15 ms·
Both 'Science' and 'Nature' have prestige, but people get confused because same domains are used for multiple journals. Open access journals like Advances or
by nabla9 6y ago
Both 'Science' and 'Nature' have prestige, but people get confused because same domains are used for multiple journals.
Open access journals like Advances or Nature Communications are not that bad, but Nature Scientific Reports is horrible.
It's very low impact journal with minimum review. It's intended to be place for grey literature where technical reports and scientific reports with no importance go. Unfortunately it has started to publish junk science too. Those pieces get posted into HN frequently. All that happens under nature.com that makes them seem legit.
- TheGallopedHigh 6y agoThis is not entirely true. It has a low impact, but is still reasonable. Nature Scientific Reports is still published by nature and does peer review. Granted the content is not on the level of nature itself. And junk science? Please provide links.
- nabla9 6y agoCrap, Courtesy of a Major Scientific Publisher https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2016/06/10/crap-courtesy-of-a-major-scientific-publisher https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2016/06/10/cr... More on Scientific Reports, And on Faked Papers https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2016/06/15/more-on-scientific-reports-and-on-faked-papers https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2016/06/15/mo... They are supposed to do very light peer review just trying to check if the article is technically sound. Apparently even that review process is broken.
- TheGallopedHigh 6y agoThanks for the links
- Certhas 6y agoTechnical soundness is not light peer review. It's the core of peer review. Everything else is editorializing and selling "importance". As a matter of fact you can get plenty of crap into the higher tier Science/Nature journals if you just tell a good enough story about importance. You can leave the real work to disentangle whether the story is true to others that can publish in lower impact topical journals. Generally speaking I believe Science and Nature, and the role they occupy in academia, are a major problem for science. They are huge contributors to overselling and hype driven research.