3 ms·
US companies aren't supposed to pay back debt (in Hertz's case, how did 2005 affect the balance sheet?) because that would be an inefficient use of capital. US
by 082349872349872 6y ago
US companies aren't supposed to pay back debt (in Hertz's case, how did 2005 affect the balance sheet?) because that would be an inefficient use of capital. US consumers are supposed to spend, not save, to stimulate the economy. US government is supposed to run a deficit, not a surplus.
And yet the aggregate US net worth is positive: about 5x its GDP. What sector have I missed?
- eru 6y agoDespite the snark, you are partially right. Having debt in your capital structure indefinitely is a perfectly fine decision to make. If there's a political will to favour equity over debt, the lawmakers should first remove the tax benefits of debt over equity. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_benefits_of_debt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_benefits_of_debt
- 082349872349872 6y agoThat wasn't snark. As an undergrad, I was taught that households should be positive, corporations negative, and public sector balanced on average, which would balance out. Either I'm missing a sector in the original analysis above (please tell me what it is), or the "common wisdoms" expressed there are false (and I should be more cynical), or...?
- ninkendo 6y agoYour tone is snarky despite your words being more or less correct. Correcting someone by saying you’re not using snark is just digging yourself a bit deeper I’m afraid.
- 082349872349872 6y agoThank you.
- eru 6y agoMostly agreed.
- teambayleaf 6y ago> Having debt in your capital structure indefinitely is a perfectly fine decision to make. We're hearing this argument a lot recently, but aren't we past that already in 1980s? As I recall, it was somewhat popular among companies to pile up leverages by buying a large potion of their own stocks. The reasoning was the same as today: it was supposed to benefit shareholders because a levereged BS has tax benefits. ... which subsequently resulted in those highly-levereged ("recap'ed") companies filing for bunkruptcy. So that hack was shunned by the time of 1990s. What does make this time different?
- eru 6y agoIf you have shares in enough companies, you don't particularly care if a few of them go bankrupt every once in a while, _if_ that trade-off makes you enough money on average. Mostly things haven't changed that much since the 1980s. The biggest difference is probably that individual investors are les likely to own specific shares, and more likely to own via an (index) fund. (That doesn't mean that any particular balance between equity and debt is the right one. Just that the occasional bankruptcy is not a nail in the coffin.)
- im3w1l-alt 6y agoDebt is how much (negative) money you have. Net worth also takes non-monetary assets into account. If you take out a loan to buy a house your debt increases but your net worth is constant.
- eru 6y agoAnd, of course, every debt is also an asset on someone else's balance sheet.
- 082349872349872 6y agoSo combined US assets are worth a great deal, enough so the declining equity position of (consumers+businesses+government) in those assets has not been significant. That makes sense. Thank you.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>So combined US assets are worth a great deal Aggregate US household net worth is now upwards of $100 trillion. That puts the $25 trillion in US National debt in perspective.