3 ms·
If you have the risk tolerance for it, I would strongly advocate for using a margin account and purchasing stock in companies you trust and understand instead o
by bob1029 6y ago
If you have the risk tolerance for it, I would strongly advocate for using a margin account and purchasing stock in companies you trust and understand instead of holding onto someone else's interpretation of the same idea (i.e. ETNs and other higher-order derivatives). Put another way, if you don't have the stomach for a margin account, you absolutely should not be putting any substantial amount of money into these kinds of derivatives either. It's arguably even more risky.
Sure, 5%+ APY interest sucks, but so does being completely wiped-out over something you have zero visibility into. At least with a margin account you can look into your assets and control your risk in a very direct and immediate way.
I personally run a 50/50 leverage ratio with my margin account (i.e. 2x). I review this status on a weekly basis and will make decisions based on high/low water marks (45/55%). I've previously held ETNs and other derivatives when I was still learning the ropes... Margin accounts are 10x less stressful for me by comparison. It's literally just a normal portfolio that I would otherwise be perfectly comfortable with, but tuned slightly for a longer-term investment horizon. The fees are negligible to me with dividend income and the bigger strategic picture at play.
- jnsie 6y agoWhere are you getting 5%+ APY?
- brockwhittaker 6y agoHe’s talking about paying 5% interest to borrow leverage. That’s about the going rate.
- arcticbull 6y agoMargin interest these days is a lot lower. 5% is about what Robinhood charges. IBKR charges 1.55-0.85% depending on the amount borrowed [1]. [1] https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=44427 https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=44427
- bob1029 6y agoThank you for bringing this to my attention.
- siberianbear 6y agoIf you do this yourself and feel comfortable, good for you. But I wouldn't widely suggest people lever up 2x using margin. It's dangerous advice. In a severe down market you can be wiped out with a margin call and forced to sell at a low point in the market.
- bob1029 6y agoI strongly disagree with the notion of "dangerous" advice, especially when given in good faith. I even prefaced my post with a disclaimer regarding this practice. I could pose a counterargument that not investing aggressively in finance from a young age is the most dangerous thing you could do to your future self if you hope to maintain an equal or superior standard of living.
- haltingproblem 6y agoThis is honest and good advice. While, I would not recommend anyone trade on margin or even trade individual stocks, but if you are going to trade leveraged stock etfs then this is a far more honest way to go about it. The leveraged ETFs just give you the illusion of trading leveraged while siphoning away your capital in drips.