4 ms·
This is my feeling also, but in general I'm very frustrated at how this whole conversation is based on these "feelings" because the data is so poor. I think an
by throwaway894345 6y ago
This is my feeling also, but in general I'm very frustrated at how this whole conversation is based on these "feelings" because the data is so poor. I think an important component is an independent oversight apparatus that (among many other things) is responsible for collecting standardized, high quality data that can be aggregated at a national level so we can conclusively answer questions like, "do police target certain races in their killings or is it an artifact of different crime distributions or etc?". It just seems insane to me that we keep going through this cycle over and over and spend so much time debating these questions, but we don't avail ourselves by the relatively inexpensive, straightforward step of collecting more/better data. Of course, not everyone will respect data over their own feelings/experiences, but (1) the data might agree with those feelings/experiences and (2) the rest of us can move toward a consensus at any rate.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Darkphibre 6y agoCompletely agree, we need to be collecting this data at a national level. And it's a reallly hard problem to properly asses, because there are so many confounding variables. Nature had a great analysis on the data collection/analysis perspective last year: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02601-9 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02601-9
- fellowniusmonk 6y agoThese aren't feelings. This is about feedback loops. Effectively what is happening is that a minority number of cops are horrible, but because the garbage collection apparatus of PDs and our legal systems are broken this violence occurs without accountability. Our police force has had it's immune system stripped away. Qualified immunity, lack of independent prosecutors and police unions make this a multi angle problem. Imagine every place you've worked (if you've done that) and the larger the company the more likely you are to have one or two scary psychos that you just try to keep off their radar, now imagine that coworker has qualified immunity, a state issued gun, police union backing and a blue line to back him up... you aren't going to antagonize that guy, at best you'll avoid him, and he'll go out effectively unsupervised or with someone who won't stop them, we need external processes to get rid of bad cops so police have a better work environment. Police reform is the most pro human thing I can think, whether your a cop or not. https://law.yale.edu/sites/default/files/area/workshop/leo/leo16_fryer.pdf https://law.yale.edu/sites/default/files/area/workshop/leo/l...
- throwaway894345 6y ago> These aren't feelings. This is about feedback loops. Then you aren't the group I was referencing. :) Your feedback loop theory seems plausible. Hard to say conclusively without more data, which is my point.
- Ericson2314 6y agoThis "feelings" complaint is a major dog whistle you know. The fact is, the relationship between unprivileged communities is such that: - Crime rates to not reflect actual community grievances - Community members do not want to rely on police even if they would like to bring in some sort of neutral authority / arbitrator to a dispute. - The portion of would-be crime where the would-be victim is happy for the police presence is incredibly low. - The portion of actual crime where the actual victim is sad for the police absence is incredibly low. So it doesn't even matter if the statistics show the police kill extra in proportion to the neighborhoods the patrol and that in turn is proportional to the crime rate, because you haven't Baysianed deep enough to find the cycle. As exemplified by the latter two points, there is no way to find any value for the police as they currently with a democratic basis, and as such they must be defunded and replaced with something else.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> This "feelings" complaint is a major dog whistle you know. I care very little about alleged dog whistles these days. You can only cry wolf so many times and all that. > So it doesn't even matter if the statistics show the police kill extra in proportion to the neighborhoods the patrol and that in turn is proportional to the crime rate, because you haven't Baysianed deep enough to find the cycle. Maybe you're right, but the conversation as far as I'm aware is still very much fixated on the former question. We are locked on this question and we can't meaningfully "baysian" our way to deeper questions without more authoritative data. If one actually cared about solving the problem, he ought to support this sort of data collection initiative.
- rayiner 6y agoYour “facts” are actually feelings or conjectures, and are demonstrably untrue. Black communities in fact want police (and the criminal justice system) to address high crime rates. This article collects a number of statistics: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2014/12/black-community-is-concerned-with-black-on-black-crime-suggesting-otherwise-is-ignoring-the-facts.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2014/12/black-community-... > Finally, Atlantic Media’s “State of the City” poll—published this past summer—shows an “urban minority” class that’s worried about crime, and skeptical toward law enforcement, but eager for a greater police presence if it means less crime. Just 22 percent of respondents say they feel “very safe” walking in their neighborhoods after dark, and only 35 percent say they have “a lot” of confidence in their local police. That said, 60 percent say hiring more police would have a “major impact” on improving safety in their neighborhoods. In fact, even today, a slight majority of African Americans say that the criminal justice system in their area is “not harsh enough” on criminals: https://gssdataexplorer.norc.org/documents/899/download https://gssdataexplorer.norc.org/documents/899/download (Table 2). At the height of the crime wave of the 1980s and 1990s, over 70% of black Americans felt we needed harsher punishment of criminals. Half of African Americans today say we are spending “too little” on law enforcement. Hispanics are even more strongly in favor of policing. 53% of Hispanic people supported NYC’s controversial (and unconstitutional) stop-and-frisk policy: https://www.blackenterprise.com/nypd-stop-and-frisk-poll-racism-nyc https://www.blackenterprise.com/nypd-stop-and-frisk-poll-rac.... Notions of “defunding the police” are an idea dreamed up by people who don’t actually live in these disadvantaged communities. Poll after poll shows that is not what disadvantaged communities actually want. They want the law to be enforced; they can’t criminals brought to justice; and they want all that done with due process protections, just like police manage to do for white neighborhoods.