2 ms·
For those unfamiliar with Rawls: Dershowitz's application of the veil of ignorance is astoundingly facile. As the article correctly observes, the VoI is not th
by woodruffw 6y ago
For those unfamiliar with Rawls: Dershowitz's application of the veil of ignorance is astoundingly facile.
As the article correctly observes, the VoI is not the Golden Rule: it does not ask us how we how we would feel if the thing we advocate were done to us, but whether we would accept a course of action or policy were we to know nothing about ourselves.
Applied correctly, the VoI encourages everybody to be against political corruption, regardless of political orientation. But this runs contrary to Dershowitz's own political goals, and it's easier to co-opt your dead academic colleague's system than it is to excuse criminality from first principles.