7 ms·
Activists want to eat their cake and have it too. On the one hand they say platforms may exercise “their” free speech by moderating posts or banning people and
by mc32 6y ago
Activists want to eat their cake and have it too.
On the one hand they say platforms may exercise “their” free speech by moderating posts or banning people and that’s okay because it’s a private co. and not obliged to be platform for everyone.
Then on the other hand a different company also exercises its free speech (under their own argument) by not moderating posts and now that’s bad because some speech should be moderated and they disagree with those voices.
So like basically they’re for corporate free speech when they agree with the controls but are against it when they disagree with the results.
Just say it. We only want to allow our approved views — we don’t want free speech.
And not only that but they protest free speech but totally don’t walk out when they unscrupulously slurp up data on everyone.
- joshuamorton 6y agoI acknowledge Facebook's right to not moderate such things. And support the laws that give Facebook that freedom. I think it's morally reprehensible and therefore support Facebook's employees movement to work to change Facebook's actions. These are not contradictory views.
- mc32 6y agoFree speech is morally reprehensible or just speech you disagree with? If we’re talking about the president’s post, look, there are people on the other side who also post things more incendiary are those reprehensible too? Or is it because we disagree with the poster? I don’t see how you square FB having that right but simultaneously disagreeing with what happens when they exercise that right.
- Talanes 6y agoYou don't understand AT ALL how someone could want an organization to make a choice, but not want the government to make that choice for them? I don't think people should wear socks with sandals, and I will not hesitate to tell them that should I see it. I'll still be the first protesting if the government starts making them take off their socks.
- mc32 6y agoYeah I understand that they want to allow an org to make a choice so long as they agree with that choice. I also understand they’d welcome government regulation so long as it would further their cause... they just don’t say that.
- danharaj 6y ago> Yeah I understand that they want to allow an org to make a choice so long as they agree with that choice. They are part of the org. They want a say in what that org does. Is this controversial? People want the world to be a certain way and don't want it to be other ways. This is hypocritical? > I also understand they’d welcome government regulation so long as it would further their cause... they just don’t say that. Ok, so you're admitting to setting up a literal strawman but we should trust your ability to read the thoughts of hundreds of people. You're clearly having a normal one.
- kryogen1c 6y ago> They are part of the org. They want a say in what that org does. Is this controversial? of course its contraversial. its not free speech if they only say what you want them to, is it?
- danharaj 6y agoThere is no place on Earth where you can say literally anything and not have a consequence for it. People who subscribe to such an absolutist free speech make buffoons of themselves.
- jlarocco 6y agoMy feeling is that focusing on Twitter and Facebook's response is missing the point completely. Trump's threats were repugnant and disgusting, but it's not Twitter or Facebook's place to tell people that. It's important, as citizens, to hear what politicians are saying and form our own opinions. The consequences of Trump's threats will not go away just because Twitter told everybody they were violent threats. Shooting the messengers won't help anything. Have corporations imposing their "morals" on public communication would be a very dangerous slippery slope, IMO.
- mc32 6y agoI agree the great danger here is corps feeding us their morality and shaping society as they please with people complicit in this take over. These are media and ad companies and people want them be the gatekeepers of permissible speech.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoI think what you're saying is fair, but I also think you're raising a different argument than the OP. This is probably more suited to a top-level comment. But in response to the subject of your comment: don't they already do this regardless? Isn't inaction a moral response in itself? In the same way that [as a loose example, so don't shoot me if it falls short] Coca Cola or Nestle see no moral problem with consuming entire regions' fresh water supplies for profit? Is it that American Express or Wells Fargo making a moral decision when they deny a credit application to somebody who may need it to eat? Surely those institutions are as public as any social media platform. I think there is a lot more to work through there. Personally, I'm in the camp of the people should push for what they see as the right action: be it that a beverage company stops exploiting disadvantaged regions for their fresh water supplies or an internet company tags a post/comment as containing whatever kind of information might be questionable. Long, slow, hard road may it be—most people seem inclined to do better by each other on the large scale. The more options they have to do so, and the less potential gain by acting anti-socially, the better. It's definitely a complex problem [trying not to ramble, but even "acting out" can be a social act rather than anti-social, hence the complexity]. Boy...
- 6y ago
- colllectorof 6y ago>These are not contradictory views. You think the supposed contradiction is between legality and morality of not censoring certain speech. The actual contradiction is between claiming to support people's right to free speech while also supporting policies that undermine one of the main reasons that right is important in the first place. This is not a matter of spherical freedom in vacuum. This is a practical matter of whether a tiny number of people should be able to effectively control country's political processes because those people happen to own certain technological tools.
- joshuamorton 6y agoThe harm of government regulation of speech is greater than the harm of corporations censoring views with which you personally agree (or disagree). Facebook isn't going to imprison you, and there exist other platforms, however vehemently people like to deny that. > claiming to support people's right to free speech To be clear, I didn't claim this, in the sense that I don't support the ideological right to free speech that some people do. I fully support consequences for saying stupid and things. Much as you are free to say something I disagree with, I am free to tell you it's stupid, or stop associating with you in response.
- frabbit 6y agoLabelling them as 'activists' is imprecise. I agree that this particular activism is counter-productive, hypocritical and pro-censorship though.
- yibg 6y agoI'm not sure if the push is for corporate free speech one way or another, but rather that corporates can exercise their free speech by moderating and that facebook should moderate this particular post. So to me it seems like the ask is for facebook to align on a particular set of moderation rules.
- vlovich123 6y agoMy limited understanding of the situation is that there's general displeasure with the leadership response around Trump's persistent & ongoing violation of community standards that other members would have been censored for. This is qualitatively extremely different from the position of "I should be allowed to do anything as a private party" and also different from the "government should regulate it". It feels like a strawman to paint everyone with the same brush and then just focus on the contradictory extremes. There's a pretty clear contingent that is in favor of having clear community guidelines that apply to everyone & don't have blanket carve-outs for those with already powerful voices.
- y-c-o-m-b 6y agoFacebook has already set a standard for what it deems as approved speech: https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards/credible_violence https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards/credible_violenc... See this section > Do not post: > Threats that could lead to death (and other forms of high-severity violence) of any target(s)
- mc32 6y ago“When you drive very fast, you get in wrecks.” Is that a threat or a warning?
- Simulacra 6y agoIt's possible Facebook has taken this position to further them into the safe harbor of Section 230. Then again, maybe what social media has taught us is the superiority of our opinions.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoUnless there are nipples involved.
- metalgearsolid3 6y agoDo you not understand that these non-approved views, for the most part, come from actual nazis? Like, real life nazis. People that will kill you because of your skin colour. I've read a lot of bootlicking comments on this website lately from people who want to talk in upper abstractions about free speech and discuss moral theory. You are all completely missing the point. That black people are needlessly DYING because real life white supremacists are having their voices promoted and platformed on the internet. When it comes to activists eating their cake and having it too, yea, those are the privileged facebook employees taking a paid day off as a way of making a statement. What a joke. You know who needs their voices heard? Who needs free speech? Black people. And our society silences them through gruesome MURDER. Murders with no justice. God forbid someone get their tweet "fact-checked".
- saagarjha 6y agoI think most of the people who push for free speech understand that sometimes people say things that almost everyone disagrees with. It's easy to sit back and call something "hate speech" or "inciting violence" or any other set of labels but in practice those who push free speech understand that while the examples brought up are usually fairly clear it can be complicated in general. I would suggest you assume a bit more good faith from the people you're arguing against.
- pera 6y agoI don't think gp assumes bad faith. The problem I see is that free speech absolutism is currently serving as a platform to protect those who are making death threats in social networks. Sure sometimes is difficult to discern whether a post was an actual threat or just figurative language, but is it really that terrible to delete a post that was calling to shoot people even when maybe the intention was "just figurative"?
- saagarjha 6y agoI'm sorry, but calling a comment "bootlicking" does not imply good faith, nor does a claim that their viewpoint overlooks Nazis or murder. But to your comment, which I think I can respond to: if I perform illegal activities on a platform, I don't think there's really a choice at that point as to whether the platform can take it down. Death threats, posting child pornography, infringing upon copyright…all of those are things you can go to jail for anyways, so it's not really a "free speech online" issue at that point.
- sixstringtheory 6y agoI think it's perfectly consistent to oppose government attempts to curtail free speech while also advocating for your place of employment to act in a way consistent with your morals and principals. Of course FB doesn't have to listen. But it's their employer, they have a social relationship, they can bring concerns to them. Trump is the one wanting his cake and eating it too. He wants to be able to say whatever he wants on a private entity's platform, and also constrain the free speech of that same entity.
- mc32 6y agoI don’t doubt Trump wants to eat his cake and have it. All politicians do. My problem is with people who say they are just and moral but also want to tell you what is and what isn’t truth and who and who doesn’t have the right to speak freely. People who want to regulate speech are power hungry. They want control. Like Lenin, they know the path to power is communication media that is the goal. Control the narrative.
- pera 6y agoFree speech absolutism is something I sincerely cannot understand, may I ask you: 1 - What do you win by allowing users to make direct and explicit death threats? 2 - What is your view with regard to the paradox of tolerance? 3 - Are you against all kind of moderation in forums/social networks?
- mc32 6y ago1- Who made a credible direct and explicit threat? That said. In person you can tell a threat better. Online it’s very hard to discern what’s what. On reddit otherwise nice people will say rather nasty things that they don’t actually mean and will not act on. It will take time, generations, for this to suss out. Psychologically it’s quite different. 2- I am not a pacifist. But I think there is something to be learned from them. You have to believe that in the long run good arguments will win over poor ones. That said, in life nothing is sure. 3- No, but I know there is no perfect answer or one that works in all circumstances. Yet, I feel that allowing political censorship is dangerous. All kinds of “isms” love controlling speech, especially political speech. It’s dangerous to find comfort in that corner.
- pera 6y agoJust yesterday I reported two posts on Twitter calling to shoot democrats in the head. If you want to see some examples right now you can search for any political imageboard or spend a few minutes on Twitter, it's not rare at all. Thanks for the answers.
- xdavidliu 6y ago> Activists want to eat their cake and have it too. Ted?