6 ms·
This is a... tremendously odd book review, since it's barely about Forrester's book at all, and also her book came out way back last September. Also it's funny
by crazygringo 6y ago
This is a... tremendously odd book review, since it's barely about Forrester's book at all, and also her book came out way back last September. Also it's funny (but very cool) to see it here on HN, since unless you're a political philosopher you've probably never even heard of Rawls.
But I have read both much of Rawls as well as Forrester's book, and hopefully I can distill what it's all about here for anyone curious.
In a nutshell, Rawls revived the long-since-discredited notion of the social contract (society is an agreement between people for the common good), and gave a deeply intellectual justification for both liberty, as well as extensive (although not unlimited) redistribution -- thus a "liberal" middle way between pure communism and pure capitalism.
He presented this in a kind of universal way, and thus gave a kind of intellectual respectability to liberal democracy that provides health care, social services, arguably a basic income, and so on, putting that on par with the equal intellectual respectability that free market liberalism had. So liberals who supported social programs weren't just wishful thinkers or muddy-headed -- they had just as much intellectual rigor as market conservatives. This was huge.
But the "universal" aspect of his philosophy always seemed rather suspect. Forrester's book is a wonderful history of how his ideas evolved as products of the time and specific national/international historic circumstances, and were often "out of date" by the time they were published, and therefore there's nothing "universal" about them, and that the veneration given to his ideas may be preventing us from developing even better ones.
But tying any of this to Trump or Dershowitz is total nonsense/clickbait.
- lordgrenville 6y ago> unless you're a political philosopher you've probably never even heard of Rawls Rawls is one of the most famous philosophers of the 20th century. Almost any Ethics 101 course (a requisite in a wide range of fields) will touch on his work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Glyptodon 6y agoI've always thought it sort of odd that a living condition floor isn't taken as a functional requirement for systems of self government where by definition the voting population needs enough leasure time to be informed and participating. On the other hand I've never been particularly surprised by self interested actors being more than happy to have many citizens subsisting at a level that precludes such functional participation.