5 ms·
How many months of 110% income would it take for, say, the middle 80% of US households to have accumulated 6 months worth of savings?
by 082349872349872 6y ago
How many months of 110% income would it take for, say, the middle 80% of US households to have accumulated 6 months worth of savings?
- 101404 6y agoThat probably depends on the number of iPhones and cars they buy in that period.
- bsder 6y ago1) A cell phone is an absolute necessity nowadays. Sorry. Remember the Dot Com bust? People were becoming homeless but absolutely maintained their cell phone because it was the single thing that they had to have to get back out of being homeless. And that was 2001! Cell phones have just gotten more important since then. This is in top of the fact that a cell phone nowadays may be the only computer someone has access to. 2) I know of very few poor people who buy new cars. However, most of them would be better off if they did. Quite often, the amount of money they have to pour into an old car to keep it running exceeds the amount of money to actually purchase a new car. However, no one will give them the loan required to do so.
- yayadarsh 6y agoThis is borderline antagonistic. Do you think that the majority of lower-income people who do not have large savings are in this situation due to disproportionately high discretionary spending?
- burlesona 6y agoThe post you replied to was a little snarky, but there is some debate here, a lot of which boils down to financial options and “financial literacy.” For example: > Poor people do have surplus money to save, find Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) economists Abhijit Banerjee and Esther Duflo. Even people living on less than $1 per day spend money on many nonessential items such as alcohol, tobacco, and televisions.2 And when poor people increase their earnings, they spend only two-thirds of their windfall on food. These findings suggest that poor people are not just living hand to mouth; they do have funds to save. So the question is, what financial products could help the poor lay away some of those funds for the future? Source: http://www.pensiondevelopment.org/documenten/Helping%20the%20Poor%20Save%20More%20-%20Karlan.pdf http://www.pensiondevelopment.org/documenten/Helping%20the%2...
- dathinab 6y ago> such as alcohol, tobacco, and televisions Seems to be a very misguided study. If you live a supper shitty live then you will try to escape from it and if there is no way to do so practically doing so mentally is a way. Like by drinking, smoking and watching TV. Also drinking and smoking are drugs. Stopping taking them is hard. Especially if they make you feel like your live became barley bearable when taking them. I'm not saying that this doesn't mean that thinks would be better if different but the way you post it and the quote kinda imply that it's fully their own fault for not being more clever. It's like saying "it's fully your own fault that you can't stop the addiction you have without proper help and which is one of the view thinks in your live which don't total suck". I.e. it's quite detached from the reality of how poverty, addiction and similar work. Also just to clarify I do not mean addiction where you take super high amounts all the time. I mean the more common wide spread forms of addiction where you frequently take smallish amounts of it and just can't stop doing it. I also was somewhat imprecise as I mixed up that and escapeism in a wishi washi way.
- thephyber 6y ago> I mean the more common wide spread forms of addiction I think you are describing compulsion. "Addiction" is generally reserved for actions which have a detrimental effect on everyday living (like the inability to hold a job, keep friends, or stay out of jail).
- dougmwne 6y agoYou're right, and yet... We live in a consumer society. The messages pulling us to buy things are pervasive and highly effective. Our self-worth has been successful tied to those cars and iPhones by the companies who sell them. It's a real phenomenon that when a low income person gets a windfall they might buy a TV. But there are a number of totally legitimate reasons for that. Besides the marketing, money has a totally different meaning when you are low income. It's not some safety blanket you can store up for later. It's more like evaporating pools of water on a hot day. It's going to go somewhere, and soon. It's pretty rational to have it go towards something you know you or your family will enjoy instead of the next bill collector. The bill collectors will never be satisfied anyway.
- dathinab 6y agoYou know buying a use second hand iPhone can be a better monetary investment then a new android phone when you get convinced by all the Apple marketing about superior build quality. (Because Apples definition of that tend to not include physical robustness). Also if buying a car allows you to save hours every day you can then use to work more and earn it back pretty fast (or take care of you kids or whatever) then this might be quite reasonable.
- triceratops 6y agoIf marketing works in convincing people to buy more stuff than they need, then it's directly responsible for poor people making unwise financial decisions. If it doesn't convince people to buy more than they would done have anyway, then it doesn't actually work. This means the marketing, advertising, PR and communications industries can be completely eliminated. Right? So which is it? (FWIW, I think it's the first).
- dang 6y agoWould you please stop posting flamebait and/or unsubstantive comments to HN? You've unfortunately been doing it repeatedly. We have to ban that sort of account, in the hope of preventing this site from destroying itself. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sesuximo 6y agoHard to say since ppl are also spending less right now
- dathinab 6y agoLong. Because before they can start saving basic needs (home, food, health i.e. mediciens) need to be satisfied and especially the lower percentages might not be able to do so every month with what they earn. Especially health cost might stack up (e.g. a delayed dentist visit because it can't be afforded) and some get more then linearly more expensive when stacked up (small problem with tooth escalated, interests etc.). So it's not absurd to assume that in the lower percentages of the population getting 110% income will get them at best 10% of a income savings and likely only after some month already passed. With that they would need 60!! month to build up that savings. Now I can't say where the this stops, is it the lower 5%,10%,20%,30%,40% no idea. But it's gradual. Also the gap between poor and rich has become quite absurd in the US, so this can make make people much less wealthy then you might think end up in the middle 80%.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoWhy not just create a simplified welfare state ? Claim benefits for up to six months no questions asked.
- thephyber 6y ago> Why not Because US policy makers don't trust citizens. They demand that all benefits be means-tested and the onus is on the recipient to prove. Also, one of the major parties (the one that controls the Senate and the Executive Branch) wants to dismantle "the welfare state". I don't think COVID changed that part of the platform. Personally, I would love for policy makers to listen to Code For America leadership and change policy to make it stupid simple to hook into employer data to know when a person is layed off and message them with SMS or a Push Notification that they are already registered for {unemployment, MedicAid, food assistance}, but the friction for those systems is what one (or both) party wants, so I'm not holding my breath.
- dahart 6y agoHere’s a hand-wavy estimate. Last year, the personal savings rate in the US was about 8%, so at that rate it would normally take 12.5 years to accumulate 1 year’s income worth of savings, or 6.25 years to save 6 months. If you earned 10% more and saved all of it, and didn’t change anything else about your spending or saving, then your new savings rate would be 16.3%, which would mean it’d take a little over 3 years to save for 6 months. If you previously weren’t saving anything, but you started saving all the extra income from a 10% raise, then your savings rate would be ~9% and it’d take you 5.5 years to save 6 months’ worth of income.