaurant and the consumer benefit from the arbitrage. Airbnb is profitable so I'm not sure why you included it. If you don't like Airbnb that's fine but it has nothing to do with bad business models. Airbnb has proven to be a pretty good model. Even better it's challenged the stranglehold hotels have had on some local politics. You posted about Uber which is also a pretty good business model so not really relevant here. Pollution is a problem that needs to be solved but very little of that blame lies with Uber. A carbon tax could fix that instantly. We cannot rely on investors to save the environment.
- Apocryphon 6y agoBut the restaurant experiences other problems from DD, as per the article: "Doordash was causing him real problems. The most common was, Doordash delivery drivers didn't have the proper bags for pizza so it inevitably would arrive cold. It led to his employees wasting time responding to complaints and even some bad Yelp reviews." Some of the comments in the Doordash comments goes into the externalities caused by predatory pricing, Rents have increased in many housing markets due to Airbnb's presence. The fact that a dip in their business has led to more affordable rents is rather telling. To say Uber has a "pretty good business model" belies their huge operating expenses leading to both mass layoffs post- and pre-pandemic, but that's not my point. They're still contributing to an externality by driving up traffic and car usage. We can't rely on investors to fix the environment, it is true, but we can doggone blame them for wrecking it. These are just some random examples but are far from the only effects generated by reckless companies with a slash-and-burn-to-hyper-growth mentality.
- bobbydroptables 6y agoSome bad Yelp reviews and wasting the time of a minimum wage employee? Not exactly the apocalypse or "a cluster bomb" or whatever you called it. Yes businesses have externalities. No, this cute story does not make me question silicon valley. Spending a lot on customer acquisition costs is the norm and on net works out very well for SV. Again, Airbnb is not a bad business model, so we're now having two different discussions. This discussion is supposed to be about why people don't like cash flow-negative businesses. Airbnb is a great business model (cash flow positive with solid growth). I see it has some externalities that you don't like, but literally every business has externalities. It's fine that you don't like them but that's not an indictment of capitalism or SV. It's just a business you don't like. Are you equally upset with most of the Fortune 500 that probably have worse externalities than driving up prices in some trendy neighborhoods? If so, that's fine, but nothing to do with our discussion. Uber is a fine business though. The issues with uber aren't it's cash flow problems. They could very quickly become cash flow positive if they wanted to (they would just have to change their growth trajectory). If you're worried about carbon emissions, that's fine, we all should be. But you should be furious at basically all businesses. This is nothing special to do with Silicon Valley. You should focus 100x this rage on the Permian Basin. Are you?
- Apocryphon 6y agoThis wasn't the first story to describe animosity between restaurants and food delivery apps. Not too long before that article there was also this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23194727 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23194727 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10551312 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10551312 Perhaps one could also say their attempts to cheat their staff out of tips is also an externality in the sense that it further devalues the labor power of gig workers, but I suspect I'm just overusing that word by now. > Not exactly the apocalypse or "a cluster bomb" or whatever you called it. It's less of an apocalypse, than collateral damage. Perhaps during the first dot com bubble the majority of the losers- Enron excepted- kept the damage within the tech sector. Nowadays with software having eaten the world, the capacity to cause problems for the rest of the world is much greater. > I see it has some externalities that you don't like, but literally every business has externalities. It's fine that you don't like them but that's not an indictment of capitalism or SV. It's just a business you don't like. Are you equally upset with most of the Fortune 500 that probably have worse externalities than driving up prices in some trendy neighborhoods? So this is the crux of if tall, which could provide fertile ground for a more extended discussion. There's something to be said that many of these grow-at-all-costs VC-cash infused unicorns have modus operandi that includes cutting corners and aggressive business tactics. Stories about early-stage Uber telling its drivers to drip off mustaches from competing Lyft vehicles come to mind, presaging the much more excessive and extensive abuses that later resulted. The question is, would this sort of reckless behavior have manifested if the overall pace that these companies were operating under were not as aggressive and fast? Does the the medium of the money eventually dictate the behavior of the company? It would seem like in some of these examples, the promise of big dumb money, coupled with incentives to pursue cash flow-negative business models, coupled with the problems resulting from having to make good on the big dumb money investments while digging themselves in deeper with said half-baked business models, leads to them engaging in even more risky and externality-creating behavior. And generally promotes a toxic business culture that excuses bad behavior. If they had less money to play around with and lower expectations and thus less incentive to desperately flail around trying to justify their crazy valuations, could this behavior be preempted, or at least lessened? > Airbnb is a great business model (cash flow positive with solid growth). And yet, their losses were mounting pre-pandemic: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/10/17/airbnbs-quarterly-loss-reportedly-doubled-in-q1.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/10/17/airbnbs-quarterly-loss-repor... > You should focus 100x this rage on the Permian Basin. Are you? You don't need to be livid with rage to mention someone is contributing to a larger problem, however proportionally small. You don't even need to mention climate change as a reason to blame ridesharing for driving up traffic; the increase in traffic is inconvenience enough, let alone its influence on public policy wrt urban planning, decrease in investment for transit, etc. > They could very quickly become cash flow positive if they wanted to (they would just have to change their growth trajectory). Great idea! Will they? Can they?