3 ms·
In this day and age with the power and ease of networks, is a personal introduction really discriminatory? or was it ever? Find out where he gets coffee in the
by pedalpete 16y ago
In this day and age with the power and ease of networks, is a personal introduction really discriminatory? or was it ever? Find out where he gets coffee in the morning, ask the barista for an introduction. It might not work, but it is an intro.
Also, is a woman any less likely to be linked in the network than a man? I'm not sure exactly what you're getting at saying this is discrimination.
If a personal introduction is discrimination, isn't location discriminatory as well?
- solsenNet 16y agoYeah, yeah, yeah, tell it to the EEOC. The applicant pool requirement upsets a lot of people (like how the hell can i control who applies?!), but it's the reality of modern HR. Deal with it, and be productive!
- Semiapies 16y agoThere's a reason it's called an "old boys' network". EDIT: We have many men at HN who are hypersensitive about any suggestion that sexism exists. It's disgusting, pathetic, and gives me one of those moments where I'm embarrassed that I come to this site. [This is more directed at the downvotes than you, pedalpete.] But this is reality - all hand-waving about how a good candidate will get an introduction aside, the advantage to getting introductions goes strongly to people who already know someone. In this industry, that's an almost entirely male crowd.
- jeremymims 16y agoAlmost all VC funding is done through introduction. That's the way this game works. It's one of the reasons so many people apply to YC. As a VC, you spend your days trying to figure out which teams will be successful in the future (even if they've never created a company before) and sometimes all you have is a trusted recommendation to work from. I can't think of a single VC who brags about how few people they know, how small their network is, and how they can't think outside the box to reach the person they don't know who could change the destiny of your company. What we all agree on is that it is a good thing for more women to be in tech. Here's an influential VC who is ACTIVELY trying to encourage more balance in his applicant pool and he gets attacked. Seriously, what's the endgame here? Discrimination exists. He's one of the good ones trying to make it better. The real discrimination is the stuff you don't see in a blog post. Not cool attacking someone trying to do the right thing.
- Semiapies 16y agoLet's unpack the things you say here, starting from the end: "Not cool attacking someone trying to do the right thing" Of course, the only people I actually attack are people here on HN who are very much hostile to trying to do the right thing. "Here's an influential VC who is ACTIVELY trying to encourage more balance in his applicant pool and he gets attacked" I haven't attacked him, nor do I see anyone else in this thread attacking him. His chosen methodology got criticized. Is someone trying to do something right immune from criticism? No. Now, is he trying to do something right in the first place? Perhaps. He does seem to be uneasy at a male-dominated pool of responses. However, his response to seeing this pattern is to assume that this represents a failure on the part of some unknown women who did not respond. That's a remarkable and dubious attitude to strike; taken most charitably, it's a startlingly naive one. "sometimes all you have is a trusted recommendation to work from" The cold fact is that someone not within a network or who cannot easily enter that network is disadvantaged by this requirement. In this case, it's a strongly majority-male network that shows quite a bit of discomfort and sometimes outright hostility towards women trying to enter it. So, I will say to you: 1) Blaming women for the fact that you've set up filters that are biased against them? Uncool on the VC's part. 2) Jumping on someone pointing out those biased filters? Uncool on your part.
- jeremymims 16y agoSigh. You do know that almost all of us are on your side, right? Do you have any idea how often the topic of the difficulty of hiring women comes up when I talk to fellow entrepreneurs (male and female)? Personally, I've tried recruiting six talented female programmers to apply to Y Combinator. None have. Two of them took jobs at Goldman Sachs. One of them was one of the most talented programmers I've ever met. If you want to change the game, you've got to get in it. The fact of the matter is that VC is an institution that's incredibly biased against anyone who doesn't have connections. The year before I went through Y Combinator, I emailed 30 VCs our pitch deck. Two responded. The day after demo day, we had offers for meetings with half. Today, I have no trouble setting up meetings. VCs simply don't have time to review every company that might come their way. So they use intros and recommendations as short cuts. This isn't actually a male or female issue. Very few people have the requisite connections to break into this group. Isolating it to a female issue alone probably minimizes the seriousness of the problem. That's why I love when a VC like Bryce reaches out and gives people a way to even get in the door without having said connections. This is a huge improvement for those willing to take advantage of it. Seriously, I'm open to suggestions. What solutions do you have that would get more women into the game? We both agree that it would be a good thing.
- pedalpete 16y agoIf you're going to downvote me, fine, but please explain how you feel a personal introduction is discrimination, if that is what is being debated.
- ojbyrne 16y agoDiscrimination basically means you're most likely to be friends/look more favorably on people who are similar to you in age, gender, race, or religion. Even if someone from outside those groups manages to force themselves into your presence like you describe, you're going to look less favorably on them just because they forced their way into your presence, and even if one person does pass on the introduction, others won't. Meaning that statistically, if you're not from the same group as the person giving the personal introduction, you're less likely to be interviewed for the job.
- pedalpete 16y agoThanks for the clear response, though I disagree on a few points. 1)your definition of discrimination I think is twisted to fit this case. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&defl=en&q=define:discrimination&sa=X&ei=hYyCTYv9O4P0tgPxm6nlAQ&ved=0CCMQkAE http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&defl=en&... . 2)as jeremymims points alludes, the ability to network is a key part of the job requirements, therefore, the ability for one to show that the challenges they faced in reaching through their network or the creativity in getting an introduction could be favorable in getting hired.
- LilValleyBigEgo 16y ago> Find out where he gets coffee in the morning, ask the barista for an introduction. Uh that's stalking.
- Semiapies 16y agoAnd not the sort of introduction they're looking for - it's an extremely bogus example.