3 ms·
I'm not sure about this. Maybe qualified immunity should be reduced in scope, but I don't know about doing away with it. A police officer that tasers a violent
by ineedasername 6y ago
I'm not sure about this. Maybe qualified immunity should be reduced in scope, but I don't know about doing away with it. A police officer that tasers a violent suspect should be immune from prosecution if that suspect falls and hits their head, or has a heart attack. I don't see a way that police could do their jobs without some version of qualified immunity.
I think that at least part of solution lies in better training on use of force, massively increase training on deescalation techniques, better psychological screening and continuous followups, full-time body cams that don't turn off and are tamper resistant with appropriate logging of metadata to detect misuse-- to the extent that if a complaint is made against an officer and the camera is mysteriously not functional, the disciplinary burden should be moved to favor the complaint. And probably other things too-- this is not meant to be an exhaustive list of reforms.
- Simulacra 6y agoI think that might be the logical end goal: Remove police from street policing, and let communities police themselves.
- thephyber 6y ago> let communities police themselves This happened in the wild west and didn't work out so well.
- vulcan01 6y agoAt least, we should reinstate requirements that police should come from their own communities...
- thephyber 6y agoThat might be an improvement in many places, but it would probably create problems for San Francisco and San Jose, where cost of living is largely unsustainable for people who make starting police salaries unless they lucked into a family house. We sometimes forget that officers get to choose where they want to work and will migrate to the best place for them. The ratio between housing costs and salary (among other quality of life factors) is pretty important to lots of officers and we may end up lowering the quality of officers by only restricting the pool of eligible employees.
- thephyber 6y agoI have a few small complaints with your details, but generally I'm similarly wary of flipping a switch on qualified immunity without knowing the unintended consequences. I would like to hear from countries which do not have such protections of their LEOs.