3 ms·
Maybe it is necessary to read the book that the article is ostensibly built around. I hope so, because the article seems to do little to offer an argument for w
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
Maybe it is necessary to read the book that the article is ostensibly built around. I hope so, because the article seems to do little to offer an argument for why Rawls attempt at a universal notion of "right" is somehow now seen as a mistake. It closes with this claim:
"In reminding us that even political philosophers who claim to speak outside any particular time or place are, in fact, the product of a particular time and place, Forrester undoes the pretension to timelessness that Rawls claimed, at least for a time."
At best, there's some sort of argument that "a small group of influential, affluent, white, mostly male analytical political philosophers" are now seen less favorably as people, or at least as "influencers". Fair enough, and almost certainly true, but what does this have to say about Rawls ideas themselves?
The closest it comes is by mentioning Haraway's "god trick" critique, which is not fleshed out nor given any real standing. Haraway's critiques and ideas are not stupid, but they stand in absolute opposition to Rawls (and others of his "kind") in asserting that there really can be no universal knowledge (because it is all situated). This isn't really a critique of Rawls, it's just a denial that the entire project of western philosophy can ever be well-conceived. That might be true, but if so it takes down much, much more than just Rawls and his contemporaries.
If I had to TLDR the article, I'd say "philosopher dude from 70s was once super popular, now faces criticisms from others who never agreed with him."
- crazygringo 6y agoIn a nutshell, Rawls assumes that a kind of "individualist" constitution-based political liberalism is the right answer. I'd say there have been three main critiques of this that have arisen in the past 30 years: 1) That people aren't atomistic individuals, but rather embedded in groups, societies and identities, and so a theory of politics needs to consider the importance of groups as well as individuals, that a group is more than the sum of its members (multiculturalism) 2) That Rawls' focus on constitutionalism basically gives way too much weight to law made by constitutional conventions and interpreted by a supreme court, with normal political processes of voting, representation, and lawmaking seen as relatively unimportant (rights talk, perilously antidemocratic/antipolitical) 3) That liberalism has been having a really hard time lately dealing with populism, immigration, making good political decisions generally, and so on, precisely because it ignores feelings about groups, and that majoritarian democracy seems to be resulting in worse and worse policies lately. So empirically, people are worried that we need some improvements (crisis of liberalism)
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThanks for that. Vastly more informative than the original article.
- woodruffw 6y agoI agree with the broad strokes of these critiques, with one exception: Rawls treats individuals as atomistic in terms of a universal ethic (broadly in line with Kant and deriving the law for oneself), but is explicit about the role and value of intersubjectivity in the process of reflective equilibrium. In other words: Rawls does indeed acknowledge the role of groups and societies in his political theory, and is even prescriptive about their role in moral education (per Piaget). I think it's a interpretative mistake in contemporary analyses of him to ignore that he at least attempts to address this.
- mistermann 6y ago> That liberalism has been having a really hard time lately dealing with populism, immigration, making good political decisions generally, and so on, precisely because it ignores feelings about groups... Liberalism, or more accurately the "public mainstream conversation about reality", does indeed ignore feelings about groups, but this is but one thing it ignores, there are numerous other things that we routinely and enthusiastically ignore. There is a very strong culture of desire to ignore observable evidence (facts/possibilities/counterfactuals, ideas, events, etc), and this culture can be observed always and everywhere (in varying degrees, of course), from science/medicine to mainstream media to public forums. Of course, it's not possible or pragmatic to discuss everything in full resolution, but there's absolutely no need to deny the existence of the complexity of reality.
- 363728226 6y agoCan you expand on your definition of liberalism a little? It seems like you're defining liberalism by how the word is used collquially in the public context but I took the parent to mean liberalism as in the academic concept realated to philosophy, political science, and international relations theory.
- _bxg1 6y agoI think there's a trap whenever you try and pursue an unbiased, universal perspective or theory or truth (and not just in this one space): it can be really easy to lose sight of your own biases and flaws, which always exist, and always impact your perspective. None of us can claim to be fully rational and removed, so whenever we try and venture into the realm of universal truth, we must always keep our own biases front and center and account for them as best we can. That isn't to say we shouldn't pursue those truths, but I think the point being made is that Rawl's framework encouraged people to sweep their own biases under a rug, which is a dangerous thing to do.