3 ms·
Some time back, when contact tracing was first being discussed, I mentioned that State level actors would love the data being generated by these programs. Seve
by falcolas 6y ago
Some time back, when contact tracing was first being discussed, I mentioned that State level actors would love the data being generated by these programs.
Several people disagreed, either commenting that they already have this capability, or that they have no reason to use it.
And here we are today. The right to assemble falling victim to a tragedy of the commons, justifying greater erosion of our rights.
- thephyber 6y agoGet off your high horse. They did already have an equivalent technology. > either commenting that they already have this capability DHS was using drones to track protesters in Minnesota. Most large cities already contract with a private company that flies a Cessna in circles over the city taking high resolution pictures. Odds are better than not that there were Stingrays in the area of the protest and that there are private contractors tracking social media updates and passing the data long to the local Fusion Centers. Yes, we should be concerned about any new tool, but there is a risk to any technology that it will be used against us. The more important question is: is the "juice worth the squeeze"?
- serf 6y ago>Get off your high horse. They aren't gloating, they are lamenting that no one seems to care about their opinion. I feel exactly the same way with regards to computer privacy and militaristic authority creep. This cycle gets really de-motivating: 1) New technology X is developed, 2) Some warn while others celebrate 3) Technology is used a single time for nefarious/unbounded reasons above and beyond the original described use. 4) Some think the new uses are obvious and warranted, Some reel from the lack of over-sight and spread of X 5) Novel use of technology beyond original described use becomes common-place and standard. 6) Normalization of non-standard use diminishes or mutes opinion of those originally concerned all-together. We've seen this cycle over and over again. Stingrays, drones, less-than-lethal weaponry, armed and armored military vehicles, sonic weaponry, social media doxxing. Where is the line drawn on equipment and tactics used in-state? Lethality? LTL weapons are shown time and time again to be anything but non-lethal. Total loss of privacy? ARGUS-derived drones can see pedestrians with exacting details, and we can track the rest with the ELINT equipment on the same bird. >Yes, we should be concerned about any new tool, but there is a risk to any technology that it will be used against us. Here's the rub : these technologies are being showcased and purposed for use against civilians. There is no longer a waiting period for 'juice worth the squeeze' : we now know the juice from these fruits-of-labor is poison for most civvies, and the measured goal is now 'subduing power' or 'crowd dispersal' There is an industry formed around these types of systems, and they are all racing each other for the newest and greatest devices for 'in-home peace keeping'. There is no situation in which a citizen of the US can be for anti-protest specialized weaponry and equipment and expect the same level of power with regards to protests and civil disobedience themselves. And some wonder, with every piece of legislation that increases authority over-reach or budget: 'well, if they don't seem to care about the lethality of LTL weaponry -- when are these groups going to pull out the real weaponry?'. How far are we away from those surveillance drones up high carrying hellfire air-to-ground systems 'to keep the peace'? How far are we from those in authority choosing to use such systems, even as a strong-arm maneuver? How far are we from being OK as a society with some being blown to smithereens because of property destruction and social outrage? Some of us may have different views on the distance from where we are now to the future I painted in the previous paragraph, but a few of us, myself included, are pretty worried that may be closer than some of us realize. >They did already have an equivalent technology. Equivalency comparisons are of no use. More similar technologies that have overlapping functionality allow for a broader range of choices when peacekeepers ask for authority in using such equipment. If there are 5 products that have a similar functionality, that's in essence five different attempts that can be made by law-makers to woo local authorities and judges into cooperation with said technology.
- DennisAleynikov 6y agonobody ever listens unless its politically convenient. contact tracing was never going to be left 'only for medical purposes'
- thephyber 6y ago> contact tracing was never going to be left 'only for medical purposes That's all fine and well to speculate, but where is the evidence that it's true?