3 ms·
> You have already said that companies should be allowed to moderate violent speech; except most forms of violent speech are actually protected! So you are sayi
by rsynnott 6y ago
> You have already said that companies should be allowed to moderate violent speech; except most forms of violent speech are actually protected! So you are saying that the government should shield some protected speech, but not others. Where, pray tell, do you draw the line?
And, going back to what spurred this; what would one call Donald's little outburst? It could easily be considered both political speech and violent speech. Which wins? Even more to the point, what about his libel? That's both political, and something that Twitter could easily be sued for without CDA230.
Of course, in the case of such narrowing actually happening and surviving the courts (which seems pretty implausible), Twitter would presumably just ban him on the violent speech thing (or for no stated reason at all, as permitted by their ToS); far safer. There is some considerable irony in the fact that it's only due to the strong protections provided to websites via the CDA that he has a platform.
- ashtonkem 6y agoAnd that’s the core of the situation; the politicians (well, most) at the heart of this know that an end of 230 means that Trump will get banned. This is about partisan posturing, not a bona fide attempt to change how internet regulation occurs. It’s exactly like Trump’s threats to “open up” the libel laws; ignoring the fact that he has no authority to do that, he would be the first victim of such a change.