5 ms·
> it seems to me to mean that Google's business reviews are unreliable information Of course they are - any information at this scale is best-effort and should
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> it seems to me to mean that Google's business reviews are unreliable information
Of course they are - any information at this scale is best-effort and should be treated as just a general indication and possibly erroneous.
- leereeves 6y agoEven the Yellow Pages were able to manage information at this scale more accurately. Google's culture favors minimum effort, not best effort.
- MattGaiser 6y agoI don't see how that would be possible for the simple reason that the Yellow Pages couldn't be updated.
- onemoresoop 6y agoBut it didnt need to be updated too much since the data had integrity in the first place. Sure, updates are needed since ... changes in the real world so there were yearly issues for that. Regardless, we live in a time with more possibilities, we can do updates but why loose corectness? With Google it’s not just an isolated case
- exiled13 6y agoExactly, Google prefers to automate this sort of thing. Youtube has similar problems and it's equally as impossible to reach a human being to get the problem sorted out.
- user5994461 6y agoThe local yellow pages made the business pay about €1000 to be listed (could be quite a bit more depending on the category). Google may have numerous issues but it doesn't require you to pay one month of income.
- leereeves 6y agoIs it even possible for a business to pay Google for better service? It seems like they just can't be bothered to fix the info, not even for €1000.
- dhosek 6y agoOnce upon a time I had a business phone line. It came with a free Yellow Pages listing in the category of my choice. If I wanted a display ad it was more, but the listing itself was included in the slightly higher price I paid for having a business line instead of a home line.
- ooobit2 6y agoI don't know about minimum effort. Some of Google's product teams have focused their best work on limitations that don't make sense. An example: It takes a lot of work to build an entire app ecosystem for Android Auto, only to disable the whole f'n thing if the end user disables Google Voice.
- rectang 6y ago> Of course they are That's facile. The system is designed so that in the aggregate, users will not treat this review information as unreliable. It doesn't matter that a tiny percentage of users have the wherewithal to assess it properly.
- orestarod 6y agoThe users will not treat the review information as unreliable, you say. But that is no indication of the information's actual reliability, is it? Like saying an unreliable politician is seen as reliable by the people. Yeah, he fooled the voters. Yeah, he's still unreliable in truth.
- monadic2 6y agoThey should put up a disclaimer “pay us or we’ll sink your business”
- monadic2 6y agoI’m right folks! This is glorified blackmail.