4 ms·
I've been to a Rio Tinto mine in the Pilbara and talked to some people there about a large doughnut shaped piece of work they were doing avoiding some aborigina
by roenxi 6y ago
I've been to a Rio Tinto mine in the Pilbara and talked to some people there about a large doughnut shaped piece of work they were doing avoiding some aboriginal site. They do more than just pay lip service to the idea of preserving this stuff.
I'm obviously a bit biased, but I don't expect 40,000 year old sites riddled with artefacts are actually that rare in the Pilbara. It isn't the sort of place where things change quickly. It is much more likely that this is one of the few they've found because it has a mine on top of it that was paying for an archaeologist to fly out and look.
As can be seen from the article - the aboriginals have no idea how old these sites are or what is in them when the mine approvals are negotiated. It makes sense, nobody is keeping a 4,000 year inventory of what practically amounts to buried junk of no value to anyone outside of one small tribe of people. Possibly not even them if I let my usual cynicism seep through.
It is easy to see Rio shouldn't have blown the cave up. It is appropriate to change the legislation. It is reasonable to pay the locals money. If the reporting is accurate that the site was historically rare then it is a loss to the historians. But it isn't international news or an international loss - if it hadn't been in the path of an active mine even the traditional owners wouldn't have known what it was, or cared about its historic significance.
- fit2rule 6y agoThis is utterly false. The original land owners definitely knew it was there and wanted Rio Tinto to protect it. They decided not to, and blew it up instead - the reason given was 'the explosives are already in place and its too dangerous to remove them'. Australians try to cover up their racism and heinous history with erasing the worlds oldest extant culture, but there is a rising tide that is moving against Australian complacency and wants them to put a higher priority on protecting human heritage over extracting mineral wealth. The original land owners of the Australian continent have a huge case for the return of their lands - these acts are only designed to make it harder for that to occur. Rio Tinto didn't even need to mine in that area - it was merely a convenient way to remove cultural heritage that would've made the original land owners case for native title stronger.
- ReticentVole 6y agoLatest evidence is showing that 'modern' Australian Aboriginals are only 4,000 years old: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2018/mar/14/most-australian-indigenous-languages-came-from-just-one-place-research-claims https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2018/mar/14/most-... Basically a second wave of colonisation from New Guinea that conquered/destroyed/assimilated the existing, older humans.
- fit2rule 6y ago>Latest evidence is showing that 'modern' Australian Aboriginals are only 4,000 years old: In your gleeful rush to discount humanities oldest extant civilisation, you seem to have made the fatal association: human language = human being The original land owners have been on the Australian continent for 60,000+ years, and they have maintained oral traditions that are over 40,000 years. No amount of blathering from racists is going to change that fact: its a matter of geological record.
- roenxi 6y ago> ...the explosives are already in place and its too dangerous to remove them... I hadn't heard that before, but it is actually a really good reason. It would be risking people's lives to try and defuse an active shot. Once the explosives are in the ground the shot was going to be fired one way or another. The aboriginals needed to, and a presume probably did, raise concerns before explosives were loaded.