6 ms·
I think we all know he is not "facing" anything. People that collect big and stable salaries will not change company employment over this. Virtue signalling is
by pdimitar 6y ago
I think we all know he is not "facing" anything. People that collect big and stable salaries will not change company employment over this.
Virtue signalling is cheap, endangering your family's livelihood is hard.
"It's very difficult to make somebody understand something, especially if their salary depends on them not understanding it."
Facebook is, in general, an unethical company. And this has been known for a long time. If you didn't leave yet you won't leave over this either.
- ethagnawl 6y ago> If you didn't leave yet you won't leave over this either. You have no idea why people have stayed and/or how their minds have changed over time. Everyone has their breaking point and this could very possibly be it for some people. Also, your quote should be attributed to Upton Sinclair.
- malloreon 6y agothey stayed through: - pro Kavanaugh - genocide in Myanmar - destruction of privacy - facebook accepting it creates extremists
- bryan_w 6y agoThere's two sides to all those issues* that reasonable people can take. * except the Myanmar thing - but that wasn't an active thing, but rather not being responsible in growth and having incorrect assumptions about state actors
- inopinatus 6y ago> Also, your quote should be attributed to Upton Sinclair. “Citations are optional on informal forums such as the Hacker News” —— Mary Wollstonecraft
- pdimitar 6y agoTrue, everyone has their "enough of that" point. But it seems to me that the people who work at Facebook are after the good money, the prestige and the stable job that is mostly immune to tremors (like the pandemic). I can't generalise all of them of course. But we never had historical data of people mass-leaving big corps over such issues so I'm tempted to believe in my generalisation.
- Simulacra 6y agoIs there an employee version of Karen? "I am not shopping here anymore!" and yet they typically do come back to shop there. "I will not work for this company is X" and they still work there.
- ethagnawl 6y agoI'm not defending anyone working at Facebook and, on the whole, I think Facebook is extremely problematic. I personally decline semi-annual offers from their recruiters. I'm just saying that it's too easy for outsiders to pass judgement when they know nothing about individual situations and circumstances. To their credit, despite whatever friction they may receive from on high, Facebook does have employees who care about and are working to address contentious issues. Also, people greatly overestimate how easy it is for others to actually find new jobs. Yes, there are lots of high paying tech jobs available (I have no idea how the Covid-19 pandemic may have changed things) but some people -- for a variety of reasons: health, family and otherwise -- have great difficulty doing this. Hiring is known to be broken and is the cause of _great_ anxiety for some number of us for these reasons. (It's so problematic for me that I don't even bother, at a great cost.)
- pdimitar 6y ago> Also, people greatly overestimate how easy it is for others to actually find new jobs. I don't. I am jobless for one month now and have been semi-actively looking for a job for two-three months. I never worked so hard for free in my life! I know exactly what you mean when you say it's really hard. Many people might underestimate it... but I don't. My point was -- still is -- those people should not virtue signal if they can't put their wallet where their mouth is. Ask yourself "am I willing to leave this cosy position because I disagree with the policy of my employer?" -- and if the answer is no then IMO you should just save your disagreement for yourself.
- bamboozled 6y agoMost people I know that work there still either: 1) Have little concern about the ethics. 2) Care about money. 3) Feel smart and important for working there (I'm smart, I made it). This won't change their view on those things.
- chrisseaton 6y agoWhat about people that fear they won't be able to get another job? You say 'care about money' to make them sound callous but that could include people who care about being able to put food on their family table.
- dominotw 6y ago> they won't be able to get another job? this doesn't apply almost any engineer working at facebook. Everyone was hiring before corona hit.
- chrisseaton 6y agoJust because you managed to get a job at Facebook in the past doesn't necessarily mean you can get a job anywhere else now. Tech interviews are very fickle. If people studied for a Facebook interview but don't have the time to do that now due to something like caring for someone then they could be in trouble.
- dominotw 6y agoI am not saying its guaranteed that they will find a job but tech unemployment was at all time low and even a mediocre engineer could find a job before corona pretty easily. If they are so unqualified to find a tech job in boom season then there were plenty of jobs outside tech too. I don't agree that most of these engineers would never be able to find another job if they quit fb. Maybe a tiny % of protestor, sure.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- edanm 6y ago> Facebook is, in general, an unethical company. And this has been known for a long time. If you didn't leave yet you won't leave over this either. You might be right. But you might be wrong. And the way you're framing it, it's either a) someone agrees with you, and has already left FB (meaning you were right), or b) someone has stayed at FB, therefore ethics is unimportant to them. Your dichotomy leaves no space for the idea that you might be wrong, or that the people who work at FB might not agree with you that it is unethical.
- koheripbal 6y agoNuance is such a rare commodity online these days. One telling sign of that is that few, if any, media sources that criticized Facebook's decision even bothered to publish the rationale. Think about that. Imagine perceiving yourself as journalist and intentionally not reporting the rationale of a point of view you disagree with. Once I heard Facebook's logic... I actually found it compelling. I think it's good we have social media companies that don't all agree with one another and act as a single entity. That would be scary.
- pdimitar 6y ago> Once I heard Facebook's logic... I actually found it compelling. I think it's good we have social media companies that don't all agree with one another and act as a single entity. That would be scary. I don't think any reasonable human being will argue with that. The problem are a lot of other practices of Facebook, like the lack of privacy and all sleazy corporate lingo and lobbyist pressure they utilize to never actually have to be a privacy-first company. And that's not even touching their experiment with free Facebook traffic in India, simply branded as "Internet" which, predictably, led many people to believe that Facebook is the internet. (And surprising no one, this was stopped only after a big wave of negative PR.)
- dominotw 6y agowhy would someone work at FB if they think its unethical, given almost all of those people can find another job pretty easily.
- badrabbit 6y agoThey'd take on less pay with growth opportunity elsewhere. Even with more pay! "Former Facebook engineer" helps with salary negotiation.
- dang 6y agoThis comment breaks the HN guidelines. Read it closely: it's completely generic other than a shallow response to a single word in the title ("facing"). It offers nothing but the exact same indignation that has been expressed thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands, of times already. It is, in fact, a perfect specimen of a generic comment, the kind we don't want here because it makes discussion repetitive and ragey: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20generic%20discussion&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que.... Therefore, please don't post like this to HN. Repetitive indignation is the opposite of curious conversation, and we seek the latter. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20curiosity%20repetition&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Disclaimey bits: 1. No, I'm not siding with Facebook or whatever; just with the intended spirit of HN. A comment like this breaks that spirit while seeming to be on topic. 2. I don't mean to pick on you personally. It sucks to be singled out and there is zero intention of shaming here. I'm just picking on this particular comment, about something that we basically all do at times.
- pdimitar 6y agoI guess it can be viewed that way. As much respect as I have for the moderation team on HN, this time I will respectfully disagree -- but I will improve the website by restraining myself from commenting on such hot semi-political discussions in the future. That would be best for everyone, I believe. --- EDIT: (after your edit): Rest assured, I am not taking it personally nor will I "attack" or press the matters further. I agree my comment wasn't well-spirited and was dismissive. It's just that sometimes I get tired of what I perceive as virtue signalling. But I agree that it's best to keep that opinion to myself and not add negativity to the forum. Thank you for bringing this perspective. I feel I actually needed it.