2 ms·
Claiming a proof that 1+1=1 is right down there with claiming the Earth is 6,000 years old. This argument has already been debunked. Raising these issues semes
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Claiming a proof that 1+1=1 is right down there with claiming the Earth is 6,000 years old. This argument has already been debunked.
Raising these issues semester after semester, without presenting some startling evidence to re-open the case is a lot like a convicted killer asking for a new trial without finding new evidence or errors.
At a certain point you turn to the 1+1=1 crowd and say, "your proof is wrong, and this has been conclusively demonstrated. It does not need to be heard again."
We passed that point over a hundred years ago. Thus, the argument that 1+1=1 has been heard, and does not need to be a homework assignment in any future "Intro to Proofs" classes.
See, this is the flaw in your argument. The conversation here is about exposing students to these arguments as an intellectual exercise. The relevant question to ask is not "can someone debunk holocaust deniers/debunk the proof that 1+1=1?". The relevant question is "can this class of students debunk holocaust deniers/spot the flaw in the proof that 1+1=1?"
(Details on 1+1=1. http://mathforum.org/library/drmath/view/57110.html http://mathforum.org/library/drmath/view/57110.html )
- Semiapies 16y agoI don't get the downvoting - this is pretty much the point of TFA, and it's valuable. Ideas like these gain support in the first place because people don't have the critical mindset to see what's wrong with them.