4 ms·
YouTube comments. The upvote/downvote system appears to be near-useless as it doesn't influence ranking like you think it would (it is a factor, but is by far
by Nextgrid 6y ago
YouTube comments.
The upvote/downvote system appears to be near-useless as it doesn't influence ranking like you think it would (it is a factor, but is by far not the only one), ranking appears to be semi-random and only encourages shitposting.
There is also a lack of moderation regarding said shitposting. They clearly have the infrastructure to (wrongly) ban comments at scale like those critical of China, so why can't they use it for good and ban "FIRST!!!" instead?
Old comments were not imported properly. Older videos have comments with the old reply system (@username) but without being linked to the comment it replied to despite back in the day the "@username" bits being clickable so they clearly have (had?) the data to tie the comments together but couldn't be bothered doing their job properly.
A single wrong click will take you to another page and when you go back you lose your scroll position and you can no longer find the comment you were looking at. The infinite scroll/"load more" system doesn't help with that either.
Reddit (and its clones) solved all these problems just fine (at least on the old UI), there is no reason for YouTube not to be able to do the same.