4 ms·
you're exaggerating. you can verify, modify a program without having access to processes, designs, contacts, etc. It's much harder without those but it's defin
by wiz21c 6y ago
you're exaggerating.
you can verify, modify a program without having access to processes, designs, contacts, etc. It's much harder without those but it's definitely possible. You're also aware that you can fix your own car, your fridge, your house if you ever want it. Those objects don't actively fight to stay un-repair-able (although the times are changing)
as far as cloning goes, I'm sure you're aware that there are many clones of your television, phone, etc. sold every day.
But in the end, it's a political choice. Either you agree with the fact that some people protect "their" idea (that they had by studying others' ideas), make profit out of it by keeping it a secret, that is, making sure it won't reach the greater part of mankind but only their customer base. Or you don't agree with that. RMS doesn't and he shows he can do it with an appropriate level of incoherence (notice that most free software, in turns, is written or proprietary hardware : just try to reverse engineer a CPU).
So it's not black and white. And if in some field there are rules, laws, etc. don't forget they were put in place also to protect commercial interest (in place of general interest). Software being new, it gives us (the idealists) an opportunity to propose another approach.
- jfkebwjsbx 6y ago> You're also aware that you can fix your own car, your fridge, your house if you ever want it. You can fix material defects. You cannot change the design, which is what you can do if you release the source code. The same way you can make small fixes in a program relatively easily, for instance updating a dependency or patching small bugs in the binary. So you are agreeing with me. > as far as cloning goes, I'm sure you're aware that there are many clones of your television, phone, etc. sold every day. You cannot clone them for free without cost, which is the problem with software given the source code. > making sure it won't reach the greater part of mankind but only their customer base Do you really think a business does not want to sell? Marketing is about telling everyone about your product.