5 ms·
IA's lending is not unlimited, even with the National Emergency Library. The books are still restricted by DRM, they do keep track of how many copies are out fo
by zozbot234 6y ago
IA's lending is not unlimited, even with the National Emergency Library. The books are still restricted by DRM, they do keep track of how many copies are out for each book, and they do monitor the system to prevent abuse. It's a real library lending system, nothing like what they do with actual public domain works.
- space_fountain 6y agoBut for copyright to mean something and for the authors to get paid IA's emergency library can't become the norm right? If they don't enforce limits on the number of copies what does it matter that they monitor the number of copies.
- betamaxthetape 6y ago> IA's emergency library can't become the norm I don't think the plan is to "become the norm". It's an 'emergency library', and it exists currently because the pandemic has forced regular libraries to close.
- space_fountain 6y agoHum, many are starting to reopen which maybe helps to explain why this lawsuit is happening now. Regardless while it changes the morality I don't think it changes anything about the legality.
- zozbot234 6y agoAs long as physical libraries throughout the U.S. and in much of the world are shuttered due to COVID, something like the NEL makes a lot of sense. It's not the norm, but we're not living in normal times either.
- jasode 6y ago>IA's lending is not unlimited, even with the National Emergency Library. I'm not debating with you about the details since I haven't used IA's system myself but the last time this came up, a commenter explained that there were a bunch of loopholes in IA's "limits" that it was effectively "unlimited". E.g. after the checkout period expires, you just check out the ebook again. Again, I don't know if this is true. EDIT to replies equating this to "physical books" : the context of my answer was "digital" ebooks. Physical books are already limited in the sense that libraries' limited budgets only buy limited copies of paper books. So library patrons renewing their borrowed book is "unlimited" on time but not a threat to the publishers because the # of copies are still limited.
- thomaslord 6y agoShockingly, at physical libraries you can also re-borrow a book if there's nobody on a waiting list for it.
- space_fountain 6y agoOften libraries put limits on the number of times you can do this, but also since IA is currently not restricting the number of copies of a book it loans out that must make a difference no?
- popinman322 6y agoWhy would that matter? It's still only available to one party.
- space_fountain 6y agoWell right now that isn't true. IA suspended limiting the number of loans they issue to the number of books they own.
- hashhar 6y agoAnd how is that different from a physical library.
- tzs 6y agoA physical library pays based on maximum simultaneous checkouts. If they want to allow 5 people to have copies checked out simultaneously, they buy 5 copies from the publisher.
- hashhar 6y agoAnd the IA followed that rule too but opened up wider access with an "Emergency" library once lockdowns due to COVID-19 were put in place.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBut under the National Emergency Library, a very large number of people can read one copy of a book at the same time. That makes it completely different from a library "lending" system, regardless of whether user actions are tracked. Whatever your thoughts on the IA's practices, it's worth being clear on this.
- zucker42 6y ago> The books are still restricted by DRM I don't think this is true for many books, which are scanned copies and available as PDFs or EPubs.
- zozbot234 6y agoIt's definitely true of copyrighted books in the NEL. You're not getting actual PDF's or ePub's, only DRM-based versions are made available.
- jasode 6y ago>IA's lending is not unlimited, even with the National Emergency Library. The Internet Archive's Chris Freeland is the Director of Open Libraries and wrote the IA blog post[1] announcing the NEL change and he acknowledges that it is "unlimited"[2] -- and yet you say it isn't. I don't understand why you contradict IA's own representative. Are you affiliated with IA in an official capacity? - >Stephanie Willen Brown: So, librarian to librarian, is this unlimited simultaneous users? - >chrisfreeland: Stephanie – Yes, for the duration of our waitlist suspension![2] [1] https://blog.archive.org/2020/03/24/announcing-a-national-emergency-library-to-provide-digitized-books-to-students-and-the-public/ https://blog.archive.org/2020/03/24/announcing-a-national-em... [2] https://blog.archive.org/2020/03/24/announcing-a-national-emergency-library-to-provide-digitized-books-to-students-and-the-public/#comment-392139 https://blog.archive.org/2020/03/24/announcing-a-national-em...
- zozbot234 6y agoThis is only talking about 'unlimited' simultaneous users, and the term "unlimited" should be related to its proper context. It's 'unlimited' in a sense because the former limits have been suspended. Everything else is separate, so I'm not sure why we're being told assume that IA can't do their job properly.
- jasode 6y ago>This is only talking about 'unlimited' simultaneous users, and the term "unlimited" should be related to its proper context. Because the "proper context" in this case is what the publishers are filing the lawsuit about. It doesn't matter whether you agree or disagree with the publishers. To the publishers, unlimited simultaneous users is the same as unlimited copies. With public libraries, they paid for limited simultaneous checkouts of digital ebooks which is limited copies and that was acceptable by publishers. In contrast, IA did not pay publishers a license to make copyrighted works available to unlimited users. The publishers didn't file lawsuits against public libraries; they filed it against IA. In your own words (since you don't object to the word "unlimited" and you thought my summary was unfair), what exactly did IA do that the publishers are filing lawsuit about?